Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Gravitas | Xi Jinping's China provoking a verbal conflict with India? | WION" video.

  1. The entire issue in the eastern sector between China and India stems from the British's illegal claim to the entire South Tibet through the notorious McMahon Line, a claim that India never obtained before the British, nor could it achieve independently. Now, India is attempting to retain what it could not obtain on its own, but only inherited illegally from its former colonial master. South Tibet was never claimed by the British; the McMahon Line was merely proposed by the British in 1914 as a negotiation tactic with the Chinese government. However, no Chinese government ever agreed to it. This is why Tawang, which should be on the west side of the McMahon Line according to maps, remained under the control of the Tibetan local government throughout the British Raj period, rather than being controlled by the British Raj. Tawang was only occupied on February 14, 1951, not by the British, but by Nehru's dispatched army. The PLA reached Lhasa in October 1952. "Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Pema Khandu today announced that his government will set up a memorial for Major Bob Khathing, an Army officer who commanded a small team of soldiers to establish India's administrative control in Tawang, which borders China, in 1951."
    5
  2. The roots of the conflict between India and China were planted by the malevolent actions of the British. Their history is stained with numerous malicious deeds perpetrated across the globe, affecting various regions.
    5
  3. All of the Indian Army's victories occurred under the Congress party's leadership, not the BJP's. These victories include reclaiming Goa in 1962, securing Bangladesh's independence in 1971, and the success in the Kargil War in 1999. In contrast, the BJP's actions have been less successful. For instance, in 2017 during the Doklam standoff, the army withdrew following China's final warning. Today, the Chinese PLA remains stationed in Doklam, transforming it into a fortified military base and constructing multiple villages in the area. 2019, with Barakot, air strike totally failed, with a mig 21 shot down and pilot got invited to taste fantastic tea Furthermore, in May 2020, 72 Indian soldiers were wounded by PLA forces and hospitalized at Pangong Lake. Then, on June 15-16, 20 soldiers were killed, and 200 others were captured by the PLA. This information was reported in The Express Tribune article dated October 10th, 2021, titled "Indians furious..."
    4
  4. yeah, you only care about action, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  5.  @Ace78928  numbers? count yourself, as shown in The Express Tribune article dated October 10th, 2021, titled "Indians furious..."
    2
  6. simple words, nobody cares about your election, simply a clown play wasting money and time.
    2
  7. read a UK scholar's article, about McMahon line, which is the base for for so called illegal Arunachal Pradesh "The Simla Conference as a whole failed when the Chinese Government refused to recognize the validity of the initialling done by their delegate Chen I-fan. The Foreign Secretary to the Government of India concludes that "the Simla Convention has not been signed by the Chinese Government or accepted by the Russian Government and is, therefore, for the present invalid." " JOURNAL ARTICLE TAWANG—A CASE STUDY OF BRITISH FRONTIER POLICY IN THE HIMALAYAS LARS-ERIK NYMAN Journal of Asian History Vol. 10, No. 2 (1976), pp. 151-171 (21 pages) Published By: Harrassowitz Verlag Of course I do not expect any Indian would read or care about the fact nor history.
    2
  8. as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    1