Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Rafale Jets To Give India Edge Over China, Pakistan: New Air Force Chief" video.

  1. Rafale is not stealthy, "of course"???haha :))do not cheat yourself. wont work in real war.
    3
  2.  @clavier2560  ：）） ha :))who told you that??you mean F22 and F35 are all wasting of money?? "good manoeuvrable airplanes" ??? do you know no matter how good it is, the max G cannot be bigger than 9??but air to air missile can get to 30-40 G easily??
    2
  3.  Izno Iznogoud  Indians are very famous with their big mouth, they do not have concept if they claim something they need evidence to support, for them, as long as they say something big or heard someone said something, as long as it satisfies for themselves, they would believe it is true and in this case, to justify they bought Rafale which is not stealthy fighter. In basic physics concept, so far for human knowledge, radar is the best way of detecting a plane, stealthy fighters can greatly reduce the ability of radar detection, as simple as that, meter length wave radar or whatever, can detect stealthy fighter, that is OK, however, it cannot be used for missile to lock on the target, for that missile still needs shorter wave length, such as X band, as fire control radar. you can detect, but you cannot do anything until you get hit by enemy's missile, how sad that would be?? lots of IAF pilots will be invited to have tea either in Pakistan or in China. haha :)) it is Delicious. haha :))
    1
  4.  Izno Iznogoud  in Rafale, it is callled SPECTRA, which has a function of active cancellation of incoming radar to reduce its radar signature, however, it can only reduce about 20%, not enough for being detected. if what you said are true, then USA will buy Rafale too, no need to develop F22 and F35. as simple as that, haha :))
    1
  5.  Izno Iznogoud  as for the G force, OKOK let's say Rafale can stand for 30 G. Happy?? hah, but do you know maximum G a human can stand?? even while wearing special compressed suits, the maximum G for pilot is 8-9G, understand?? so what 11G for?? haah :)) when you said pilot need 10 G to escape missile, I knew you just do not know anything since the pilot may be already died. no need to escape anything. haha :)) that is why I said for maneuver even Rafale can get to 9 G, it is no match to air to air missile since there is no human in a missile. go ask a pilot, when he does 9 G, he is actually in Blackout, that will take a while for him to get back to normal
    1
  6.  Izno Iznogoud  as for meteor, just like what I said before, it is just basic physics, that RADAR can detect much farther than your "electrio-optics", what about in cloud situation?? can it detect anything?? hah, also, as I said before, even it can, it wont work with Meteor, understand?? that is 2 different thing, meteor has no OSF-IT, nor QWIP in it, it just has a small, (since it is on a missile, much smaller than on a jet) active radar, it need to lock on the target, but when you facing a stealthy fighter, the range it can lock on is greatly reduced. understand now?? this is all common sense and basic physics. you may use meteor to shoot down your mig 21 or su-30MKI easily, but not on a stealthy fighter.
    1
  7.  Izno Iznogoud  that is why the whole world put stealthy fighter as 5 generation fighter, no one put Rafale in that category, that is why French themselves is now developing a stealthy fighter, they call it 6 th gen, no matter what they call, they put stealthy capability in the new fighter, if all as you said, that is just wasting money, the sad fact is that India is still getting less than 5 G fighter in this world of 5 and above generation fighters, no matter what you boast your Rafale, there is a generation gap between it and a 5 th generation fighter.
    1
  8.  Izno Iznogoud  tell you a secret, do you know what Serbia shot down F117?? not by a missile, but with a meter wave length radar and Anti-aircraft gun，not by missile, actually, missile wound not work.
    1
  9.  Izno Iznogoud  give you one more little quiz for you to think: for your 36 rafales, what if China send 200 stealthy drones in front each carry 2 air to air missiles and these are guided by J20s behind them? will Rafale shoot the drones (to make you happy, let's say rafale can detect them) with all the meteors?? then what about 36 J20s each carry 4 PL 15 behind the drones? hah :))
    1
  10. Izno Iznogoud all by your big mouth
    1
  11.  Izno Iznogoud  so you mean India just wasted money on S400?
    1
  12.  Izno Iznogoud  evev you have 100000 meteors it cannot lock on stealthy jet before rafale is shot down
    1
  13.  @TOUKOretrotaku  at the G, 10.5, he is in the unconsciousness stage, cannot do anything, cannot operate the plane, usually in the stage of escaping missile attack, until the jet can get back to lower G status, are you Rafale pilot?? show me where you got the information.
    1
  14.  @TOUKOretrotaku  even though it does not matter much, even you add it to 11 G , it will never can match air-air missile's ability of 30-40G.
    1