Comments by "Shalanaya" (@Shalanaya) on "Thom Hartmann Program"
channel.
-
5
-
5
-
4
-
4
-
Men and women must have the freedom to comfortably express their own beliefs, such as the bible is not factually true, but NOT when those beliefs invalidate someone's sense of self like their gender identity they were born with, especially by using verbal violence to purposefully misgender someone, because that is when you are guilty of supporting a fascistic regime that has power over the sovereignty of an individual and the truth of who they are. This is how fascism grows by valuing belief over the the value of an individual and who they are for themselves. If you wish to have individual freedom, you have to validate differences of those individuals, once you devaluate it, you devaluate it for yourself, it is a two-way street. That's how it works. Viewpoint diversity always cancels itself out when those views devalue that diversity, it leads to fascism. If you wish to bring down corruption and oppressive regimes, you need to raise the value of an individual by a sacrifce of your own beliefs by honoring the differences of others.
It is of crucial importance to understand that there is a major difference between a religion and someone's gender identity, since it is not a belief, it is not comparable, it is who someone is that determines their safety and place in this world, it is equal to saying you are not Christian and preventing them from entering a church based on that outside authority. Trans women are women based on established facts of their gender identity developed in utero during the second trimester due to the hormonal exposure in the womb, it is a belief that someone is a woman because they have a vagina, those are not facts, it is a choice how to gender the body and categorize it that way. Gendering of the sexed bodies is a sociological ideology determined by cultures, and has roots in actual fascism as it serves the capitalist status quo and corporations as reproductive means to an end,. it is what or who you are, and it has to be valued, you can change your religious belief, not your biology and how you were wired to exist.
For example, trans women belong in female sport without any shadow of a doubt, because their body is largely within the range of female body and not male body anymore, but also because they are women based on their gender identity, it is their individuality and difference which matters here, and sport is by default based on disadvantages from the start, that means that if we took out all the taller and stronger women from the gender group, those weaker ones would also benefit, but that is not what sport is about, it is the advantages and disadvantages that diversify the gender group and empower the whole as a result. As long as we can ever evolve as a human species, trans people need to be fully integrated witin the genders they identify as in order to prevent ourselves from the fascistic system to take over - because the value of an individual and their self knowing has to go higher above someone's belief or definitions of them, otherwise they become the oppressors of those differences. If religions are violent towards others by denying and invalidating their differences, then they have no place in public, this is not the case for trans people, because they are representing the self actualization of who they are and have to be integrated based on that self knowledge without our own imposition of beliefs upon them. The same applies to abortions, every woman has a right over her own body to give or take away life. This is the kind of system we need to focus on building. It's been unstable from the start, capitalism itself is based on predatory power over others and exploitation, it was a matter of time we would get to this point.
4
-
4
-
3
-
Except you got it TOTALLY backwards!!! And only support Trump and the fascism to deny someone's right to exist on their own terms, you are a major problem and reposnsible for a potential genocide of men, women and children who do not fit the beliefs of an authority, because gendering of the body is a authoritarian movement that goes back to totalitarian/fascistic regimes weaponizing the bodies against the inner authority of the person. This is why Hitler has attacked trans people at the time and all the research on them and sent them into death camps. Gender identity is not a belief, transwomen are women based on well established facts of their gender identity developed in utero during the second trimester due to the hormonal exposure in the womb, it is a belief that someone is a woman because they have a vagina, those are not facts, it is a choice how to gender the body and categorize it that way, come back to reality please, gendering of the sexed bodies is a sociological ideology determined by cultures, not facts of reality. You have been socially conditioned to believe gender identity is a belief, you can not change that belief, you are born that way, you can change your religious belief, not your biology and how you were wired to exist.
2
-
@benjaminfranklin8412 In ortder to get along we need to value individuality over personal beliefs, it is not up to you to determine if trans women are women, your obligation is to validate their difference to be who they are without imposing your beliefs on them. Of course that trans women belong in female sport, because their body is within the range of female body and not male body anymore, but also because they are women, and sport is by default based on disadvantages from the start, that means that if we took out all the taller and stronger women from the gender group, those weaker ones would also benefit, but that is not what sport is about, it is the advantages and disadvantages that diversify the gender group and empower the whole as a result. As long as we can ever evolve as a human species, trans people need to be fully integrated witin the genders they identify as in order to prevent ourselves from the fascistic system to take over - BECAUSE the value of an individual and their self knowing has to be higher than someone's belief or definitions of them, otherwise WE are the oppressors, not them! Do you understand that? This is crucial and very very important to understand, all differences have to be integrated. If religions are violent towards others by denying and invalidating their differences, then they have no place in public, this is not the case for trans people, because they are representing the self actualization of who they are and have to be integrated based on that self knowledge without our own imposition of beliefs upon them.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
@benjaminfranklin8412 It is of crucial importance to understand that there is a major difference between a religion and someone's gender identity, since it is not a belief, it is not comparable, it is who someone is that determines their safety and place in this world, it is equal to saying you are not Christian and preventing them from entering a church based on that outside authority. Men and women must have the freedom to comfortably express their own beliefs, such as the bible is not factually true, but NOT when those beliefs invalidate someone's sense of self like their gender identity they were born with, especially by using verbal violence to purposefully misgender someone, because that is when you are guilty of supporting a fascistic regime that has power over the sovereignty of an individual and the truth of who they are. This is how fascism grows by valuing belief over the the value of an individual and who they are for themselves. If you wish to have individual freedom, you have to validate differences of those individuals, once you devaluate it, you devaluate it for yourself, it is a two-way street. That's how it works. Viewpoint diversity always cancels itself out when those views devalue that diversity, it leads to fascism. If you wish to bring down corruption and oppressive regimes, you need to raise the value of an individual by a sacrifce of your own beliefs by honoring the differences of others.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@ToddTyczkowski USA won't survive, some of us mediums have seen it a year ago that US would dissolve as a nation, and at the end of the year 2025 WW3 would start, some of us also saw extermination of people in camps. So please if you can leave, then leave. Nothing can stop what is coming unless people in the Military go and arrest them all one by one. The sooner people act the more damage can be prevented. If people listened more to psychics and mediums with good track record a lot of atrocities and suffering could be prevented. I am grateful for being able to help some people to emmigrate already last year, and obviously not everyone was going to believe me, in a fair world only MAGAs would stay in the US to suffer the consequences of their actions, but obviously that is not the case, I dont like to see innocent people left behind. So I say to everyone if they can move, then do so, if not, move to the west coast, there is a high probability California, Oregon and Washington will secede, it could save millions of lives.
1
-
lol. delusional, the woke outcry that free speech is being shut down was never a thing, only consequences to one's abusive speech, only when government interferes counts as shut down of free speech, not individual platforms and spaces that individual people own and have rules over. This is why throughout the history some forms of cancel culture were necessary to prevent authoritarianism, it was not cancel culture that's been authoritarian, but the extreme opposite, it protects the individual freedom against the invalidation or violence of individual sovereignty or dignity, because what starts in energy ends in action. We have evidences already that election was never subverted by democrats, only conservatives who projected out what they were doing themselves in 2020 by creating false scenarios and evidences that election was stolen, that was disproven through investigation and by judges. Everything was set up with the help of Heritage Foundation funding various alt.right conspiracy sites selling fake news to psy-op and socially condition masses of people all these years, this has already been done in the 1930's through Goebells propaganda about jewish conspiracy, the classic nazi playbook. Trump owns Mein Kampf and knew all the tricks how to create propaganda through intentional projection blaming the opposition of what they were doing themsevles so they would never be suspected. Only lack of self awareness on the part of conservatives was able to suck them into this division, and what is divided is easy to conquer. I would suggest you to wake up.
1