Comments by "Shalanaya" (@Shalanaya) on "The Institute of Art and Ideas" channel.

Because she knows how her ideology is fascistic in its essence. It erases someone's sovereignty and agency over their own mind and body.
4
Most bullying is directed towards trans people, and all trans people are activists just by their existence, there is rarely any trans person on this planet with some amount of self respect and self worth that does not share the same views as those who openly are targetted as activists, because it deals with self evident experiential truth, what people like Kathleen does is to adhree to a religious ideology over someone's experience, she values oppression, division, shame and fear over transcendence and elevation of the spirit by healing our shame and fear connected to each other's sexed bodies. This also relates to trans women in sports as there's been a sceitnfic report released a few months ago confirming that trans women after several years on HRT no longer have any biological advantage since their muscle mass, tendons and ligaments fall within the female range due to the hormonal development, of course, it is the same as if we rejected all the taller and stronger women and left only smaller and weaker ones in, the latter would surely benefit, but that is not what sport is about, this si purely based on prejudice and ideology that has nothing to do with reality, biology and the truth.
3
This is why existence of transgender people is bringing reason to an otherwise cultish belief system that man or woman is this or that, which were rooted in a belief, and not science. gender bianry itself was brought in from colonists, in ancient societies there were mutiple genders , the original Jewish Torah itself had 6 genders.
2
lol, sex is never binary, nothing in mother nature is binary, people like you play being gods by trying to put nature into two boxes, nature defies categorizations. There are officially 6 biological sexes based on the consesus of the scientific community which was released to the public. Most ancient societies never had had two sexed, but multiple as well. Gender identity also is not socially constructed, it is biologicaly developed during the 2nd trimester, we have evidences for that, it is deeply connected to sexual instincts, and it is the same thing as sexual orientation diferently expressed, it is a sexual instinct expressed towards one's own body instead of the outside bodies as in the case of sexual orientation. This is how one can recognize how self aligned we are in our sexual dimorphism. In other words, sex is never binary, scientific community has known this for decades, but we are sexually dimorphic, and it can manifest in all kinds of creative ways, because mother nature is a creative force that knows no limit and it defies categorizations. This is how human species needs to be understood, not as man and woman, but as sexual contrasts, and through this trajectory come back to our sexual instincts like animals do, since they do not need social gendering categorization, they have sexual instinct, the same instinct that makes a heterosexual dude sexually attrracted to a trans woman.
2
What is extreme at honoring each other's truth about themselves without forcing onto others what we think they are? People like you have lost the meaning of love as a sacrifice of our ego, beliefs and sense of personal reality by honoring the difference in the other. What is extreme is this narcissicism from people like you, it is a self projection.
2
@jayk5549 The women in her league have the right to expect fair competition among equals. Asserting the rights of one TG competitor over the rights all the other women competitors is unbalanced, unreasonable and simply not fair - it diminishes their rights to fair sport. There are many cases like that. This is the “nuance” part that they refuse to accommodate. You talk about nuance while refusing to see the nuance yourself, do you realize that there's been released a scientific report recently that is confirming that after several years trans women are within the female range and no longer have any biological advantage? The nuance is that some women have more biological advantage over other women as well, that si how sport works, if we took out all the taller and stronger women and kept only smaller and weaker ones, those weaker ones would benefit as well. I can NOT believe what I am reading here, I just can't, most people are absolutely insane or clueless around this topic, dont you see this is nothing but prejudice? If you did not know those are trans women, you would not care, through hormonal transition the biology of trans women is changed drastically, and advantage is not just biological, it has to do with training, diet, etc. Women only benefit from having trans women in there because it diversifies their gender group enough to pose as a beneficial challenge.
2
Transgender is not a cult because it is not rooted in a belief but purely in a biology and self determination to embody our spirit. hat is a cult is a belief that woman is someone who has a vagina, because it s rooted in a belief. What we are witnessing here is a self projection, transgender peopel are the voice of mother nature rebelling against this oppressive colonial sexist system.
2
Well said, you spared me all those few minutes from watching this insanity. She is known for being disconnected from reality herself. It is pure ideology vs truth, this is why neo-fascists or fundamental Christians tend to defend people like her, it is belief over reality, which is nuanced, and never black and white, never binary, it is chaotic and blurred. This is why they need to define man and woman so much, but how can you do that to nature that is so chaotic in the first place. This just shows you how they are not on the side of freedom whatsoever.
1
It is a child abuse for a child to be told they are a girlk or boy just based on their genitalia, I hope you understand that.
1
@dax2005 It is totaly outdated, hence why so many scietists and biologists in this world fully acknoledge that trans women were born biological females, based on the criteria of gender identity that is fully biological and innate, as a guiding biological principle that deal with self perceptin and neurobiology, it has been officially recognized that way by the scientific community hence why it has been implemented in education and dictionaries. The world is moving on, and this lady is just resisting reality and basic science and the actual advanced biology with regards to what we know about transgender people. People like her are going to have a very hard time on earth, including conservatives.
1