Comments by "Comm0ut" (@Comm0ut) on "TheQuartering"
channel.
-
31
-
19
-
8
-
7
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
There are really four Harley subcultures. One is the straitlaced men with money (which is why HD sold special Shrine models) who are the touring market. Another is blue collar bikers who were never patch holders and wanted a machine they could service anywhere (including the human mutual support network old motorcycles made necessary before the internet) . They bought the Super Glides and Low Riders which copied what the same people did to used big twins to shed weight, bulk and maintenance obstacles. The fewest by far are the (real) 1%ers who are famous but too small to influence sales volume. The key one is the independent mechanic/manufacturing/restoration subculture including speed and repair parts makers like S&S, Baker, Ultima, Paughco etc. If the other subcultures die the last will remain because it's self-contained and doesn't care what Milwaukee thinks.
As models fade from factory support most vehicles become more difficult to support but HDs become easier. One can build a stronger, faster, and more specialized to owner preference hotrod Twin Cam, Evo, Shovelhead, Panhead, Knucklehead without using a single HD nut, bolt or washer. HD engineering through the classic and most of the Twin Cam era is simple but intentionally so by fierce customer demand. The sound basics are frequently undermined by product cheapening since the Twin Cam era but TCs are still easy to work on though I don't care enough to add one to my fleet.
Their 1936-1999 basic engine design was engineered for simplicity of manufacture on manual machine tools which makes aftermarket parts far less expensive than otherwise.
The impact of that choice cannot be overestimated but few besides mechanics think to notice. What made HDs successful over time was their durable, easily rebuildable crankshafts which along with their vertically split crankcases, individual removable single cylinders and heads made it possible to overhaul an engine to what they call "zero time" in aviation. It made it easy to cannibalize the many useful parts from any worn out or blown engine. That's why my Panhead had '48 and a '58 cylinder heads and was easy to turn into an ~84" cubic inch stroker to keep up with modern traffic using a recent set of cylinders and a stroker crank. Do THAT with any other bike that ancient.
That 1936 basicdesign was so reliable the Timken output shaft bearing was downgraded by the "new HD" to a roller when they went to semi-automated assembly for Twin Cam. (Now the same bearing is an expensive upgrade!) While the non-unit big twin primary and final drive sprocket arrangement has been obsolete since the smaller K Model introduced right-side drive (carried on by Sportsters through the Evo) in 1952, it also confines damage to three separate areas, the engine, the primary drive, and the transmission/final drive. That engineering choice makes Harleys like two-wheeled Legos. It's why my Panhead has a 1990s five speed Softail gearbox and excellent electric starter connected by an aftermarket belt drive. The ability to mix components and parts from 1936 to 2000 is unmatched (Royal Enfields older models being the closest).
HDs were practical to ride for many decades which is why there are far more 1950s Harleys than there are Triumphs or Nortons. The unique aftermarket support and ease of overhaul mean classic HDs easily last generations like my '48 "Panhead Of Theseus". 😁 The vintage HD culture will remain just like the vintage Britbike, Indian, Japanese and other cultures none of which need the modern companies bearing their name. I won't miss the Wokely-Pervertson company should it come to grief, but I'll laugh at them.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
"Mechanics" are not going to suffer so please abandon that innocent, well intentioned but mistaken idea. Remember in the US mechanics usually own all our tools and equipment so the barriers to starting your own shop are modest outside very expensive areas. Many of us have better motorcycle workshops at home than most dealers. No mechanic worth their salt doesn't have more than a lifetime of employment AND side work could finish. Good mechanics never starve and we can work on anything because we understand theory of operation. If you can wrench bikes you can (and MANY mechanics do) move into industry, aviation etc and make more money. I did and I'm far from special. There are many videos of car guys (fewer with bikes as there are fewer powersports industry techs) quitting that part of the industry for much greener pastures. I'm a multibrand car and bike mech with decades in aviation as my primary careers so this is not speculation.
Insulting your core demographic is nothing new to HD as senior bikers remember quite well from the "flip the patch" era. Real bikers do not need (want is not need) anything the new company makes. Street bikes in the US are TOYs, not transportation (the exceptions prove the rule and know who you are) and toy buyers are already receding from motorcycling. Why buy product from a company which supports .pdf files, gr00ming and gender surgery upon children too young to make informed consent? I don't want the new HD to get better, I prefer it go bankrupt as the aftermarket already amply support every Harley ever made. There will always be plenty of used rides and parts to assemble new ones. Real bikers spin our own wrenches. Remember the REASON the old motorcycle culture existed (and remains strong in niche areas like hot rodding, chopping, drag racing etc) is mechanical mutual support. Commodification, especially marketing to posers, ended most of that culture which today mostly exists among vintage riders. If HD crumples the massive US aftermarket (all small businesses BTW) can easily supply every part in stock or upgraded form which is why you can build a better "big twin" without a single Milwaukee nut, bolt or washer.
HD as a company should be excommunicated to show the American people really can punish their woke oppressors. A new generation of younger riders (especially in chopperdom) are building their own rides and discovering there is far more to bikerdom than riding an appliance.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1