Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "All about INS Arighat: India's second nuclear submarine | WION" video.

This thing is totally useless. It's so tiny that all it can carry is the K-15, which has a range of only 750 km and might even fall back on its own head. In comparison, China's SLBMs, with the JL-2 having a range of 8,000 km and the JL-3 with 15,000 km, are far superior. India's much-vaunted K-4, with a range of 3,000 km, is still in the testing phase, launched from a 'submerged underwater platform.' The K-4 is too big to fit into the Arihant or Arighat submarines. For the next four so-called nuclear subs, the situation will be the same since all of them will have the same diameter. Therefore, none of them will have any real capability for 'nuclear deterrence from the ocean.
4
as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."🤣😂
3
congratulations, but this time , please remember to close all the doors, do not let sea water to get inside to submerge the nuclear reaction room, like it did in Arihant. haah :))
2
How to Sink a $3 Billion Dollar Submarine: Leave a Hatch Open Perhaps the most embarrassing incident was the near-sinking of India's first nuclear submarine, INS Arihant, in 2017 due to a hatch left open, resulting in extensive repairs and a year-long inoperative period.Jun 5, 2024 ____National Interest
2
you are coming? haha :)) well, that is not important, more important is when you are leaving, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
2
they do not need enemy to destroy , they can do it themselves. INS Sindhurakshak (Sanskrit, for Protector of the Seas)suffered a major fire and explosion on 14 August 2013 and sank at Mumbai's naval dockyard with the death of 18 crew members. The real reason is the crew was playing with the torpedoes. , with this kind crew who needs enemy?>???????
2
@LS59 as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."😅🤣😂
2
Let me tell you the truth about how India wasted all that money on this project. The diameter of this submarine, like the INS Arihant, is 10 meters, which can only fit the tiny K-15 missile. However, the K-4 missile has a length of 12 meters, so it won't fit. In a normal country, they would stop producing this class of subs and start building larger ones with a bigger diameter. However, since no other country will sell nuclear subs to India, India has to make them itself. The problem is that to do this, you need a huge steel plate bending machine. For a 10-meter diameter, you need a roller that can handle 17 meters, as the total should be 33 meters, with half being about 17 meters. To make a 12-meters diameter, you need a machine that can handle about 19 meters. India doesn't have such a huge steel plate bending machine, so they can't make it. But instead of stopping, India continued to spend more money on it. A member of the Indian parliament suggested that since the sub can only carry six K-15 missiles, why not add more? So, they decided to add a 10-meter section in the middle of the submarine to make room for more missiles. However, they didn’t consider that the problem isn’t how many K-15s you have, but that you can’t fit larger missiles like the K-4 in it, since the diameter remains the same. Adding more K-15s doesn't change anything. No other nuclear country will let your sub get within 750 km of it. But India keeps spending (wasting) more money on this, so after this one, four more subs of this class (named S4, S5, etc.) will be built. Well, it's your money; waste as much as you like.
2
you jumped out just to prove what I just said :"The pity here is that not a single person from India can argue with me on the specifics, especially regarding the technical details of their own weapons. All they can do is resort to personal attacks, which won't help. It only shows their lack of manners, nothing else."
2
you are coming? haha :)) well, that is not important, important is when you are leaving, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........." 🤣😂😂
2
the reason is not you do not copy, such as in your drug industry, your directly copy western drug, and your government issued law to protect this copy. the fact is you have no ability of copying, for Su 30 MKI, even you have license from Russia, India still needs to buy directly over 1500 parts and raw material from Russia, and cost of making in India is more expensive than direct buy from Russia
2
The pity here is that not a single person from India can argue with me on the specifics, especially regarding the technical details of their own weapons. All they can do is resort to personal attacks, which won't help. It only shows their lack of manners, nothing else. If you can't even argue with an ordinary person from China, how can India fight China, which has millions of much smarter people in its military and defense industry? Your accusations of 'copying' or 'stealing' won't help you because, no matter what, we have far superior weapons with a generational gap compared to yours.
2
@Kaymcgi see, you just jump out to prove what I just said, thank you,
2
@rockykk-h7b 1962 fought in mountain, 2020 fought in mountains, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
2
@nirajsanu528 the reason is not you do not copy, such as in your drug industry, your directly copy western drug, and your government issued law to protect this copy. the fact is you have no ability of copying, for Su 30 MKI, even you have license from Russia, India still needs to buy directly over 1500 parts and raw material from Russia, and cost of making in India is more expensive than direct buy from Russia
2
one more good news for India, with Indians here shouting "boycott China", now TATA will buy China made batteries for TATA make EV (4 wheeler) in India.
2
if you save the money on this useless thing, you may , just may, get a single gold in olympics, rank will go up at least 3, so not at 71, but 68? 😆🤣😂
2
@basicknowledge2053 INS Sindhurakshak (Sanskrit, for Protector of the Seas)suffered a major fire and explosion on 14 August 2013 and sank at Mumbai's naval dockyard with the death of 18 crew members. The real reason is the crew was playing with the torpedoes. 😆😅😂, with this kind crew who needs enemy?>???????🤣😂
2
@basicknowledge2053 no need to mention your junk Agni V, with range only 5000 km, even North Korea made ICBM with range over 15000 km
2
@thesenate8477 that is a BS 1. you cannot explain why it got back to test again in a submerged platform after that. 2. 2016 test only flight for 700 km, and claimed its got range of 3000 km?? it is just a joke
1