Comments by "Shalanaya" (@Shalanaya) on "Tucker Carlson"
channel.
-
It is indisputable that the biological features of our bodies that broadly differentiate half of us from the other half are important, and that we cannot choose the biological sex features bequeathed us at birth. And yet it is clearly not true that all aspects of “biological sex” are “immutable” (they change under the influence of both endogenous and exogenous sex hormones throughout the lifespan), only the tiny genetic difference that shortly after conception (usually) triggers the hormonal cascade that (usually) sends our reproductive biology down one of two characteristic developmental paths and then retires, is indeed pretty immutable. Yet even if we adopt the narrowest possible definition of biological sex as this immutable genetic difference, there is nothing controversial about believing that it is distinct from gender identity. It is because biological sex is distinct from gender identity that transgender people can, and do, exist.
However, it gets even more complicated, and this is what guarantees the freedom and safety for women, gender identity is developed by biological sex itself, it is only not used as a definition, yet. When we talk biological sex, most people use cultural definition that has nothing to do with actual biology, but the CULTural definition of sex. This is why within sports, medicine or social areas definition of sex is different, it is different from culture to culture changing throughout the history. This is one reason most people live unconsciously in a literal cult of biological determinism, this is why there is the strong link between religious fundamentalism and gender critical movement. The more you go east to the Middle East the more apparent it gets, where sex binary and polarity teachings reach the ultimate outcome - moral police weaponizing each other's bodies due to people's materialistic decadence that has excluded the holy trinity of mind, body and spirit, or time, space and consciousness, proton, electron, neutron, etc. People allowed themselves to be enslvaed by time and space (duality) outside of their control, this is what we are dealing with here, a total degeneration of humanity self projected onto trans people who make a sacrifice, even if uncosnciously, to take us out of it. They are promising an awakening to those who are ready and willing to free themselves from the fears and shame around their and others' bodies into a true multi-dimensional realm.
These children go on cross-sex hormones as soon as possible to correct the deformity of nature, the same like intersex children go on hormones around 12 due to their own body not producing any. The act of discouragement from it is an actual reflection of the repressive war against life itself through the conditioning of a materialistic mind, from becoming, movement and change. Gender transiion is ultimately a sacred spiritual journey out of the materialism that has plaqued mankind for centuries that weaponized the body against the soul. And we see it in the way how people once again defend biological determinism that is completely disconected from our sense of self.
Genetic sex should not have primacy over gender identity as a socio-legal category. It’s a political position that denies the validity and very existence of those with transgender identity because of that deeply materialistic perspective of life. Which certainly isn’t feminist, and shouldn’t even be a controversy in a democratic society. Outside of the medical field that forced diversity of biological sex into binary for safety and convenience have misunderstood that it is not binary in other scientific and socio-cultural fields whatsoever. This is why sex is a bimodal spectrum with two high end peaks on both sides that can be embodied differently, because the elements of nature are diverse enough to express feminine in multiple ways, this is why we understand that toys like a barbie doll is seen as a woman, it has been made of the elements of mother nature just like our biological sex. We use gametes to sex the bodies to uphold a sexual contrast/polarity, however in case of trans bodies, it would take using less binary markers of the body to support the sexual contrast in their sexual relations, this is the entire paradox.
As women we need to fight against any notion of biological determinism, because it is that what has treated us as objects and inferior species, it is what perpetuiates materialism and social hierarchy of domination vs submission, this is why feminism came into existence in the first place. Gender identity is that missing link that is liberating us from materialism, it is not a coincidence that most trans people are by nature very spiritual, the first trans man was a monk for example.
What the anti-trans lobby is doing is no different from what Nazis and Mengele were doing by inverting nature and playing God, because they are ruling over the bodies through their ideological dogma rooted in 2 dimensional mind-set, it is a mind-set that allows you to see only two sexes, it also allows you to see flat earth, and they would be correct. But within the 3rd dimension, the earth is round and sex is a diversity. Transitions for children and adults are not done against someone's will, unlike what Nazis did, or Frankenstein. In the future the entire hormonal and surgical treatment will be widely regarded as a holistic care that tackles the entire body, just like a diet or yoga. What will change is the science, that means that everyone will be changing their sex like they are changing their clothes these days. The reason why it is already regarded as a holistic treatment by therapists, because it treats the whole body, whereas lobotomies were treating the mind, which is why it is conversion therapies that are compared to lobotomies, and for a good reason as they are designed to turn life against itself, to change who someone is on the inside. When we are sick, we don’t change the mind, we change the body that affects the mind. Trans healthcare is in fact amongst the first that avoids the monstrosities of the past where people were pushed into lobotomy, electrical shocks, psychotherapy and sent into mental institutions, anything just to change the brain so people could fit into their norm and social constructions of the gender, now the approach is to change the body form instead, yet that is the threat to the system that exploits the body in order to oppress the mind that seeks authentic self expression, calling it an ideology is a way how to make it seem like they can force the change in the mind again.
The truth is people spend so much energy and effort clinging to physicality to argue their bias. It's ultimately not about physicality. It's an issue on a higher level of psychological and spiritual. The body is just a vessel of the karmic world for us to use and manipulate to reflect us, not a material object such as a body to manipulate us to reflect it. The entire life is about correcting our imprints on the matter of our being.
Nazis during WW2 were calling trans healthcare barbaric and closing all their clinics and surgeries. It is the neo-fascists and Christian fundamentalists who stood behind Hitler in their support who are against trans healthcare, not a coincidence, it is all perfectly connected. Because they need to uphopld their illusion of gender identity serving as the systematic control by the patriarchy. These surgeries for trans people are not experimental at this stage by any means, because they are not exploring a new territory, but following a standard procedure established more than 100 years ago, in fact surgeries done on intersex people are far more experimental, as they are exploring a new territory based on how they were born, not to mention they are not done against someone's will, they are considerted a 'miracle' treatment and vast majority are satisifed with it.
Transgender humans are bringing mutation to the systems that we are attached to. Sports / Religion / Government / Healthcare / Media etc. are massive systems with money, prestige, rules, and hierarchy anchoring them. Systems self-protect which means that when the old rigid ways no longer serve them, they will reach a tipping-point that will bring expansive and evolutionary shifts or else they will crumble. The law of nature is change. If change scares someone then they are not aligned with nature, they are aligned with the rigid systems that nature is in the process of deconstructing. Trans people are weapons of destruction to the system, and the establishment is using people's fears to stop them, the same tactic has been made by Hitler and Mussolini by demozing jews, gays and trans for their public at the time before they were sent into gas chambers, so they could stand on the side of their leaders. Trans represent the future free from archaic systems of social control rooted in fear by the radical act of freeing mother nature from the sexist patriarchal systems around the world that determined what man or woman is in the first place as a result of humans giving p their own powers, and bring back self determination instead of colective imposition upon mother nature.
3
-
3
-
Freedom is achieved through an act of inclusion as a tool that sacrifices and erases the means through which the governmental power can exploit and oppress mankind, and that is our beliefs rooted in trauma around sex, shame, guilt, body and identity. The oppression is ultimately not against women, it is against the feminine, the mother nature herself as a creative force - the reflection/shadow. The oppressive regimes come into existence as a result of resistance towards the inclusion and sacrifice for the individual that evolution demands, which then leads to division of people, and then conquer by an outside authority, because authority of an individual has been rejected or devalued. True freedom always needs to come with the destruction of all that we think is true in the name of freedom and power for the individual. Because the truth is a multiplicity that diversifies into multiple billions of pieces of the whole system that unifies through its diversity at a higher point.
"We trade away some, if not much, of our freedom for the feeling of safety that comes with sticking with what we know, because the known can only be as scary as it already is, whereas the unknown has limitless potential to be terrifying" - Philip K. Jason
Biological sex is not and should not be determined by sex chromosomes anyway. Chromosomes are nothing more than a storage of structures of the underlying genetics. Biological sex is determined by a massive and complex array of genetics and epigenetics. And that includes hormones of the body. There is no overall general consensus of the definition of biological sex. Most definitions center around reproductive ability which is not fully determined or realized until well into puberty. Sex assigned at birth is based on appearance of external anatomy. Chromosomes are not frequently used to determine sex assigned at birth unless there is a need to perform an analysis. And now get this, gender identity itself has been found to be biological due to its in-utero hormonal exposure during the second trimester, while sexual orientation during the third trimester, so stepping out of this complexity and imposing rules on nature is literally playing God. This is not a coincidence that it has been largely religious organizations who were upholding this binary categorization, but also neo-nazis, because it helps them to perpetuate the predatory paradigm of 'domination vs submission' (man vs woman). Gender Binary has been a tool of psychological control by deeply oppressive regimes on this planet (especially in Moddle East) in resitance to individual expansion that could serve the whole system as the whole system could serve the individual, because when the whole suppresses the individual, then the individual can not reflect the whole, and that is when tyranny comes into play. The fear gives them the reason to rule.
Notice what Adolf Hitler has once said:
"It was by the will of God that men were made of a certain bodily shape, were given their natures and their faculties. Whoever destroys His work wages war against God's Creation and God's Will." - Hitler (Mein Kampf, vol 2, chapter X.)
"Parallel to the training of the body a struggle against the poisoning of the soul must begin. Our whole public life today is like a hothouse for sexual ideas and simulations. Just look at the bill of fare served up in our movies, vaudeville and theaters, and you will hardly be able to deny that this is not the right kind of food, particularly for the youth . . . Theater, art, literature, cinema, press, posters, and window displays must be cleansed of all manifestations of our rotting world (which conservatives would call "liberal") and placed in the service of a moral, political, and cultural idea." (which conservatives would call "conservative")."
- Hitler ("Mein Kampf", Vol. 1, Ch. 10, )
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Good lord. Modern real consevativism is what Hitler believed in, it is the actual fascism that made Nazi party in the first place. Woke marxism is what indigenous tribes of Africa and AMerica used to be based on, it is liberating the entire planet and is bringing revolution to the whole world. The communism is what indigenous native american communities were living under. Remember that conservativism in any shape of form is fascistic at the core!!!! This is something people need to wake up to already! Fascism under Hitler could have worked only under the pretense of defending consevativism.
"Parallel to the training of the body a struggle against the poisoning of the soul must begin. Our whole public life today is like a hothouse for sexual ideas and simulations. Just look at the bill of fare served up in our movies, vaudeville and theaters, and you will hardly be able to deny that this is not the right kind of food, particularly for the youth . . . Theater, art, literature, cinema, press, posters, and window displays must be cleansed of all manifestations of our rotting world (which conservatives would call "liberal") and placed in the service of a moral, political, and cultural idea." (which conservatives would call "conservative")."
- Hitler ("Mein Kampf", Vol. 1, Ch. 10, )
1
-
1
-
1