Comments by "Elaine" (@Petal4822) on "Corey Gil-Shuster" channel.

  1. Palestine never belonged to the Palestinians. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires, never an independent country. That is why there was never a King of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. That would be like India demanding Pakistan back.Lol
    12
  2. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires. It was never Palestinian land. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. for both the Jews and the Arabs in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted to eradicate Israel. In 1947 India lost land to Pakistan in the two state Partition of India into two separate countries. India is not demanding Pakistan back. Germany lost land to Poland after WW2 never heard of the Germans demanding their land back from Poland. In WW2 more civilians lost their lives in Germany than in Britain …that didn’t make Germany right. Palestinians will have to stop playing victim. Left alone Israel is no threat.
    11
  3. There is no land of Palestine unless they are setting up a theme park
    10
  4. Palestine never belonged to the Palestinians. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires, never an independent country. That is why there was never a King of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. That would be like India demanding Pakistan back.Lol
    9
  5. India is not demanding Pakistan back. Pakistan took land from India. During the 1947 two state Partition of India. Germany lost land to Poland after WW2 … Germany is not demanding it back and accusing Poland of stealing their land. The reason innocent civilians get killed is because the Palestinians attack Israel. There were many more civilians in Germany that got killed in WW2 than British civilians… but that didn’t make Germany right. Palestine - was a region occupied by other Empires all throughout history. The Palestinians never owned it … they lived there with the Jews and Arabs. In 1947 The Arabs rejected the chance to have their own country by the UN because they wanted to eradicate Israel. Israel was legally created by the UN 1947 Resolution. The Palestinians should stop playing victim. Left alone Israel is no threat and have turned a desert into an Israeli superstate.
    8
  6. Following the UN vote in 1947, a legal partition was drawn up to allow- * A Jewish State covering 56.47% of Mandatory Palestine * An Arab State covering 43.53% of Mandatory Palestine. * The Israelis agreed to this two state Partition… the Palestinians rejected it because they wanted to wipe out Israel rather than have their own independent state. * Note : The Palestinians rejected their own Independent state. * In 1948, 800,000 Jews were attacked, by the Arabs and forced out of their homes and expelled from Arab countries and found refuge in Israel. The Arab made up a Resolution called ‘Khartoum Resolution’ known as The Three No's"; No peace with Israel, No negotiation with Israel, No recognition of Israel. You can’t compare Holocaust survivors with no where to go to Palestinians Arabs who had choices of 22 Arab nations. Jordan is 80% Palestinian and is a Palestinian state and Gaza makes up the second state. To carve another Arab state out of the only Jewish state is a crime. Left alone Israel Is no threat. The Palestinians Arabs refused to have their stare when offered it. It’s not about land to them it’s about wiping out Israel.
    7
  7. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires. That is why there was never a Land of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. Arabs were greedy. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. Is it ok for India to demand Pakistan back. Lol 😂
    7
  8. For some reason they forgot to mention who started the 1948 war and the invasion of Arab armies designed to wipe out Israel.
    6
  9. Read the Balfour Declaration
    6
  10. Palestine was never a sovereign country. It was a British Mandated Territory ... The Balfour Declaration..was the declaration ...enabling Israel to be a Jewish Homeland. The Turks had Palestine for 600 years before the British. So we should hand it back to the Turks not the Palestinians.
    5
  11. Palestinians standards are designed to wipe out Israel.
    5
  12. Palestine was offered their own independent country and rejected the two state partition in 1947 because they wanted to destroy Israel instead.
    4
  13. Unless you have Ancient Turkish Artefact or Ancient Ownership Scrolls going back 3,000 years ..you Arabs have no land to claim, Palestine NEVER existed. The Israelis have strong links to the land, underground temples and ancient artefact going back four thousand years.
    4
  14. You cannot compare Holocaust survivors that had no place to go … with Palestinian Arab refugees that had choices. Palestine wasn’t a country it didn’t exist. That is why the U.N voted on the 2 state partition plan for Palestine in 1947. The Jews signed, the Arabs rejected the 2 state partition. The Palestinian Arabs would rather destroy Israel than have their own independent state. The Khartoum Resolution known as "The Three No's" — No peace with Israel, No recognition of Israel, No negotiations with Israel. Was the Doctrine of the Palestinian Arabs. The Palestinian Arabs that fled to neighbouring Jordan in the 1948 Arab / Israeli war are still in refugee camps to this day. It’s time for the UN to start putting pressure on the Arab nations to recognise the Palestinian refugees as THEIR citizens by giving them ‘the right to return’…. to live-work in Arab nations. It’s been 70 years of misery for the Palestinian Arab refugees. It’s time to stop using them as political pawns and let them live in peace .
    4
  15. The Palestinian Arab woman with the black scarf made a good point about the WestBank — Is it the occupiers fault if there is ‘garbage’ on the street? She is saying it’s the Palestinian Arab corrupt leaders that are creating the Garbage. Not the Israelis.
    4
  16. I can’t believe Israel managed to get control of ‘Jerusalem ‘ when the Crusaders tried for centuries to get control of Jerusalem and failed. What an achievement !!!
    4
  17.  @jdb5961  Why was Palestine not a sovereign nation under the Ottoman Empire ? Just saying ?
    4
  18. Did you get a part in the movie "Ali Baba and the forty thieves"
    4
  19. Palestine was never a sovereign country. It was a British Mandated Territory ... The Balfour Declaration..was the declaration ...enabling Israel to be a Jewish Homeland. The Turks had Palestine for 600 years before the British. So we should hand it back to the Turks not the Palestinians.
    3
  20.  @MK..1558  Ancient Turkish Artefact or scrolls of title records going back 3,000 years are enough to prove it’s your house.
    3
  21.  @randomdude8493  Nothing will change the fact that Judea, Samaria and East Jerusalem are part of Israel. No one is going to force Israel out. The Arabs have tried in previous wars against Israel and failed miserably. Maybe the neighboring Arab countries could do more to help the Palestinians. They could try and change Gaza into a paradise state, rather than leaving it to the fate of Ham ass. Ham ass seem more interested in harming Israel than the well being of their people. The Palestinians deserve a better life. Egypt should re-open its border with Gaza., that would be a start.
    3
  22.  @randomdude8493  Why don’t the oil rich Arab nations build them homes and give them refuge. In 1948 over 800,000 Jews were attacked, forced out of their owned homes and expelled from Arab Nations. All because they were Jewish. Israel gave them refuge and looked after them. Why can’t the Arabs look after their own. Just saying.
    3
  23. India is not demanding Pakistan back. Pakistan took land from India. During the 1947 two state Partition of India. Germany lost land to Poland after WW2 … Germany is not demanding it back and accusing Poland of stealing their land. The reason innocent civilians get killed is because the Palestinians attack Israel. There were many more civilians in Germany that got killed in WW2 than British civilians… but that didn’t make Germany right. Palestine - was a region occupied by other Empires all throughout history. The Palestinians never owned it … they lived there with the Jews and Arabs. In 1947 The Arabs rejected the chance to have their own country by the UN because they wanted to eradicate Israel. Israel was legally created by the UN 1947 Resolution. The Palestinians should stop playing victim. Left alone Israel is no threat and have turned a desert into an Israeli superstate.
    3
  24. The Palestinian Arab woman with the black scarf made a good point about the WestBank — Is it the occupiers fault if there is ‘garbage’ on the street? She is saying it’s the Palestinian Arab corrupt leaders that are creating the Garbage. Not the Israelis.
    3
  25. Christian Evangelists believe that the return of the Jews to the Holy Land and the establishment of the state of Israel in 1948 were in accordance with Bible prophecy. 80 million US. Christian Evangelists support Israel.
    3
  26. Palestine was never a sovereign country. It was a British Mandated Territory ... The Balfour Declaration..was the declaration ...enabling Israel to be a Jewish Homeland. The Turks had Palestine for 600 years before the British. So we should hand it back to the Turks not the Palestinians.
    3
  27. The refusal by the Arabs to accept the two state partition in 1947 showed that they were not interested in establishing their own state if it meant allowing the existence of a Jewish state.
    3
  28. Unless you have Ancient Turkish Artefact or Ancient Ownership Scrolls going back 3,000 years ..you Arabs have no land to claim, Palestine NEVER existed. The Israelis have strong links to the land, underground temples and ancient artefact going back four thousand years.
    3
  29.  @Mpharm17  Ham Ass who own Gaza and the Palestinian people are trying to wipe out Israel. Israel’s very Existence is being threatened. No amount of ranting will change that fact. Judea, Samaria and East Jerusalem are part of Israel. Who is going to force them out …no one.
    3
  30.  @Mpharm17  When the Arabs declared war on Israel in 1967, the Arabs lost their right to that land. Israel gave the Arabs back Gaza as a token of peace. Then the Arabs turned it into a t*rrorist state, shooting rockets at Israeli civilians. Instead of investing in the well-being of its own citizens. Now the Arabs are wanting more land to attack Israel. Ham ass hides behind civilians to shoot rockets, 25% of their rockets dropped back and exploded inside Gaza and injured their own people. Ham ass cheats with the votes to stay in power and continues to oppress its people.
    3
  31. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires. It was never Palestinian land. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. for both the Jews and the Arabs in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted to eradicate Israel. In 1947 India lost land to Pakistan in the two state Partition of India into two separate countries. India is not demanding Pakistan back. Germany lost land to Poland after WW2 never heard of the Germans demanding their land back from Poland. In WW2 more civilians lost their lives in Germany than in Britain …that didn’t make Germany right. Palestinians will have to stop playing victim. Left alone Israel is no threat.
    3
  32. India is not demanding Pakistan back. Pakistan took land from India. During the 1947 two state Partition of India. Germany lost land to Poland after WW2 … Germany is not demanding it back and accusing Poland of stealing their land. The reason innocent civilians get killed is because the Palestinians attack Israel. There were many more civilians in Germany that got killed in WW2 than British civilians… but that didn’t make Germany right. Palestine - was a region occupied by other Empires all throughout history. The Palestinians never owned it … they lived there with the Jews and Arabs. In 1947 The Arabs rejected the chance to have their own country by the UN because they wanted to eradicate Israel. Israel was legally created by the UN 1947 Resolution. The Palestinians should stop playing victim. Left alone Israel is no threat and have turned a desert into an Israeli superstate.
    3
  33. Unless you have Ancient Turkish Artefact or Ancient Ownership Scrolls going back 3,000 years ..you Arabs have no land to claim, Palestine NEVER existed. The Israelis have strong links to the land, underground temples and ancient artefact going back four thousand years.
    3
  34. Israel has done a lot with the land in only 70 years. They worked the land and made it into a prosperous nation. Israel is very good at climate change. They invented the water drip irrigation which reduces methane emissions to almost zero, and offers farmers 150% more yield. Israel's water drip irrigation changed the land from a dry desert into a rich green agricultural land. Israel grows 90% of it’s own produce. Israel has vast water De-salutation plants. Maybe Gaza could develop De-salutation water plants and grow their own food and become a climate-change friendly state.
    3
  35.  @countorlock3148  Once the Ottomans handed Palestine over to the British in 1918. The British created the “Balfour Declaration” that stated that All Jews could make their home in Israel. There was never a mention of the word ‘Palestinians ’ in the Declaration .. only the wording “a scattering of non-Jews.” After WW2, Britain gave the Mandate to the UN… who voted to create the national state of Israel in 1947. It was never stolen it was given to Israel.
    3
  36. The Palestinian Arab woman with the black scarf made a good point about the WestBank — Is it the occupiers fault if there is ‘garbage’ on the street? She is saying it’s the Palestinian Arab corrupt leaders that are creating the Garbage. Not the Israelis.
    3
  37. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires. It was never Palestinian land. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. for both the Jews and the Arabs in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted to eradicate Israel. In 1947 India lost land to Pakistan in the two state Partition of India into two separate countries. India is not demanding Pakistan back. Germany lost land to Poland after WW2 never heard of the Germans demanding their land back from Poland. In WW2 more civilians lost their lives in Germany than in Britain …that didn’t make Germany right. Palestinians will have to stop playing victim. Left alone Israel is no threat.
    3
  38. Israel is the biblical ancestral home of the Jews, who have lived there for four thousand years
    3
  39.  @Samlaren  Before 1776, the US wasn’t a country. It was individual states that were colonised by the British. The colonises were ruled by King George ||| and the Parliament of Britain. When the US became an independence country in 1776. The first President of the US was George Washington.
    2
  40. Palestine never belonged to the Palestinians. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires, never an independent country. That is why there was never a King of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. That would be like India demanding Pakistan back.Lol
    2
  41.  LandBackDay Sept-30  The UN 1947 partition gave the Palestine Arabs 46% and the Israelis 54% of the land. The Israelis signed, the Arabs rejected it. The Palestinians Arabs would rather wipe out Israel than have their own independent state. In 1948 until 1967 the Palestinian Arabs attacked Israel, this led to the expansion of Israel's territory. Israel is recognised worldwide as a sovereign democratic country.
    2
  42. Once the Ottomans handed Palestine over to the British in 1918. The British created the “Balfour Declaration” that stated that All Jews could make their home in Israel. There was never a mention of the word ‘Palestinians ’ in the Declaration .. only the wording “a scattering of non-Jews.” After WW2, Britain gave the Mandate to the UN… who voted to create the national state of Israel in 1947. It was never stolen it was given to Israel.
    2
  43. Maybe the Mos lim Arabs should leave and move to another Arab state. Dubai is lovely.⛱ To carve another 22nd Arab state out of a lone Jewish state is a crime.
    2
  44.  @Abu_elQasem  It’s not yours either. You can’t prove it’s the Arabs land. Why after WW1 was it the only land to become a mandated territory. If it had been a sovereign nation. The U.N. 1947 vote which included 56 countries could not have voted to partition it and create Israel.
    2
  45. Jerusalem has no relevance to I*lam. M*hamed died in 632 the mosque was built in 698 where is the connections to Jerusalem.
    2
  46.  @Abu_elQasem  It’s just not your land.. you can’t prove it’s your land. Jordan annexed the WestBank between 1949/1967. Why did Jordan not give it to the Palestinians if it was there land? You go and look elsewhere for another Land of Palestine ….. in a theme park.
    2
  47. I can’t believe Israel managed to get control of ‘Jerusalem ‘ when the Crusaders tried for centuries to get control of Jerusalem and failed. What an achievement !!!
    2
  48.  @machojones1146  They wouldn’t let the native Americans take over the White House… Israel was given to the Israelis by the Balfour Declaration.
    2
  49.  @randomdude8493  I can’t believe Israel managed to get control of ‘Jerusalem ‘ when the Crusaders tried for centuries to get control of Jerusalem and failed. What an achievement !!!
    2
  50. I noticed how much a dump Arab streets are compared to Jewish streets.
    2