Comments by "Crazy Eyes" (@CrizzyEyes) on "The Starship Troopers Discourse" video.

Heinlein's novel doesn't really depict Fascism. The idea of a hardcore meritocratic state in which you must serve in the military to vote seems ghastly to us now, but strictly speaking, it simply isn't Fascism, just an idea that could potentially coexist with Fascism. Heinlein toys with the idea because he was frustrated with genuinely awful decisions made by civilians in our government during the Cold War, and had served in the military himself. Fascism is kind of a flash-in-the-pan ideology that has little to no relevance today, because it is by its very origin a reaction to Communism. However, the things that Fascist states had in common were: - a body of voters who are completely desperate and faced with choosing between radical ideologies in the wake of a weak sitting government before the Fascists arrive - a call back to the most glorious period in that nation's or people's history and a claim to be able to return to that former glory - seizing the means of production, not unlike Communism, to both modernize and control industry (remember, Fascism was relevant when most of Europe still needed to industrialize, badly, especially Italy) - blaming a specific group of people for most if not all of the woes the nation currently faces (again, not unlike Communism) - and of course, totalitarian control of the government Helldivers depicts a government much closer to Fascism than Starship Troopers. However, my personal theory is that it is a plutocracy run by defense and arms contractors that manufacture reasons to go to war to perpetuate their own profits. It explains why the government seems to wage war so inefficiently; it's like the mistakes and ulterior motives that came up with the F-35 taken into overdrive, and put in control of the entire human species for a few hundred years.
29
There was an April Fools' event in the game War Thunder (normally a game that only lets you play historical vehicles) which allowed you to play using book-accurate mobile infantry suits a year or two ago. It was fun, if a bit goofy, but they're big exoskeletons with the ability to leap onto buildings and use the type of weaponry you'd normally see on a tank.
15
I had no idea that they made Magicka. Wow, they've come a long way. HD2 just has really great feel. The gunplay is really good, the guns "feel" real and the recoil is represented one-to-one in the game. It's not just a cheesy RNG cone of bullets. You see your optic bouncing around and you can control the recoil if you're skilled. You have the option of stealth and going prone, even though it doesn't seem like a tactical shooter, and there are even options to benefit that play style. The objectives are varied and fun to complete. The hitboxes and hit detection are really good. It's just a game with really solid fundamentals. It feels "realistic" enough to make you feel like a god among men when you do manage to kill an entire platoon of killer robots or giant termites by yourself, but not so much that it makes the game frustrating or slow.
7
He was really talking about the Commies. He had some unfavorable things to say about the tribe, but if I recall right it was only the context of people from the Jewish ghettoes generally being disgusting while he oversaw displaced peoples housing.
6
@Guciom >he thinks the movie matters and that the director didn't hate Heinlein
4
@alexberkowitz5897 If you swallow media that pretentiously claims to be an adaptation of something else, while sabotaging the source material, then you're a little bug-brained yourself there, fella. Next you'll tell me the Halo TV series is good.
3
ST really explores the difference between "citizen" (or in our terms, veteran) and "civilian" and what ramifications allowing rich, pampered people to run our society has for us. It is, without question, a militarist book, but in the context of the times especially (the height of the Cold War) it was quite reasonable. And I'm sure Heinlein felt vindicated after he saw how stupidly the Vietnam War went.
2
@Blaze6108 Life is hard when you have the ability to recognize patterns.
2
All of the guns in this game have optics, you just need to press your buttons and don't be such a casual.
2
There's a kind-of-similar game called Natural Selection, but both teams have RTS commanders that work with the rest of their team playing FPS in order to win the match, and it's humans vs. a hive alien race. Although, I think that the first game designed it so that only the humans got a commander, but it's been a really long time.
1
@KibitoAkuya The Nazi party wasn't really Fascist at the time, it was uncle Adolf that turned it around. He added three zeroes to the ID numbers on the party cards to make their membership seem larger and ousted all the real socialists when he came into power.
1
@corriemooney9812 Yeah, you could say they were "nuclear war" levels of different. Many people thought we were going to go to war with the Soviets soon.
1
@jetfrog4574 Fascism is a lot more narrowly defined than people seem to think it is. Every modern dictator is not a Fascist. There are many flavors of totalitarian ideology and that is only one of them. The Federation isn't even totalitarian. It's closer to the Roman republic pre-Caesar.
1
@ablearcher4058 eh... It was more like a thought experiment than satire. Try to read the book through the lens of being a pissed off Navy veteran who is mad at the US government for making bad decisions in the Cold War and you may understand, because that's where Heinlein was when he wrote it.
1
@smalltowns374 My point is really that I don't think Patton wasn't in a position to truly know all the bits and pieces of who was behind the Bolshevik movement, who was behind the American psy-ops division that worked with the Soviets to falsify concentration camp evidence, etc. And if he was, well, that's why his Jeep crashed.
1
@smalltowns374 Sure, but we're talking about what Patton said here. Patton wasn't omniscient. That said, he did apparently know too much, anyway.
1
@mandowarrior123 Based on what little they've depicted in the game, there are definitely secret police who go around imprisoning people at the slightest sign of dissent (check the fake reviews in the super store). There are also gulags named "freedom camps" and the Super Earth economy is a mockery of the American economy where your hard work will never let you get anywhere unless the government decides it's okay first. The Democracy Officer in your ship is obviously supposed to be a morale officer (i.e. commissar) and is the guy who always spits out some fluffy meaningless quote at the beginning and end of a mission, like "DEMOCRACY PREVAILS AGAIN" or whatever.
1