Comments by "Shalanaya" (@Shalanaya) on "The Daily Signal"
channel.
-
Gender affirming care is a life-saving medical necessity for people of any age, the decision not to provide even puberty blockers isn't "waiting to make a decision until they're older". The hormones are gonna happen. You're just making a decision for them, and one that is statistically likely to be harmful. It is never, ever anyone’s decision to transition but theirs, If someone thinks cis kids should be allowed autonomy over abortions and blood transfusions but trans kids shouldn’t be allowed to transition, then they need to fix their heart. Kids should be given time to think" - this is literally what puberty blockers are for. People who argue this in bad faith are actually saying "kids should be forced to go through the the puberty of their AGAB". This is exactly the same as forcing cis children to transition."Let kids be kids" implies that "kids" are hetero or non-trans by default, and that being trans is some sin of intrusive thought. Why are they being told to be cishetero before they get to decide for themselves. Obviously there's no discussion about banning puberty blockers for children having precocious puberty so THEY get a chance to be kids. Puberty turns youths into adults, “blocking” puberty in adults is like giving contraception to people in their second trimester or checking for traffic after you’ve already been hit by the car.
To better understand the whole picture I'll start by quoting Deleuze - "The Interpretation of Utterances" -
"There are not two sexes, there are n sexes; there are as many sexes as there are assemblages. And since each of us enters into several assemblages, each of us has n sexes. When children discover that they are reduced to one sex, male or female, they discover their powerlessness: they lose the machinic sense and are left only with the signification of a tool. And then a child really does fall into depression. They have been damaged; their countless sexes have been stolen!" (n is a symbol in mathematics for natural numbers).
Then I'll
9
-
There is objective truth between male and female, it is decided by humans how to gender the body. That is objective truth, right, that is an ideology. Wake up. Trans women are female and trans men are male, it is that simple for anyone with a common sense! By the authority of all major scientific and medical insitutions they are recognized as female through the process of recognition of their in-utero development of gender identity as a marker of biological sex, hormonal development of the body as another marker of sex, and then the sociological marker of gender which can be opposite of sex defined by chromosomes. And this is also a human rights issue where people are denied their own gender, the same like language, heritage, this an issue of ethnicide verging on the actual genocide, because their identity allows them to exist in this world. To deny it is to deny their own freedom of speech and expression, self actualization, and potential death, as hormonal therapy is part and parcel of psychiatric treatment where the prescribed hormones are alleviating depression.
2
-
Wow people like this Tim Ballard are what is so WRONG with this world! that guy in the video is completely ignorant who thinks trans children can consent to medical treatment designed to save their lives, it is NOT them who give consent, and you buy his lies, it is and always was parents, just like with ANY medical treatment. These kids NEED to get on hormones even at 13 years old, because their body needs the major hormone of the opposite sex to alleviate physiological stress on the nerves connected to the heart and bowels, because it become life threatening not just physiologically, but also psychologically. it is a medical treatment, those children are not giving ANY consent. Intersex children have been given hormones around the age of 12 years for over 50 years! And they're operated on even sooner without any of their consent, basically their body is butchered often, and in adulthood they become trans and need to transition into the opposite sex, because they have ignored their gender identity. This is insane what kind of lies these people are using to fool ignorant people like you who have no insight knowldge about what is really going on. This needs to stop!
2
-
Imposing onto kids what gender they are against their will IS a child abuse already, and has been for decades, this is the western colonial gender system that has nothing to do with biology. Asignment of sex is an ideological decision, there is no general consensus on what determines to be a boy or girl, these are all thought imposed upon people, they are determined based on the male and female parameters that serve most bodies, but biological sex has never been binary, there are exceptions to every rule. Trans children do not change any gender, they are born girls even if they have a penis, and vice versa, it is the imposition of gender onto them that is damaging to their psyche and body!!!
2
-
1
-
1
-
Women are trying to counteract the dangerous and harmful gender ideology of the older generations by telling boys or girls they are boys and girls, affirming them from early on, and then they are confused and commiting suicide, we have watched this for decades. This is why it is imperative to teach chilkdren that their true gender is not determined by which genitalia they have, that should get people in jail, because that is simply a child abuse, our psychology needs to take precedence. I am proud to have helped dozens of children to get on hormones as early as possible, and we should make sure all children grow up aligned with their own true gender without pushing them into our idea of what gender they are. penis does not make a boy or vagina a girl we alread know that, that is why we are changing what these older generations have perpetrated for decades if not centuries, it was about time. This has been proven in psychology that the more gender binary is pushed, the more children are confused about their gender, the more they are exposed to the idea of gender identity the more free they are in their self expression. The body should not decide our gender, but our psychology, this is not debatable, we already know this to be true through research.
1
-
Wow people like you are what is WRONG with this world, that guy in the video is completely ignorant who thinks trans children can consent to medical treatment designed to save their lives, it is NOT them who give consent, and you buy his lies, it is and always was parents, just like with ANY medical treatment. These kids NEED to get on hormones even at 13 years old, because their body needs the major hormone of the opposite sex to alleviate physiological stress on the nerves connected to the heart and bowels, it is a medical treatment, those children are not not giving any consent. Intersex children have been given hormones around the age of 12 years for over 50 years! And they're operated on even sooner without any of their consent, basically their body is butchered often, and in adulthood they become trans and need to transition into the opposite sex, because they have ignored their gender identity. This is insane what kind of lies these people are using to fool ignorant people like you who have no insight knowldge about what is really going on. This needs to stop!
1