Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "CNN-News18"
channel.
-
111
-
India is country getting relative weaker year by year, and with no important roles in the important world affairs but only a passive observer. Although it tried very hard to be the leader of the global south, but no other country wants its leadership, they want China, but China does not want to take the job. Even for Pakistan, in the history, it had 1971, 1999, however, all those had become very remote past, will never happen again, 2019 marked the turning point for India, from then on, it has lost all its military edges to Pakistan, as this time shows, India, besides talking all time time, there is no effective way India can hurt Pakistan in any sense, not even stop the water treaty, let alone military action, India has lost it completely.
38
-
32
-
India, I would like to share what Sun Tze said in his "Art of War" whiten 2000 years ago, "knowing both your enemy and yourself is crucial for success in war". for you, you do not know you, you do not know your enemies either, that guaranteed you will lose. What are you? you are very poor and weak and backward country, 90% of your people with $2 a day. All your limited advanced weapons are imported, will not be replaced or even repaired in time when they got damaged. You can maximum fight for about 2 wks, we can do it for 10 years as we did to Vietnam, No any other country bear responsibility or can afford for your defense, and you do not have anything to pay back for the support from other countries since no such support will be free. China stand with Pakistan, you like it or not, it is a reality and fact, it is so close, just next door. Russia will not fight China just for you, US is too far way and also with no reason fight China for you. no need to expand this , you are no way out.
24
-
19
-
14
-
14
-
12
-
Have you noticed that Modi no longer makes the kind of specific promises he did 5 or 10 years ago? None of his big promises were fulfilled, leaving them as empty pledges. For instance, the promise to create 100 million jobs in manufacturing actually saw a decrease from over 60 million jobs to just 27 million. Similarly, the promise to double agricultural workers' wages has not materialized, and instead of raising India's manufacturing GDP from 16% to 22% by 2022, it dropped from 16% to 13%.
Now, the only big goal left is making India a developed country by 2047. However, that's another pipe dream. If India wants to reach China's current GDP of $18 trillion to qualify as a "developed country," it would need to grow at over 7% annually for more than 23 consecutive years. Unfortunately, India's growth rate has already fallen from 8.3% to 6.7%, and it’s expected to drop further next year. So, this last promise of Modi’s will also remain unfulfilled. That's why he is now focused on flying around the world talking about world peace, which no one seems to take seriously.
12
-
7
-
6
-
"Farmers' income would double by 2022, this is a promise I would assure our Indian farmers.."
- Modi, 2019
"China has bullet trains, so are we Indians too, very soon. Our 508 km Sabarmati-Mumbai bullet train, would be a reality before August 15, 2022.."
-Modi, 2018
"Make in India would end China's era as the factory of the world .."
-Modi, 2015
"I will create at least 20 million jobs a year until there are not enough workers if elected as the PM of India.."
- Modi, 2014
"When we Indians celebrate our 75th year of independence in 2022, I shall present to you all, India's very first bullet train.."
- Modi, 2017
"India will send its first astronauts to space before independence day 2022, this is not a promise but a guarantee.."
- Modi, 2018
"Give me 5 years as the PM of India and people won't even remember there was once something called pollution in India.."
- Modi, 2014
"If I'm the PM of India, Pakistan and China would be so scared of India's power, they would think twice before attempting any funny moves on India.."
- Modi, 2014
"Give me 6 years and corruption would be a thing of the past in India.."
- Modi, 2014
"We will build 100 smart cities within 5 years in India to the point where Americans, Japanese, Europeans and even Chinese would want to come and study our smart city concept.."
- Modi, 2015
"Atmanirbhar Bharat Self-Reliant India will end our imports from China, instead, China will even have to import stuffs from us after that.."
- Modi, 2018
"Give me 6 years as the PM of India and everyone in the world would want to come to India to study our achievements.."
- Modi, 2014
Ladies and gentlemen i present to you the Talking Superpowe
6
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
for such kind space travel , due to the earth is around and turning, so there is always time that at certain place (such as India) cannot contact the satellite in space, so you need to have at least 3 ground stations in apart 120 degrees on the earth to contact space probe continuously, NASA and ESA (Europe space agency) all have many ground stations around the globe, it is called deep space network, DSN, China also, beside ground stations, China use yuanwang ships with huge antennas in the different part of the world oceans to do the job, some time ago Yuanwang 5 and 6 docked in Sri Lanka, but not for India, the whole India only has one ground station in Delhi, so India's space travel needs help from NASA and ESA,but have you ever heard your media mentioned them?? they all make it sounds like it is done all by India itself. For India's moon trip, both NASA and ESA helped, this time too, the DSN provided by ESA
3
-
2
-
"Give me 5 years as the PM of India and people won't even remember there was once something called pollution in India.." - Modi, 2014
"Farmers' income would double by 2022, this is a promise I would assure our Indian farmers.." - Modi, 2019
The absolute increase was only 38% till June 2023
"China has bullet trains, so are we Indians too, very soon. Our 508 km Sabarmati-Mumbai bullet train, would be a reality before August 15, 2022.."-Modi, 2018
none
"Make in India would end China's era as the factory of the world .." -Modi, 2015
none
"I will create at least 20 million jobs a year until there are not enough workers if elected as the PM of India.." - Modi, 2014
Manufacturing job dropped from 60 million to 27 million
"When we Indians celebrate our 75th year of independence in 2022, I shall present to you all, India's very first bullet train.." - Modi, 2017
none
"India will send its first astronauts to space before independence day 2022, this is not a promise but a guarantee.." - Modi, 2018
none
"Give me 5 years as the PM of India and people won't even remember there was once something called pollution in India.." - Modi, 2014
hah
"If I'm the PM of India, Pakistan and China would be so scared of India's power, they would think twice before attempting any funny moves on India.." - Modi, 2014
yeah, scared, PAF invited IAF pilot to taste fantastic tea in 2019
"Give me 6 years and corruption would be a thing of the past in India.." - Modi, 2014
:)
"We will build 100 smart cities within 5 years in India to the point where Americans, Japanese, Europeans and even Chinese would want to come and study our smart city concept.."- Modi, 2015
yeah, haha :)
"Atmanirbhar Bharat Self-Reliant India will end our imports from China, instead, China will even have to import stuffs from us after that.." - Modi, 2018
"Give me 6 years as the PM of India and everyone in the world would want to come to India to study our achievements.." - Modi, 2014
ha :)
2
-
2
-
The Himalayas rise to an elevation of 4,500 meters on the Chinese side. Atop these mountains, numerous long-range (4,000 km) early warning radars (AESA) are stationed, providing comprehensive coverage of every inch of India's territory. Any launch is promptly detected within the first 5 seconds, and its trajectory is calculated. If deemed hostile, anti-missiles are deployed to intercept it, ensuring its explosion before reaching the Himalayas. Simultaneously, China's hypersonic missiles, impervious to interception by current defense systems, swiftly reach major cities to the west within minutes.
2
-
2
-
The sad fact for India, except size, India has no military edge over Pakistan, therefore all the small scale military operation India will not win or will not hurt Pakistan in any significant ways, only if India initiate a full scale .. with huge size over Pakistan India can win with one conditions, that is only India and Pakistan involved, however, it is impossible, since China will not let it happen, with China gets in, India will be finished within 2 months time.
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
India's richest 1% of the population owns 40% of the country's wealth, and the richest 10% own 77%. Based on this, we can do a calculation using the total GDP to estimate income distribution.
India's total GDP for 2024 is $4 trillion, with the average income (GDP per capita) being $2857 per year.
Top 1 % own 40% of the wealth, that is $1.6 trillion, and shared by 14 million people, with income for them is $114,286 a year per person.
If 77% of the wealth goes to the top 10%, that amount is $4 trillion x 77% =$3.08 trillion, among it, $1.6 trillion is already taken by top 1%, so it is $3.08 trillion- $1.6 trillion= $1.48 trillion, shared by 9% of India population, to make it for this group to have $11746 per person per year.
The remaining $920 billion (23% of GDP) is shared by the rest of the population, which is 1.26 billion people (1.4 billion total population minus the 0.14 billion in the top 10%).
Now, dividing this $920 billion by 1.26 billion people gives $730 per year per person
Thus, the bottom 90% of India's population has an average income of about $730 per year, far lower than the national average GDP per capita of $2857. The real income for many would be even lower due to wealth concentration at the top.
From the calculation we know, for 90% of the Indian population, 1.26 billion people, the income is $2 a day.
The United Nations defines poverty as an income of less than $2 per day, and the international poverty line is set at $2.15 per day. so that 90% of the Indian population live under the UN poverty line on average, certainly among 90% some got higher income, some got much lower, this is just on average.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
this is just a joke not a hypersonic missile at all, just an air to air missile with a rocket engine, NONE of current hypersonic missiles , go check Russia's or China's , with such huge wings at back, it makes no sense, since with such wings it is impossible to reach hypersonic speed, at hypersonic speed, no need for such huge wings for maneuverability, again, it is just a joke
1
-
1
-
Can old parliament building still work? sure it can, is this new one much better than the old one, not really. Old one is by British, new one, inside is still the same as designed by British. this is no beauty in this building at all, and no meaning. In such parliament building, such as Capital Hill of US or British parliament, they are either round or squared, the reason is, round shape represents heaven, or universe, which means, the power from God. or squared which means the earth, power from the people, none of them with triangle shape as this new one. since it does not mean anything,
1
-
1
-
since Indians all know they are weak against China, so they like to mention quad to scare China, quad is just a joke to China, first of all, it is officially just a talking group, a forum, although India wants it be Asian NATO, others not want to bear responsibility to fight China just for India's sake what for? US wants things back, such as asking Ukraine to pay back with their rare earth resources, there is nothing in India to pay back, no rare earth resources, no oil, no money, ..........
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Under Modi:
1.Economy: The so-called "fastest-growing economy in the world" bubble has burst, with the growth rate dropping from 8.3% to 6.7%, and projected to fall further to 6.4% next year.
2. Industry: The industrial sector continues to decline. Manufacturing's share of GDP has fallen from 17% before Modi took power to 12.84% today. There’s little hope for industrialization since the global market is already saturated.
3. Employment: Job opportunities are scarce, with only 50% of the working-age population employed. Of those, 50% are family helpers, many of whom work without pay.
4. Consumption: With limited job opportunities, there's little money for consumption. India's consumption growth is only half of its GDP growth, which will inevitably drag down overall economic growth.
5. Social Division: Modi's tenure has deepened divisions between religious and ethnic groups.
6. Foreign Relations: India is increasingly isolated. In 2024, 30 heads of state visited China individually, and 51 out of 53 African nations participated in the Africa-China Summit, with very few bothering to visit India.
7. Military: India faces a widening military technology gap with China, with little chance of closing it.
8. Pollution: Despite its relatively small industrial base (manufacturing is only 1/12th of China’s), India suffers from some of the world’s worst air and water pollution.
In summary, we are grateful to Modi for what he has achieved for China by ruining India so quickly.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Trump called Modi "a fantastic man"
Yes, this is a fantastic man, Under Modi, India's manufacturing sector as a percentage of GDP has declined. In 2013, it was 17%, but by 2019, it had dropped to 16%. During the election, Modi promised to raise it from 16% to 22% by 2022. Instead, it fell to 13.3% in 2020, and the downward trend continues. In 2023, it further declined to 12.84%. So much for the dream of an industrialized India. Thank you, Modi Ji.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
total cost is $13.3 billion, among it, cost for submarine is about $860 million each, so total is $2.6 billion, then $10.6 billion for 26 Rafale M, the cost of each one is $400 million each, do you know how much F35C for US ? $89 million. Rafafe M is about 5 times more expensive. and 3-4 times more expensive than J20. Rafale before was $250 million each, same jet for France is $88 million, for Egypt Airforce was$125 million each.
it is your money, waste as much as you like
do a simple math, India GDP is 1/5 of China, India pays 3-5 times more on weapon than China, total average is China can afford 15-25 times (average 20) more on the same level (or better) weapons than India, how can you fight a war with China? we can replace our weapons quickly, you need to order them for others to make them for you, how about we fight a war for 10 yrs? we can certainly exhaust all your imported weapons and totally bankrupt your economy
India is a very poor country, with average income less than Bangladesh, yet, the government just spend huge amount of tax payers money to buy extremely expensive and useless weapons, however in this mother of democracy and the largest democracy the people who paid for this huge money, the ordinary Indian people cannot do a thing about how the government waste their hard earned money, while at the same time India is at global hunger index 107 with 5.7 million kids in malnutrition, what a joke of this kind BS democracy. The worst is, if the weapon can fight China which is the purpose of buying them, in reality, they are totally useless against China more advanced weapons
1
-
it will fail again just like 2, the reason is the basic design of the lander is totally wrong. all USA, USSR and China for the lander with a single engine, India put 5 on 2, and 4 on 3. more engines simply mean more troubles, and more problems, no one tried 4 engines, since the hole in the middle may get attacked by fine powers of the moon dusts, the lander with a single engine in the middle does not have this problem.
for other 3 countries, only take them 3-5 days to get to the moon orbit, for India 54 day?
it is not true India is the first one find water on the moon, it was Lunar 24 from USSR took the moon sample back to earth, and the finding published on 1973
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Under Modi, India's total public debt has reached $6.5 trillion, which is 182% of its GDP, compared to 120% for the U.S. and 82% for China. With such a huge debt burden, India’s interest payments this year amount to $131 billion, which is 24% of the total budget, compared to China’s 9%.
Under Modi's leadership, job creation in India has stalled. A lack of jobs means no income, which in turn leads to reduced consumption, hindering economic growth. India's GDP growth rate has dropped from 8.3% to 6.9%, and is projected to fall further to 6.2% next year. Modi's promise of making India a developed nation by 2047 seems increasingly unrealistic. For India to reach China's current GDP of $18 trillion, it would need to sustain a growth rate of over 7% for the next 23 years. However, with growth already falling below 7%, this target seems unattainable.
1
-
1
-
1