Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "India Vs China: These Two BRO Projects Can Give Army an Edge Against PLA In Case Of Conflict" video.

  1. Modern war, as show in Ukraine, showed, fight with hypersonic missiles, with stealthy fighters, with attacking drones, with long range rocket artillery (with 500 km), China has them all, India has none
    3
  2. Ladakh is not China's attacking point, since it has nothing, but bare snow mountains, currently China has only limited border dispute in the area, only want to push the border back to 1959 line. but due to it is only 400 km to Delhi (air straight line), India had to put great number of army in there, total 200000 of them facing about 50000 PLA. However, the main target of China is to get back South Tibet, by cutting off Siliguri corridor, and wipe out the 4th army stationed in Tezpur
    3
  3. Iraq war showed, no matter how strong your army on the ground, if you do not air superiority, your army is nothing but targets for your enemy air bombs. it is your situation now, so not need to boast your army position, your roads, or how many airfields you are building, totally meaningless.
    3
  4. India's war concept stayed at before WWI, that the fight at fixed position, NAZI Germany with long distance abrupt attacking with tanks and surround the enemy in large number has already changed all this. it is same for PLA. the purpose of India to have this road and air field is to trying to keep the front line with supplies and support in time of war, but India forgot an important point, that is to keep the road safe for transporting troops or supplies and to make the air base safe, all needs to have air superiority, and capability of defend the road or air base from long distance attack do you have it?? no you do not, IAF has nowhere to match PLAAF, nor it can protect the road not be destroyed in war with China's long range artillery, or missiles, or attacking drones
    3
  5. read 100 times, air superiority, without it, you will lose.
    2
  6.  @DeepakKumar-kr8oe  as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  7. the more talk from Indian army officers, the more we know Indian army does not know how to fight a modern war, especially not to China, India learned nothing from 1962 war, learned nothing from PLA In 1962 war, they thought PLA would fight India at the a certain fixed position, to shoot each other, that is totally not the style of PLA, PLA do not fight that kind of war, PLA moves, goes around, attack from the back, in 1962 war, the 7th Brigade built bunkers even without shooting open at back, to PLA went around to the back to knock them down, the whole 7th Brigade positions collapsed in just 1 day, and with Brigadier John Dalvi captured by PLA. Then later in Sela pass, India formed strong defense positions, then PLA went around via Belly trail to the back cut off the road 13 at Bomdela, to get the 4th army surrounded, so the defense positions became totally useless, with this news, Indian army just fled, they could go back with the road blocked by PLA, most of them fled everywhere through out mountains, ..................with total near 4000 casualties and anther 4000 captured by PLA
    2
  8.  @SIDDHARTH9245  I have photo to as proof, you do not , as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  9.  @silverghost5752  no need to read the article, just enjoy the photo, which was taken by PLA, not by Pakistan
    2
  10.  @SIDDHARTH9245  as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    1
  11.  @SIDDHARTH9245  so ?
    1
  12. once war started, the first wave of attack from China will be to use hypersonic missiles to destroy S400, then the sky will be controlled by PLAAF with J20 and J16 and J10C ,none of India's Rafale, Su30 MKI or Mig 21 can do anything, with air superiority established by PLAAF, all roads, camps, bunkers, artillery positions, tanks, airfields, ..............are just practice targets for China
    1
  13.  @SIDDHARTH9245  we are the same Chinese, we will get reunited with peace first, India is different, we have no mercy to India, we will turn India back to 562 tribes soon as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    1
  14.  @SIDDHARTH9245  the fact is the our enemy is really really weak, haha, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    1
  15.  @SIDDHARTH9245  i have fact with photo to support my confidence, you have nothing but a big mouth and with daydreaming
    1
  16.  @SIDDHARTH9245  so what? youtube is not India's, what can you do about it? nothing, you useless pc of sht
    1
  17.  @SIDDHARTH9245  banned or not, I am here, tell me, what can yo do? you pic of useless little sht??
    1
  18.  @SIDDHARTH9245  you look like a sht, haha
    1
  19.  @SIDDHARTH9245  show proof or sht the fk up
    1
  20.  @SIDDHARTH9245  you made statement, you provide evidence how can I prove your BS??? total no brain
    1
  21.  @SIDDHARTH9245  those are BS and lies, you f..l, not as photo, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    1