Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Gravitas: How China provokes its neighbours & loses control of conflicts" video.
-
China fought Soviet Union for this small island, China called Zhenbaodao, or Damansky, after that, later, China and Russia signed the border treaty in 2005, to your surprise, the island belongs to China now according to the treaty, so you put it here means later the whole Galwan valley will also be China's in the future treaty with India?? thank you, it just showed, China for defending her territory, would fight and have war with the superpower at the time Soviet Union, ...., then for 2020??
sometimes I wonder if Palki is working for China. she spent time, dig into history, then to show that China fought a justified war with a superpower and won. we will fight what is ours, and our enemy may be stronger or weaker, they may have nukes, lots of nukes or less nuke, all does not matter, we would fight, unlike some other country, all they can do is open a big mouth then endless talks. never dare to fight.
3
-
JOYDEB SARKAR
Results: (the war lasted from 1979-1989, total of 10 years)
1. in 1979, PLA invaded into Vietnam 30-50 km, and farthest is 100 km, occupied, 4 provincial capitals, 1 city, 16 counties.
killed 47700, wounded 7270, captured 2173.
destroyed huge amount of facilities in the area, caused great damage to Vietnam.
for China side: killed 6954, wounded: 14800, captured 280
Casualty and captured ratio: 57143(vietnam) : 22034 (China) or 2.45:1, Vietnam lost 2.45 times more than China side, remember China was an invasion part, Vietnam was just defend.
since the war happened inside Vietnam, civilian casualties was about 300,000
2. From 1980 to 1989, PLA caused another 44000 casualties to Vietnam army, so total casualties of Vietnam army during the 10 year war is about 100,000.
3. PLA took back all the territories claimed by China along the border.
4. PLA took this time to train PLA different divisions by participate the war in rotation. and gain war experience, now PLA will use these experience in the coming war with India.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@leo_reddy8821 I know,
PLA side, 5 wounded at that date, among the 5, 2 died after 8 days,
so total: 3 wounded, 2 died.
your side, 20 killed (or 47?) 76 wounded, 10 captured and released.
this is a very good ratio to remember, in coming real large scale war, this ratio will be the same, number will be time 1000,
so your side,
20,000 will be killed.
76,000 will be wounded,
10,000 will be captured.
thank you very much
1