Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Gravitas | 3 years since Galwan: What has changed?" video.
-
5
-
4
-
India do not know PLA at all, even after 1962 war, they thought PLA would fight India at the a certain fixed position, to shoot each other, that is totally not the style of PLA, PLA do not fight that kind of war, PLA moves, goes around, attack from the back, in 1962 war, the 7th Brigade built bunkers even without shooting open at back, to PLA went around to the back to knock them down, the whole 7th Brigade positions collapsed in just 1 day, and with Brigadier John Dalvi captured by PLA. Then later in Sela pass, India formed strong defense positions, then PLA went around via Belly trail to the back cut off the road 13 at Bomdela, to get the 4th army surrounded, so the defense positions became totally useless, with this news, Indian army just fled, they could go back with the road blocked by PLA, most of them fled everywhere through out mountains, ..................with total near 4000 casualties and anther 4000 captured by PLA
3
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
PR China under CCP founded by Mao, totally different from China before 1949, under GMT (now in TW), PR China never lost any war since its founding in 1949, do not use Nanking in 1930s to judge PRChina.
1. 1950 Korean war, took PLA only 3 months to kick all US army out of Korea
2. 1962, completely wipe out entire India army, took 30000 sq km Aksai chin back to China
3. 1967, not a real war, but a border skirmish, with each side only shot each other with artillery, no real attack therefore, no win or lost,
4. 1969, fight with Soviet Union for an island, today, this island is still in China, and signed treaty with Russia in 1999.
5. 1972, fight South Vietnam sunk multiple Vietnam warships and occupied whole Parcel Islands in SCS.
6. 1979, fight Vietnam, till 1989, took back whole territory, and after that signed treaty with Vietnam to have all the territory in China
7. 1984, fight Vietnam, in 318 sea battle and win to occupy the island in SCS
8. 1987, fight India, and won later India PM visited China seek peace
9. 2020, Galwan, no need to say, see photo,
as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
1
-
@moesugumaran5073
3. 1967, not a real war, but a border skirmish, with each side only shot each other with artillery, no real attack therefore, no win or lost,
PR China under CCP founded by Mao, totally different from China before 1949, under GMT (now in TW), PR China never lost any war since its founding in 1949, do not use Nanking in 1930s to judge PRChina.
1. 1950 Korean war, took PLA only 3 months to kick all US army out of Korea
2. 1962, completely wipe out entire India army, took 30000 sq km Aksai chin back to China
3. 1967, not a real war, but a border skirmish, with each side only shot each other with artillery, no real attack therefore, no win or lost,
4. 1969, fight with Soviet Union for an island, today, this island is still in China, and signed treaty with Russia in 1999.
5. 1972, fight South Vietnam sunk multiple Vietnam warships and occupied whole Parcel Islands in SCS.
6. 1979, fight Vietnam, till 1989, took back whole territory, and after that signed treaty with Vietnam to have all the territory in China
7. 1984, fight Vietnam, in 318 sea battle and win to occupy the island in SCS
8. 1987, fight India, and won later India PM visited China seek peace
9. 2020, Galwan, no need to say, see photo,
as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
1