Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "NDTV"
channel.
-
41
-
20
-
19
-
17
-
14
-
13
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
11
-
10
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
8
-
8
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
Birender Singh Dhanoa should be fired long time ago, under his leadership, IAF got nothing but losses and humiliations. No need to mention large number of crashed of IAF jets under his leadership which showed that he has no idea how to manage the service and maintains part of the IAF jets , just in 2019 alone, IAF's so called "airstrike" showed very poor plan, and even worse execution, totally missed the target, not killed a single "terrorist" but a poor unlucky crow and some pine trees with so called "smart bombs" with huge jet formations with Mirage 2000, su-30 MKIs and early warning planes, and even right after that, the air battle again lost everything did not achieve anything except the pilot was invited unwillingly to have "delicious" tea in Pakistan, with a Mig 21 shot down, a helicopter was shot down by India's own missile, to save face and whole India made a lie saying they shot down an F16, which cannot fool anyone buy themselves, it showed a total mess of IAF under Birender Singh Dhanoa's leadership.
7
-
India's problem is more fundamental, they are:
1. Hinduism ,there is no science and logic in it, those are the key essential factors for building a modern country.
2. western style "democratic" political system, under this system, not very intelligent people get elected, since in a society most intelligent people is not majority, in a developed country with highly educated population, it could be fine, but in India with huge uneducated and less educated population, they would elect what they like or sound good to them, not a really intelligent one, Such as Mr. Modi, obviously most of his policies are failed, however, he claimed he had the most votes in the world, but if he cannot run a country well (already past 5 yrs), what most vote good for??
also under this system, people judge by western standard, not by reality in India as, Author pointed out, for all regulations that restricted the release the energy for productivity, however, under western style "politically correctness", no one can change those unrealistic rules.
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
compare India GDP under Congress and BJP,
from 2007-2014 under Congress, India GDP increased 1.68 times, from $1216.74 Billion to $2039.13 Billion
from 2014-2020, under BJP, India GDP increased 1.29 times, from $2039.13 Billion to $2,622.98B. considering affected by the pandemic, so just compare to before the pandemic, from 2014 to 2019, it is 1.41 times, still less than the growth under Congress.
6
-
5
-
5
-
this shows how stupid the 2017 Doklam incident caused by India was, at that time, China's road was just for a patrol since before the patrol was on foot, with the road PLA can use patrol cars, no importance in war since is it only 150 meters from the border, in war the first thing will be destroyed. However, the over reaction of India made China realize India consider this is essential for India, that why India stayed there for over 2 months no matter what China said to them they would not withdraw until China seriously prepare war for it,
anyway, from that time, thanks to India's reaction, China put a lot of efforts in building Doklam into a solid military base and in war certainly it will be used for China to cut off Siruguli corridor
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
in international relationship, nobody really trusts anybody else. especially for India and China, for China, India is still occupying part of China, called Tibet South. for India, China is all weather iron brother of Pakistan, if war broke out between Pakistan and India, China will surely full heartedly support Pakistan to win the war against India.
therefore, we do not expect trust from India, same is true, we do not trust India, or until our land get returned.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
1. USA does not pay too much attention to India, Trump does not even bother to visit India despite the invitation from India but he visited China.
2. USA just achieved first phase of trade deal with China, in which China and USA get agreement on intellectual property and currency. China agrees to double purchase USA agriculture products for up to $50 billion
3. China and Nepal just announced to establish strategic partnership during the first day of formal state visit of President Xi (Xi to India is informal).
4. India, under Modi, initiated Dolkam incident did not achieve anything, but through the failure of it, Modi learned a lesson, i.e, challenging China by force is useless and stupid.
5. China tried to be friend with India right after the establishment of PRC at 1949, however, India's behavior showed it does not cherish China's friendship, as shown in 1962 Nehru's forward polity by sending India troops into China's territory. China was forced to have war with India and defeated India, and learned that India is not friend of China. for now China just wants to make the Sino-India situation at peace and focus on the eastern side of China, once that issue settled (will not take too long) and turn back to the west, since India is still occupying about 60,000 s km of China's territory, we call Tibet South.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
India's real GDP is only $1.77 trillion, not as it claimed at $3.16 Trillion in 2021. to see real strength of a country, not to see what that country claimed GDP its (as India) but check what the real money the government can spend. in 2021, US collected tax revenue income was about $4 trillion, with budget about $ 6 trillion with $2 trillion deficit, China income was $3.2 trillion, spending was $3.85 trillion, guess what was India's spending in 2021? $ 400 billion, that is only 1/9.25 of China, that is how much money Indian government can spend, 1/9.25 of China, assume China and India government spend the same percentage of GDP, that is 22.5% of total GDP, real India GDP is only $1.77 trillion. you may claim you have whatever, $5 trillion, 10, 20, whatever, the real money you can spend is in your budget, that reflects your real GDP. so do not be so happy that you are taken over UK, UK 2021 total budget $1.3 trillion, that reflect, still 3 times more than India can spend.
3
-
this just showed India real level in its space program and its industry level. for the proud of India, India likes to do vanity things, but not concentrate on rising the level of its industry and basic for space program. examples are:
India likes to boost so called "mars mission" and 104 satellites by one launch, but they would not tell you that for the mars mission, India needs the instructions and guidance from NASA and its deep space network, without it, India cannot do anything like that, since India only has 1 ground station, for 104 satellite, that heaviest one is just about 1 tons, others are just small potatoes and eggs, for space it is what payload of a space rocket is count, such as Saturn 5 with capability of 140 tons that is why USA can send men to land on the moon. for India? the most powerful rocket GSLV MKIII, payload is only 4 tons. India has no plan to build more powerful rocket, but instead trying to make cheap small rocket for launching micro satellite into space to make some money. therefore we can predict, India space program has no future, especially it is very dangerous to use this GSLV MKIII for manned program to send 3 astronauts into space in 2022. as I said since GSLV MKIII can only put less than 4 tons into space, so India's spaceship is only 3.7 tons compare to China's Shenzhou spaceship 8.6 tons, and with rocket to send it into space with payload of 11.5 tons.
for Chandrayaan 2 mission, India also depends on NASA's deep space network to get into the moon orbit, that is no problem, then the last 15 min landing, it all depends on the instruments on lunar lander Vikram for measuring and controlling, obviously it failed lost control at last 2.5 km to the destination and crashed into the moon surface. this is not surprise since India is not famous on
precision instrument industry and instrument remote control.
before India can make real progress in its industry, India's space program has no future.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@abhishekkj3662
India's payload capacity for space rocket is the lowest among the countries with space program,
go check your launch record, India never sent anything more than 4 tons into space by itself.
the biggest rocket India has, GSLV MK III with GTO 4 tons, which means, it can only push payload less than 4 tons into an orbit about 170-200 km into space. with total of 640 tons of rocket itself
compare to China's LM-3B, 450 tons, can put 5.1 tons into GTO.
that is why, it will take 56 days for Chandrayaan-2 to reach the moon, compare to Chang'er of China only took 4 days to reach moon orbit,
since LM-3 can put it directly into moon orbit,
Chandrayaan-2 needs first to go into 170 km GTO track and go around earth many times to accelerate to reach the moon.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
The whole thing of the US and India can be divided into 3 parts:
1. Pretty names, such as democracy, or strategic partnership, all these are empty words, do not mean anything.
2. real thing, this part is real, that is India pays huge amounts of money for US weapons, GE 414 is outdated, US would not use it for anything, sell it to make money, India cannot use it to make 5th gen. fighter, it is a waste of money. for the drone, $32 million each to US , sold India for $100 million each, India is just a customer, nothing to do strategic partner, US sells the same to Japan and TW, difference is the US shares the data link from the drone with them, not to India.
3. a pie in the air, this is so called, technology cooperation with US and India, including making chips, or AI or whatever, the problem for this part is, it is mainly not up to the US government, it is up to the individual company of the US , if they think they can make money, they will do that, if not they will not, India is not a good place for them to make money, in the past 5 yrs, more foreign companies moved out of India than moving in, if Ford and GM all fled, they cannot even make cars in India, who can make chips in India for making money? not even potato chips, ,
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@divyaprasad77
1. the strike missed the target entirely, totally failure, it was the India claimed killed 300 "terrorists", no the other side. for India, if really 300 got killed that is a victory, at least showed what you said" destroy terror outfits", as the evidence. however, no such thing happened, therefore ,again, the mission was a total failure.
2. Cry?? nobody cried, however, the mission violated international law and Pakistan's sovereignty, as Pakistan PM said before the attack this kind action would get retaliated, that is what India got, a mig 21 shot down and the pilot got captured in front of the whole world.
3. Pakistan achieve all they wanted to : retaliate and showed their capability of defeating any India aggression. besides showing military capability of Pakistan, Pakistan also showed that they want peace and deescalation of the situation by quickly release the captured pilot, it showed that it is India that wanted the war.
India is a total loser .
2
-
2
-
2
-
@hope2251
you can only mummer this sentence for so many times, you just cannot tell what is the difference. haah :)) you are just so dumb.
Mythology is important part of religion, especially in Hinduism, however, for me, I like mythology, but I do not believe it,
but for religion, the bases of any religion is believing, either believe it or not, it cannot be tested, in religion, nobody is allowed to test if God really exist.
Unlike in science, all hypothesis can and should be tested with experiment.
go back to learn before you show up your ignorance.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
NDTV showed China "only" gets 8.1% in 2021, compare to India's 11.5% as predicted by Gita Gopinath, however, NDTV just did not listen to Gita carefully, she said, for 2021 GDP growth needs to calculate with 2020 growth together, China combined will be for 2020, 2.3% + 2021, 8.1% = 10.4% for 2 yrs or 5.2% a year.
for India 2020, -8%, + 2021 11.5% = 3.5% for 2 years or 1.75% per year.
Using GDP number, India's 2020 GDP should be $2.64 Trillion, with 11.5%, 2021 GDP will be $2.94 Trillion
China 2020 GDP is $15. 63 Trillion, with 8.1% growth, 2021 China GDP will be $16.7 Trillion.
in 2019, China GDP is 14.4/2.87=5.017 times of India's
in 2021 China GDP will be 16.7/2.94=5.68 times of India's
2
-
2
-
Anthony Klan's number was from media count not from battle field count. totally worthless. US number was from satellite watch the car/truck movement, TASS umber from some guy's head, haha :))
let us assume you own the fight, then the number should not be a question that needs other countries to provide, if you won, you could just stay there, counted the PLA you killed, counted them, and took photos, made video, .......................well, none of those happened, so it only showed, your soldiers fled in a hurry to run for their lives, haha :)))
at that night, only 3 almighty army got killed directly (including Col Babu) , other 17 s were wounded and fall into Galwan river, however, all the other comrades were in a hurry to run for their own lives, nobody bothered to dared to rescue them, they only came back next morning to pick them up from the river, Indian doctors showed, they were dead due to cold, not mainly due to the wound. we admire this almighty army to the bone.
the danger of this kind news is, if India media keeps doing this , it will provoke China release more photos and videos, looking forward to seeing them 😁😁😁
2
-
see long term,
1. put more money into R&D, currently India's R&D is about 0.6% compare to 2.1% of China, since China's GDP is 5 times, therefore the difference is 2.1/0.6x5=17.5, China's R&D is 17.5 times of India, without R&D, India cannot have good industry products with good profit to compete in the world market to export but only agriculture products or iron ores.
2. Put more money into education, currently (2019) India's education budget is $14 billion, compare to China's $685 billion,
the difference is 685/14 shocking 49 times, people say education is the future of a country, India put so low in education is suicidal, to make India have no future.
2
-
2
-
2
-
@tenzinsangpo321
Tibet South, that is the place we like to call, which is the part actually down from ridge of Himalaya, total length is about 600 km and down about 100 km towards India Assam, therefore total about 60000 skm, traditionally controlled by Tibet local government, it is the part we call Tibet South, we do not care exactly if it exactly facing to the south pole or not, the point is it is China's, we will take it back, best by peace, otherwise by force. hah:))
Stupid HK kids is destroying HK, and is now managed by HK local government, we do not want other part, we only want Tibet South, so do not trying your tricks about get others involved, we do not has border dispute with others, but India, be prepared.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@arnablahiri7023
1. Lunar 24 took the real sample back to earth did the analysis, yours is not, only by spectrum.
2. tons?? yeah, by 10 times, your biggest satellite is not more than 3.7 tons, for anything bigger than that, Indian needs to send to Europe for help.
the way you send your GEO satellite is to shoot it into 170-180 km GTO transfer orbit, than use fuels in the satellite to reach the 36000 km orbit, therefore, the satellite real weight in the orbit is 3.6 tons minus the fuel, if you use 1tons of fuel than your real satellite weight is only 2.6 tons.
3. 108 or 104 satellite?? you just need a good timer, to push each egg or potato out at different time, that is about all.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@arnablahiri7023
write so much nonsense, the biggest problem for ISRO is you do not have a really powerful rocket, the best you have is GSLV MKIII, which I have already pointed out, it is not good enough for anything, and India has no money for more powerful rocket, so they stick with this one, trying to use it for everything, with the risk of Indian so to be "astronauts" lives of India, since as I said, its payload is limited to less than 4 tons, so they try to send 3 astronauts with a tiny space ship of 3.7 tons, compare to China's space ship for 8.6 tons,
this is the level of your dear ISRO currently and for the next few decades,
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@rickyravani8834
Historically, Indians were just inhabitants of Indian plain, they were not good at high altitude like on top Himalaya that where Tibetans and Nepali's places, in history, Indians were always defeated by Nepali and Tibetans,
all the border issues today were not created by Indians but by British, India's problem is it did not care what China said, or did, it only claims whatever British claimed, no matter if those claimed by British were legitimate or not, or if India has the ability to inherit them all.
the Han Chinese controls Tibet in Min dynasty, later Qin Dynasty inherited the control. Qin， as the central government of China, NEVER recognized Simla conference, never signed it, never recognized McMahon line. Tibet local government could not represent China to cede any part of its territory to any other country.
Tibet was a part of China after Qin also, since the founding the Republic of China was on the bases of Five Races Under One Union , it was one of the major principles upon which the Republic of China was founded in 1911 at the time of the Xinhai Revolution. Its central tenet was the harmonious existence under one nation of what were considered the five major ethnic groups in China: the Han, the Manchus, the Mongols, the Tibetans, and the Hui.
At the time, China was like in the civil war period of USA, the Confederate might have signed some treaties with British, however, the winning of the Federal in the civil war, all these treaties became void, same in Tibet, after 1950, once again, Chinese central government, represented by PRC, determines border issue in Tibet any treaty signed by Tibet local government conflicting with the central government became void.
Back to the topic, it is very clearly, not just Tawang, but the whole Tibet South, is China's territory, we will take it back, either with peaceful means or by military means.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
as ISRO chairman, Mr. K Siwan should have the full responsibility, no excuse for that, he is totally respected in India, however, he sees not very knowledgeable, one example is that just 2 days ago when asked about what is the difference between India's lunar landing and China's, he said, the landing sites are different, "India would land on the south pole, but China's landing was on equator region", that is totally wrong, Change 4 of China landed also on the south pole but only on the moon's dark side.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
@Ashish14101984 as you said, mind your own business, how China treats her hero is not your concern, for any other country, 20 army killed will get retaliated, for India, it is nothing, just say some empty words and do some showing off, that is all, what a shame, they were killed for nothing.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@732anoop
that was in 1959-1962,not in 70s
China had regularly famines in her history due to climate and political reasons and limited arable land.
compare to India, India has 25% more arable land than China,
however, now China's total grain yield is 3 times of India's
average Chinese has 460 kg grain per capita
India just has about 200 kg, that is the amount of grain for Chinese in 1960s, at this amount in China famine will happen,
but in India, due to the warm weather, people consume less and can survive.
in another words, the level of your agriculture is about the same as in 1960s of China.
famine in China is a history for the past, \
that is how China far ahead than India in agriculture
nowadays, India farmers cannot even afford for soap or tooth paste. go to watch you own media about this。
1
-
@omega supreme
1. i do not represent China government, and youtube does not belong to India, therefore I can say anything I want to
2. use what kind tooth paste is up to you, however, for those people who want to use commercial one cannot afford to buy it, that is fact in today's India's rural areas.
3. Hinduisms is the way for current BJP to unite India and as their way or rising India nationalism, however, it is useless for building a modern country, for that you need science and logic, which in none in Hinduism
4. diversity means remain poor? a good and capable government can unite all of them work for a sole purpose, you mean India government is not capable of doing that?
5. if you logic is true, the USA occupied whole north American,
India government officially recognize TW, HK and Tibet are all part of China, you should bark at your government, not at me.
6. China's military power has already present in India ocean, read your own news, they have spotted many times that China's submarines in IO. as for China is alone?
yes, it does not matter, in 1962, China defeated India, who came to help you?
also you should ask if China is afraid of being alone?? tell you something your school failed to teach you, in Korean war, China fought USA lead 16 countries formed UN force, do you know what happened?? just in 3 month time, China PLA pushed USA lead UN force from China border back 500 km to 38 parallel line, and hold there for the rest time of the war and kept there today by NK army,
as for military power, it is just another failure for current India government, due to mainly the reasons I said at the beginning.
1
-
@omega supreme
1. I do not give a shxt if you think it s a lie or not I just write what I want to , I have no right?? hah :)) what can you do about it?? haha :)) who do you think you are??
ha :)) so stupid.
2. again, it is reported by your media in here.
3. whatever, as long as it s poor and weak.
4. it is your logic not mine, you just said the diversity makes India difficult to make any progress, the reason is your government does not have the capability for it.
5. using USA to explain that what you said TW, HK and Tibet are not China's is just BS.
then you have not answered, why your government recognize all of them are part of China?? your government is weak and afraid of China?? why not stand up like you did, tell the world?? hah :)) so pity you cannot represent your government, since you are nobody,
6. whatever, the fact is you were defeated, ha:)) want to try again??
7. it is our China's right, what can you do? again, nothing, just barking is useless.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@hope2251
recently in the JOurnal of Science, an India scientist published a paper about India government providing funding for this so call ancient technology, he called it "Pseudo Science", for example, in your "religion" there was a women gave birth to 100 kid, a vice president of an India university said, this shows ancient Indians knows about human stem cells science and technology, hah :)) this is totally bullshit, and India government is providing money for this kind pseudo science, this is a shame of India, a shame from India to the scientific field of the whole world, it just shows the totally stupidity, nothing else.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@hope2251
Congress represents the elite sections of India, not for majority of India ordinary people, that is why BJP won,
BJP uses Hinduism trying to get different tribes and ethnic group united, which is working, however, just as I pointed out, Hinduism can be used to unite India, but cannot be used to develop India, for that, India needs science and technology and logic way of thinking, not religions way of thinking.
therefore, back to my conclusion before:
India is a country without any future.
or there is one, go the way of China,
but just you reject, it is not possible.
therefore my conclusion stands.
1
-
1
-
1
-
India’s Disgrace
By Derek Lowe 15 February, 2019
Now we can (unfortunately) add another one to the list. The Hindu nationalist movement in India has been moving into science and medicine in recent years, making claims about ancient discoveries and remedies that are completely unfounded but appeal to their supporters.
This article at Science will get you up to speed, most unenjoyably. There was an incident last month at the Indian Science Congress where a chemist, vice-chancellor of Andhra University yet, made the claim that ancient Hindus has been doing research in stem cell technology based on a tale from the Mahabharata. You know, back in 1972 I was more skeptical as a ten-year-old reading those Erich von Däniken paperbacks which made similar claims, so it’s not very encouraging to see this stuff showing up in 2019. In fact, from the looks of it, some of these folks are citing the exact same verses in the ancient epics, and why the hell not, I guess.
Problem is, this is not some lone crank:
Some blame the rapid rise at least in part on Vijnana Bharati (VIBHA), the science wing of Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS), a massive conservative movement that aims to turn India into a Hindu nation and is the ideological parent of Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party. VIBHA aims to educate the masses about science and technology and harness research to stimulate India’s development, but it also promotes “Swadeshi” (indigenous) science and tries to connect modern science to traditional knowledge and Hindu spirituality.
VIBHA receives generous government funding and is active in 23 of India’s 29 states, organizing huge science fairs and other events; it has 20,000 so-called “team members” to spread its ideas and 100,000 volunteers—including many in the highest echelons of Indian science.
The former head of Indian defense research, for example, says that he firmly believes in the powers of gemstones to influence human health. Narenda Modi himself claimed a few years ago that the transplantation of the god Ganesh’s elephant head onto a human was an example of outstanding ancient Hindu surgical techniques. And if that sort of thing doesn’t make you want to bury your head in your hands, try this:
Critics say pseudoscience is creeping into science funding and education. In 2017, Vardhan decided to fund research at the prestigious Indian Institute of Technology here to validate claims that panchagavya, a concoction that includes cow urine and dung, is a remedy for a wide array of ailments—a notion many scientists dismiss. And in January 2018, higher education minister Satya Pal Singh dismissed Charles Darwin’s evolution theory and threatened to remove it from school and college curricula. “Nobody, including our ancestors, in written or oral [texts], has said that they ever saw an ape turning into a human being,” Singh said.
Excellent. The first time I remember hearing that one was from Mr. Smith, an elderly man who lived next door to us in my small Arkansas town in the late 1960s. He had the exact same line about apes and humans, and went on to inform me that moon landing program was a hoax and that dinosaurs never existed (“Just a bunch of old bones they stuck together”) As a six-year-old fan of NASA and defender of the honor of dinosaurs, these claims did not go over well with me. My 1968 visions of what the world would be like in fifty years tended towards space travel and flying cars, and most definitely did not include national ministers of science taking the side of Mr. Smith.
Needless to say, India has produced great scientists (Hindu and otherwise) who have done great work: Bose, Raman, Chandrasekhar, Ramanujan, Khorana and many more. But the country’s scientific record is dishonored and mocked by this sort of thing. There are many prominent Indian researchers speaking out against these idiotic statements, and I support them wholeheartedly. Science in general is dishonored by attempting to impose nationalist or religious criteria on top of its underlying principles. Those principles? To find out the truth about the natural world, to validate it by careful and repeated experiment, to build on that knowledge wherever it may lead. To understand physical reality, in other words, to work with it as it is and not to play games by believing only what it makes us feel good to believe.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@hope2251
I knew you would fall into my trap since you have an empty brain. haha :))
China do not use google or youtube or facebook, because China uses its own versions for them, ever heard of "wechat"??
Indians use google youtube facebook, and send all the money to US, at the same time, China kept all the money in China, haha :))
do you know who is the richest man in Asian?? Mr. Pony Ma, he own Tencent, which is a company worth $500 billion,
do you know how big your famous Infosys worth?? $43 billion, haha :))
now tell me, who is smarter, China government or yours??
haha :))
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@yorkshireway150 of course you do whatever you do, as long as you like, it is totally fine with me,
your western style "democracy" and "freedom" are like opium, they make you feel good about yourselves, make you cannot see the fact and reality, and at the same time, they are killing you, to make your country without future and hope,
as you said, you are happy with the way you are, just as a guy addicted to opium, he would also be very happy with the way he is
fine, enjoy,
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
what it means is, for this year GDP growth, needs to consider together with last year's growth, officially India last year was -7.3%, with this year, 9.5 % so for 2 years average is (9.5-7.3)/2=1.1(%) each year.
compare to China, last year 2.3%, this year, (assume 8%), that is (2.3+8)/2=5.15(%), China first 6 months of this year growth is 12.7%. what is India's for the same period?
1
-
Izno Iznogoud Indians are very famous with their big mouth, they do not have concept if they claim something they need evidence to support, for them, as long as they say something big or heard someone said something, as long as it satisfies for themselves, they would believe it is true and in this case, to justify they bought Rafale which is not stealthy fighter.
In basic physics concept, so far for human knowledge, radar is the best way of detecting a plane, stealthy fighters can greatly reduce the ability of radar detection, as simple as that,
meter length wave radar or whatever, can detect stealthy fighter, that is OK, however, it cannot be used for missile to lock on the target, for that missile still needs shorter wave length, such as X band, as fire control radar.
you can detect, but you cannot do anything until you get hit by enemy's missile, how sad that would be?? lots of IAF pilots will be invited to have tea either in Pakistan or in China. haha :)) it is Delicious. haha :))
1
-
1
-
1
-
Izno Iznogoud as for meteor, just like what I said before, it is just basic physics, that RADAR can detect much farther than your "electrio-optics", what about in cloud situation?? can it detect anything?? hah, also, as I said before, even it can, it wont work with Meteor, understand?? that is 2 different thing, meteor has no OSF-IT, nor QWIP in it, it just has a small, (since it is on a missile, much smaller than on a jet) active radar, it need to lock on the target, but when you facing a stealthy fighter, the range it can lock on is greatly reduced. understand now?? this is all common sense and basic physics.
you may use meteor to shoot down your mig 21 or su-30MKI easily, but not on a stealthy fighter.
1
-
Izno Iznogoud that is why the whole world put stealthy fighter as 5 generation fighter, no one put Rafale in that category, that is why French themselves is now developing a stealthy fighter, they call it 6 th gen, no matter what they call, they put stealthy capability in the new fighter, if all as you said, that is just wasting money,
the sad fact is that India is still getting less than 5 G fighter in this world of 5 and above generation fighters, no matter what you boast your Rafale, there is a generation gap between it and a 5 th generation fighter.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
the worse enemy's close and loyal friend must be the enemy, by doing this this country demonstrate it is enemy of Israel, Russia, UK and US, of course, China too. thank you. you need this. 😁😁😁With this, we know the true face of India, just a nazi state in Asia, 😁😁😁😁 and we know all the fate of nazi like state, Germany, Italy and Japan. 😁😁😁India will follow all of them 😁😁😁
this country is desperately trying to find a national hero which they have none so the only choice for them is to choose a nazi. just amazing!😁😁😁
Subhash Bose established Free India Center in Berlin and created the Indian Legion out of Indian prisoners of war. Its members swore the following allegiance to Hitler and Bose:
“I swear by God this holy oath that I will obey the leader of the German race and state, Adolf Hitler, as the commander of the German armed forces in the fight for India, whose leader is Subhash Chandra Bose”.
1
-
1
-
Under Modi, India is in the edge of total bankrupt, still dreaming to be a superpower, Harvard Business Review reported "Less than half of the 950 million working-age population is actually employed""Bleak as this statistic is, the reality is worse. According to the Periodic Labor Force Survey, some half of all those workers are self-employed, a category that includes “unpaid helpers in family enterprises,”___Harvard Business review, by Bhaskar Chakravorti July 19, 2024,
Due to the lack of jobs in India it can negatively impact its economic growth rate:
Lower purchasing power: When there are fewer jobs, people have less money to spend, which can lead to a decrease in consumer demand.
Reduced productivity: Unemployment can make it harder for the economy to be productive.
Increased government burden: Unemployment can increase the amount of money the government needs to spend.
Limited investment and consumption: Unemployment can make it harder for people to invest and consume, which can slow economic growth.
Poverty and income inequality: Unemployment can make poverty and income inequality worse.
Social unrest: A high unemployment rate can lead to social unrest.
According to McKinsey, if India doesn't improve its employment rates, it might not be able to achieve its goal of 7–8% annual GDP growth. This could also delay India's plans to become the world's third-largest economy by 2030.
No jobs, means no income, no income means no consumption, 90% of rural spend only $64 per month, and 10% spend $21 a month.
1
-
1
-
1
-
that is nothing, at least it is in China side of LAC, and LAC mean line of actual control, and it means what it means, China is actually controlling the area, so no cry needed, even LAC is not the border, we do not recognize British set "McMahon" line as the border (India should not either), our border is at we call "traditional historical border" in South Tibet, which is 150 km south of Tawang to near the bottom of Himalaya, 40 km to Tezpur (Dowang Bari Dafala) . so be prepared, we will gain more area of "actual control", next step is take Tawang (which was illegally occupied by India in 1951) back to China
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
China said China would SOFT land on the moon, then China soft landed on the moon. India said it would soft land on the moon, then lander smashed into pieces, see the difference??let me tell you what difference is , for present, China's lunar rover is still working on the moon, India's lunar rover is in pieces, cannot move on the moon, that is the difference. China said "will", it showed it worked, still workingIndia said "will", nothing is working
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1. at Galwan, Indian army got 20 killed, 76 wounded, 10 captured, compare to 2 killed 3 wounded, 0 captured at China side. India army can no longer go to patrol in PPT 15.
2. At Pangong Lake, north bank, Indian Army cannot get back Finger 4.
3. At Pangong lake, south bank, PLA occupied Helmet Top and Black Top, which are over looking Chushul where Indian army stationed.
4. At Pongong Lake, Indian army Tibetan special force, a commando was shot to death by PLA.
5. Along LAC at Ladakh, China PLA occupies all the important points, and strengthening all the positions what PLA has already held. Indian army does not have any effective counter measures.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
simple comparisons of India's lunar lander Vikram and China's Change4
1. Vikram weight 1470 kg, Change4, 1230 kg
2. Pragyan rover, 24 kg, Change 4 Yutu rover, 140 kg
3. life for Pragyan 14 days, Change4 Yutu rover, over 9 months now, still working
4. engine, Vikram has 5 engines, each has 800 N, total, 4000 N, China Change 4, 1 engine power 7500 N.
5. power/weight ratio: Vikram, 4000 N/1470 kg = 2.72 N/Kg
China Change 4, 7500 N / 1230 kg = 6.098 N/Kg
6. temperature control, Vikram, none, so only can stay on the moon for 14 earth days,
Change4, yes, already worked for 9 months, still working.
1
-
1
-
Almighty Strong Glorious Proud, Brave, made of Iron and Steel, battle hardened, with full fighting experiences, all 8 feet tall, Indian army armed with all the most advanced weapons from all over the world (Russia, Israel, USA, France, Germany, Sweden . you name it) and spend so much Indian people hard earned money as military expenses for so many year should be ready to fight and win a war against all paper made PLA with all copied weapon, to revenge for the total miserable lost of 1962, do not just talk and since you know China cannot be trusted, why waste time?? that is not what Indian people feed you and made you so fat all these year for. your duty is fight and die for your country and for India's glory,
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Indians need to do a simple math to calculate, for reaching $5 Trillion from current under $3 trillion in 5 yrs, India needs to have a growth rate for more than 10% every year for the next 5 yrs. go figure yourselves to see if it is possible.
from past 5 yrs, we can predict,
in 2014, India's GDP was $2 Trillion, China was $10 Trillion, 5 times difference, now after 5 yrs under PM Modi (so he cannot blame Congress anymore), India's GDP is $2.72 Trillion, China is $13.6 Trillion, 13.6/2.72=5, still 5 times. it shows despite India's claims that India's growth rate is faster, the actually data showed it is not the case, the rate is the same but with China's total amount per yr is 5 times larger than India's.
the fact is the fact, whether you optimistic or pessimistic, you all need to accept it, dream or slogan wont help much.
1
-
In a broadcast to the Indian nation on November 2, 1947, independent India’s first Prime Minister, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, said,
“Let me make it clear that it has been our policy all along that where there is a dispute about the accession of a State to either Dominion, the decision must be made by the people of the State. It was in accordance with this policy that we added a proviso to the Instrument of Accession of Kashmir.” – (White Paper on Jammu and Kashmir, p. 45)
In his broadcast on All India Radio, the Indian Prime Minister also said,
“We have declared that the fate of Kashmir ultimately has to be decided by the people. That pledge we have given, and the Maharaja (Maharaja Hari Singh) has supported it, not only to the people of Kashmir but to the world. We will not, and cannot, back out of it.”
while Kashmir people showed:
“A whopping 77 % are firm in their belief that a solution to the Kashmir problem does not lie within the framework of the Indian Constitution, and a clear 72% say categorically that it is independence alone which can bring peace in the violence-riven Valley.” – (Outlook India, Issue October 1995)
Modi now just ignore whatever Kashmir people want, but just send thousands of Indian army, arrested local leaders and cut off local communications and issued martial law to the region to force to make Kashmir (India controlled) as a part of India.
1
-
1
-
@kukush1071 you need to learn things more carefully, Mach 24 is the terminal speed, many of mid range ballistic missile will have that speed,
I have told you google it, China tested DF 4 with 5500 km in 1970, put into service in late 1970s and early 1980s,
after 50 years, you are still testing Agni 5
in 2018, after Doklam, China tested it again, it just worked fine as new, enough for India.
our more advanced missiles are for US, you do not deserve them,
why nuclear bomb need 10 meters accuracy??
I am sure DF - 4 can find Dehli.
that is accurate enough
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
this is one of the problems of the so-called "democracy” with voting, democracy on its definition should be majority rule, however, using US president election as example, for years, voter turnout would about 60%, and mid term would about 40%. shared almost equally with 2 candidates, in 2016, Hillary got more popular votes, but Trump got more elector vote, so that is about 30% of total population, that is not "majority".
2ndly, Majority does not mean they can make correct decision, throughout the history, in any country, usually few wise men/women led the country into prosperous, ancient Athens democracy got Socrates killed and the state country defeated.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Nobody in this world especially the western countries really want to help India, all they want but just to make some money from India, India is so proud of they have so called, so many "friends" in the world, actually that is just in names, such as Quad, which is totally useless. Either they want India to be a tool for them (such as USA) or money cow (all western countries) that is about it, on the contrary, China and Pakistan are really good iron brothers, we will fight for Pakistan if needed as we did for North Korean against USA in 1950s, all the weapons we used were purchased from borrowed money from Soviet Union, after war, we paid back (mainly by agriculture products such as fruits and meat products), that is a real friend did, any other country in this world will do this for India? None.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
As for Pangong Tso, if you check the original map of Aksai chi, you will see, so called Finger 4 and Finger 8 are the border line for Aksai chin, Aksai chin look like a frying pan on map, the pan handle lines go through, at right side, finger 8, and at left side, finger 4. Since China claims the whole Aksai chin, therefore the LAC will be at Finger 4 for China, but for India(since India claims Aksai chin too) it would be at finger 8.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
launch 7-15-2019, land first week of September, almost 2 months, Compare to China's Chang'er, reach Moon orbit only 4 days, and go around it and land in a few days later.
GSLV Mk III, 640 tons, GTO capacity 4 tons, compares to China's LM 3 B, only 450 tons with GTO capacity 5.1 tons.
4/640=0.00625， 5.1/450=0.01133333333， so the ratio of payload/total weight, China's LM-3B is 1.81 times of GSLV Mk III
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
India is a country without and cannot produce any hero so it has to choose a Nazi as its national hero, this so called Indian army was a puppet of Nazi and Imperial Japaneses army, and JP army killed many Indians too, however, this army was an ally to it. By doing this, India stands with Nazi and JP during the time Axis countries, and in the opposite to Allies of the time led by USA, Soviet Union, Republic of China and United Kingdom. the funny thing is India wants to be the permanent member of UNSC, they forgot or they do not understand UN was established by the Allies to against the emerge of countries like Nazi Germany and Imperial JP and such alike, India's stand on Bose is totally against the principles of UN. therefore it will be only a dream that India will be allowed to be a permanent member of UNSC.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1