Comments by "Shalanaya" (@Shalanaya) on "Elliot Page on Coming Out as Trans and Finding Hope" video.

HE!
3
HE! He was born a male based on gender identity developed in utero, trans people are born in the opposite sex in ways that matter! They are literally born intersex based on their unique physiology, and yet people like you weaponize cultural definition of sex against the actual definition of their sex. The reason most trans people are sad is because of the way how the world treats them, just like you, it is traumatizing over and over again, each purposeful misgendering is a psychological violence that is able to create micro-traumas, that over time accumulate and cause a major trauma which then leads to a suicide! It is people like you that make them sad, and that have blood on their hands, we do not live in a vacuum, do you understand that? It is unbelievable how oblivious people are. All of this has been multiple times documented through extensive research and therapy.
2
Gender dysphoria does not disappear after transition, it gets easier, people can live, because without transition trans people generally take their own lives. Based on research it takes usually only bottom surgery to entirely eliminate gender dysphoria, we have been seeing this pattern repeatedly. This is why these people need to transition before pubert, because it increases dysphoria by damaging their body even more due to the wrong phormones flooding in. It has very little to do with happiness per se, it is not some freaking vanity, it is about rooting themselves into their own body, which takes time. This is why transition is a gradual process where the body changes constantly, it takes sometimes 7 years before the real changes can be more evident and have a bigger impact on dysphoria. It is not like one day they take cross sex hormones and next day everything is okay, lol, all of this is a process of integration and healing. When you are sick, you dont change the mind, you change the body that affects the mind.
2
Page was born man, you could tell even before transitioning how deformed his body was. Trans people's body i a ig give away often, because trans people are technically regarded as intersex due to their unique physiology, but in terms of gender identity developed during the 2nd trimester, it is biological.
1