Comments by "Elaine" (@Petal4822) on "HasanAbi" channel.

  1. In 1947 Palestine was offered an independent state along with Israel but they rejected the two state partition… because they didn’t want to live in peace with Israel. Living in a country doesn't give an automatic right to make it your country. They lived there as Arabs from neighboring countries. It passed between rulers but NONE of them were Palestinian. Palestine is the birthplace of Judaism and Christianity. Palestine has been ruled by the Assyrians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, Romans, Arabs, Fatimids, Seljuk Turks, Crusaders, Egyptians and Mamelukes. The Ottomans 1517 /1917. Then the British til 1948. Never in history was it under Palestinian rule because Palestine was NEVER a country. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
    3
  2. Nothing will change the fact that Judea, Samaria and East Jerusalem are part of Israel. No one is going to force Israel out. Since the Palestinians have their own independence state of Gaza. Maybe the neighbouring Arab countries could do more to help the Palestinian people change Gaza into a paradise state, rather than leaving them to the fate of Ham ass. The Palestinians deserve a better life. Egypt should re-open its border to Gaza. This would be a start.
    3
  3. Israel is a relatively inclusive state for those who wish to live side by side in peace. It’s the failed Palestine terrorist leaderships with their violent extremism that are the causes of Israel's predicament. Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon have kept. Palestinians in refugee camps since 1948 to this very day. Israel was legally created by the UN in 1947. Because of the war in 1967 any defense country is allowed to occupy an invading country hence Israel's expansion. Arabs with Israeli citizenship have equal voting rights, Israeli Arab women can vote. The Arab Islamic political party helped Naftali Bennett rise to power by forming a coalition as part of the new Israeli government. This will be the first time that an Arab Islamic party will serve in an Israeli government. As a christian, I think Israel is a shining beacon of hope in the Middle East and represents freedom.
    2
  4. Left alone the sovereign national state Israel is no threat. The Arabs started the conflict by firing 4,000 rockets into Israel. No one is forcing the Arabs to leave or stay but if they are so miserable. They should leave. They can go and live happily in another Arab nation. Palestine was never an Arab sovereign nation. The Arabs living there didn’t have a country to be taken.
    2
  5. Just look at the entire middle east, there is no other country that works harder towards peace, cares about human rights and is accepting of all religions more than Israel.🇮🇱🙏
    2
  6. Who were the ancient Kings or Rulers of Palestine? I watched a vid where not one Palestinian could answer that question. Palestine has no history because it never existed.
    2
  7. Article 80 of the UN Charter specifically states that the UN is obligated to uphold the mandates of the League of Nations and the mandate specifically states that the Jewish people have the right to establish a homeland in what they called Palestine which includes Judea and Samaria. The Israeli government was wrong to evict the Jews from their land in Gaza. The only occupied land is Arab occupied Israeli land.
    2
  8. Jordan, Egypt, Iran, Kuwait and Turkey are competing. Why is Gaza or the Palestinians not competing in the Tokyo Olympics ? Just asking ?
    2
  9. Palestine never belonged to the Palestinians. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires, never an independent country. That is why there was never a King of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. That would be like India demanding Pakistan back.Lol
    2
  10. Maybe the Palestinians can change Gaza into a Climate-Friendly state that is hope for the future. Israel has done a lot for climate change. Israel invented the water drip irrigation which reduces methane emissions to almost zero, and offers farmers 150% more yield. Israel's water drip irrigation changed the land from a dry, arid desert into rich agricultural land. Israel shares this technology with India. Eucalyptus trees were planted in Israel to help drain the country’s malaria ridden swamps. In 1968 Israel was declared to be malaria-free. It was the first country in Asia to be rid of the disease. Thanks to the methods of an Israeli man called Dr. Israel Jacob Kligler. Israel is the Beacon of Hope in the MiddleEast.
    2
  11. It’s not true the Palestinians don’t get forced out their homes. It wasn’t their homes …. they got evicted for not paying the rent, the same as in every country. If you don’t pay rent … go live in a tent.
    2
  12. This woman isn’t firing rockets.
    2
  13.  @meloza  Palestine never belonged to the Palestinians. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires, never an independent country. That is why there was never a King of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. That would be like India demanding fPakistan back.Lol
    2
  14. Jordan, Egypt, Iran, Kuwait and Turkey are competing. Why is Gaza or the Palestinians not competing in the Tokyo Olympics ? Just asking ?
    1
  15. Unless you have Ancient Turkish Artefact or Ancient Ownership Scrolls going back 3,000 years ..you Arabs have no land to claim, Palestine NEVER existed. The Israelis have strong links to the land, underground temples and ancient artefact going back four thousand years.
    1
  16. Palestine was offered their own independent country and rejected the two state partition in 1947 because they wanted to destroy Israel instead.
    1
  17.  @TopHatWarrior  You are not from Texas
    1
  18. The Palestinian Arabs are Turkish as they originally came from the Turkish Ottomans. Turkey is Palestine.
    1
  19. Why don’t the Arab nations give the Palestinian Arabs ‘the right of return’ . Look after their own citizens by allowing them, to work and live in any Arab nation. Arabia has vast oil rich lands. Israel gives Jews the right to return, why don’t Arabs?
    1
  20.  @veisi0624  So is Israel 🇮🇱
    1
  21. How about Iran?
    1
  22. Palestinians need to apply for Israeli citizenship. As a citizen generally carries with it recognition of civil, political, and social rights which are not afforded to non-citizens.
    1
  23. Palestinians need to apply for Israeli citizenship. As a citizen, it carries with it recognition of civil, political, and social rights which are not afforded to non-citizens. Just saying 🇺🇸
    1
  24. Get up off your knees and move out … end your suffering!! It’s called Israel not Palestine. It was never yours to take. Go live in peace with your brothers in one of the many Arab Nations. Left alone Israel Is no threat. If the Arabs apply for Israeli citizenship …they can enjoy the same rights as Israelis.
    1
  25. Get up off your knees and move out … end your suffering!! It’s called Israel not Palestine. It was never yours to take. Go live in peace with your brothers in one of the many Arab Nations. Left alone Israel Is no threat. If the Arabs apply for Israeli citizenship …they can enjoy the same rights as Israelis.
    1
  26. Get up off your knees and move out … end your suffering!! It’s called Israel not Palestine. It was never yours to take. Go live in peace with your brothers in one of the many Arab Nations. Left alone Israel Is no threat. If the Arabs apply for Israeli citizenship …they can enjoy the same rights as Israelis.
    1
  27. .,. I am am American Christian and support Israel’s right to exist. Anyone who thinks otherwise needs their head examined.
    1
  28.  @madelainestein3579  .,. I am an American Christian and support Israel’s right to exist. Anyone who thinks otherwise needs their head examined.
    1
  29.  @madelainestein3579  Once the Ottomans handed Palestine over to the British in 1918. The British created the “Balfour Declaration” that stated that All Jews could make their home in Israel. There was never a mention of the word ‘Palestinians ’ in the Declaration .. only the wording “a scattering of non-Jews.” After WW2, Britain gave the Mandate to the UN… who voted to create the national state of Israel in 1947. It was never stolen it was given to Israel.
    1
  30. Jerusalem is the holy land for the Christians and Jews. Christians love to visit the Holy land because of its importance in Jesus' life. * Jerusalem is home to the Holy Sepulchre, a site that is believed to be significant to Jesus' death, crucifixion, and resurrection. * Jerusalem is the spiritual ancestral homeland of the Jews. * Jerusalem is home to the Temple Mount. In the future the Temple will be re-built to become the center of worship and instruction for Jews.
    1
  31. God gave Israel to the Jews and it belongs to the Jews. All Jews are the Indigenous people of Israel. No Arab is. Imagine saying Japan doesn’t belong to the Japanese 🇺🇸🇺🇸 The Arabs should go live with their brothers in one of the many Arab nations.
    1
  32. The targeting of UIGHUR MUSLIMS In concentration camps in CHINA is far worse and nobody does anything,
    1
  33. https://youtu.be/ltfafnYAgKE
    1
  34.  @germpot  Whoever created the country is part of the country. Israel has done a lot with the land in only 70 years. They worked the land and made it into a prosperous nation. Israel is very good at climate change. They invented the water drip irrigation which reduces methane emissions to almost zero, and offers farmers 150% more yield. Israel's water drip irrigation changed the land from a dry desert into a rich green agricultural land. Israel grows 90% of it’s own produce. Israel has vast water De-salutation plants. Maybe Gaza could develop De-salutation water plants and grow their own food and become a climate-change friendly state.
    1
  35.  @germpot  Britain is not historically Roman . Scotland is part of Britain and the Romans never invaded Scotland. That is why the Romans built ‘Hadrian’s Wall’ to keep the Scots out. The Scots are descendants from the ‘Picts’ No Roman DNA in the Scots.
    1
  36. Who were the ancient Kings or Rulers of Palestine? I watched a vid where not one Palestinian could answer that question. Palestine has no history because it never existed. lol
    1
  37. Everyone is a Zionist who would not want their own country. Best video https://youtu.be/Eg0GQBUajVc
    1
  38. The reason the rockets didn’t kill many civilians because Israel cares about civilians on the other side and uses the Iron Dome. Ham Ass fire indiscriminately at Israel While hiding under their own people. The Arabs, they call Palestinians, were all refugees after the 1947 war, instigated by the surrounding Arab states. The Palestinians were in Gaza and the Westbank for thirty years . … it was controlled by Egypt and Jordan not Israel. Blame Jordan and Egypt for the treatment of the Palestinians between 1947 / 1967. It was only when Israel gained the land in 1967, after a defensive war that the Palestinians decided they wanted the land. The Palestinians are completely responsible for their own fate. They were offered their own country in 1947 and refused. The Palestinians in Gaza are not within an Israeli state. They have their own Apartheid state, because no Jews are allowed in Gaza. Israeli Arabs can vote and have 13 Arabs in the Israeli Knesset. How many Jews are in the Arab Knesset ...None? Anyone that claims Israel is an Apartheid state...are denying the legitimacy of Israel. Israel is not the Palestinians country. They CAN leave Gaza. Egypt has a border with Gaza they can flow into Egypt , something the Jews couldn’t do during the Holocaust.
    1
  39. It’s not true the Palestinians don’t get forced out their homes. It wasn’t their homes …. they got evicted for not paying the rent, the same as in every country. If you don’t pay rent … go live in a tent.
    1
  40. East Jerusalem, Samaria and Judea belong to Israel.. It’s only Jews that have the right to go and live in Israel and to gain Israeli citizenship
    1
  41.  @SomeThingOrMaybeAnother  Why did Jordan not give the WestBank to the Palestinians between 1948-1967 ? 😩
    1
  42.  @araznaser1570  Why did Jordan not give the WestBank to the Palestinians between 1948-1967 ? 😩
    1
  43. Left alone Israel is no threat. The Jews were in the land in 1300 BCE, the invasion of the Philistines happened in 1250 BCE which those arabs claim to be. The Jews are the indigenous people of Israel. The arabs can live in Israel but the land belongs to the Jews.
    1
  44. Why does Egypt not re-open its border with Gaza… and allow the Palestinians to flow into Egypt. Because Egypt doesn’t want Ham ass smuggling goods into Egypt under the radar. Why condemn Israel when Egypt does the same thing. Would you let Ham ass into your county to roam about especially when they threaten your very existence. Israel has a right to defend its citizens. …… To carve another Arab state out of the only one existing Jewish state is a crime. After the Holocaust the Jews needed a safe country of their own..it’s only right they should be given their biblical, ancestral home. Any segregation is done by Gaza as it isn’t safe for Jews to live in Gaza whereas it is perfectly safe for Arabs to live in Israel. Israel has 13 Arab members in the Knesset and an Arab high court Judge. How many Jews are members of the Arab Knesset…..none. Left alone Israel Is no threat ….
    1
  45. It was never the Palestinians land. Jordan annexed the WestBank from 1949/1967 then the Israelis won the territory in a defensive war which legally gives the land to Israel.
    1
  46. Why does Egypt not re-open its border with Gaza… and allow the Palestinians to flow into Egypt. Because Egypt doesn’t want Ham ass smuggling goods into Egypt under the radar. Why condemn Israel when Egypt does the same thing. Would you let Ham ass into your county to roam about especially when they threaten your very existence. Israel has a right to defend its citizens. …… To carve another Arab state out of the only one existing Jewish state is a crime. After the Holocaust the Jews needed a safe country of their own..it’s only right they should be given their biblical, ancestral home. Any segregation is done by Gaza as it isn’t safe for Jews to live in Gaza whereas it is perfectly safe for Arabs to live in Israel. Israel has 13 Arab members in the Knesset and an Arab high court Judge. How many Jews are members of the Arab Knesset…..none. Left alone Israel Is no threat ….just saying !!!
    1
  47. What state would you rather live in Israel or Gaza ? Israel is so civilised compared to Gaza.
    1
  48. The Palestinian Arabs are Turkish as they originally came from the Turkish Ottomans. Turkey is Palestine,
    1
  49.  @araznaser1570  The Palestinian Arabs are Turkish as they originally came from the Turkish Ottomans. Turkey is Palestine.
    1
  50.  @Human-cp7lv  No you have to be a descendant of Moses.
    1