Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Tejas Mk-2 Fighter Jet Prototype Set for 2024 Rollout with Advanced GE-414 Engine | Details" video.

  1. J10C with P/W ratio, 1.04 Tejas MKII , P/W ration 0.86
    7
  2.  @SIDDHARTH9245  only on paper in your dreams, haha J10c is flying now in both China and in Pakistan, Tejas MKII is only on paper
    6
  3. it is not as good as FA18 right? US is retiring FA18. Tejas MK II only replace GE 404 to 414, the max output power of 404 is 81 kn, 414 is 91 kn, only little better, compare to PAF bought J10C from China, with WS10B engine max power 131 kn. before Tejas MKII out it is already a junk, totally useless against PAF, let alone to PLAAF
    5
  4. Indians still do not get the concept of stealthy means, it is not they cannot be detected, or perfect, the most important is the difference in RCS, as long as it has a detection difference than your jet, it will shoot your jet down, so kid, do not say J20 is not real stealthy, only shows you do not know how it works, Rafale without weapon bay, with 6 missiles its RCS is 10, J20, with embedded weapon bay, the RCS is much lower, less than 0.1. you can say it is not as good as F22 or even F35, which is fine, but important is it much less than Rafale sure to Tejas, so there will be a radar detection difference, which makes J20 can find Rafale or Tejas earlier and lock and fire missile first, then leave the area. understand now?
    4
  5. for those want to "Made in India" jet engine is better to learn why India canceled Kaveri engine, with 5 reasons, none of them can be solved
    4
  6.  @SIDDHARTH9245  BS, J10C has nothing to do with Russia
    4
  7.  @romelojha2428  all current nuclear missiles are not battle proven, so to you they are not working???
    4
  8. ​ @ss304_82  J10C with P/W ratio, 1.04 Tejas MKII , P/W ration 0.86
    4
  9. it is a sad fact, the best jet engine India can get is GE414, but it cannot be used in 5th generation fighter, without 5th gen fighter, nothing in IAF can fight J20, so WTF GE414 for??
    4
  10. When China first put out J20 with AL 31 engine, max power 131 kn, Indians laughed at it , say it cannot do supersonic cruise so is it not a real 5th gen fighter, fair enough, now China put WS 15 with 180 kn on it, totally solved this problem, but now Indians are so happy with GE 414 with max power less 100 kn want to put onto AMCA?? haha. go figure what kind of junk it will be.
    4
  11. people say, a pretty jet is a good jet, just look, how ugly Tejas is, haha
    3
  12.  @SIDDHARTH9245  again, this kid does not understand anything, that is in the dog fight test, in real war, the fight will be BVR
    3
  13. To India, we can beat Indian army in all range of war, from woodsticks to stealthy fighter, haha, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    3
  14.  @ss304_82  haha, why you bother to change it then??
    3
  15. US pilots who flight FA18 (with GE 414 engine) before given a chance to fly F22 to fight FA18, they said, there is just no chance for FA 18 at all, they finish them (FA18) all in 2 min
    3
  16. China sold JF-17 and J10C, India cannot sell a single junk of its Tejas. just fact.
    2
  17. just show a photo , or sht the fk up. as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  18.  @SIDDHARTH9245  as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  19.  @Brubnab  just show a photo , or sht the fk up. as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  20. just show a photo , or sht the fk up. as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  21. it is foolish to compare 21st century to WWII, the difference is there is no generation gap, so quantity mattered, now 1 stealthy fighter can kill 100 none stealthy, the more you make the more you loss, use brain, which you do not have any
    2
  22.  @MRBasu-rg9nw  you know a sht, go check concept of US 6 th fighter, that with canards too, stpd
    2
  23.  manusharma5225  you do not understand, even it is out as in your dream, it is still not useful, since it cannot be used for a real 5th gen stealthy fighter, for stealthy fighter, all of them with jet engine more than 140 kn. F22 with 153 kn each engine, F35, 190 kn,. J20 use WS`15 with 180 kn, Su 57, with 140 kn. yours is no use.
    2
  24.  @dragon89900  with failure rate, all most 50%, your cryogenic rocket engine failed many times. go check
    2
  25.  manusharma5225  not up to you to say that, we sold J10C already, you cannot sell a single junk of Tejas
    2
  26. it has been canceled 5 yrs ago, with reasons as 1. India does not have people with know how for advanced military jet 2. no testing facilities for the engine 3. no industry support for the materials 4. no technical persons available for this kind work. 5. no enough funding for it.
    2
  27. 1. GE 414 is useless cannot be used for 5th gen fighter, 2. even if it can be used for Tejas MKII, assume it is as good as FA18, still not be useful, Tejas MKII , just like Tejas mk1. will not be able to sell a single one to the other country. so GE414 cannot produce in a large number, 3. with limited number of GE414 production, will make the each one cost very high, therefore it will not be able to sell it to other countries. this is a bad cycle, 4. Make in India does not mean you can make the Ni-base single crystal turbine blades for it, you still needs to import the part from the US, 5. Ni-base single crystal turbine blades is already out of date for making more powerful turbine blades for which needs ceramic materials, which are the engines used in 5 th gen fighters with max power output above 140 kn, GE 414 is only 93 kn, (GE404 is 81 kn, Kaveri is 71 kn), compare to F22's engine, 153 kn, F 35 's 190 kn, China WS 15 for J20 180 kn. The US will not provide such kind engine to India.
    2
  28.  @SIDDHARTH9245 you are full of BS, tech transfer of what? do you even know what J10 looks like?? it has nothing to do with Russia, go to learn first before you open your mouth
    2
  29.  @SIDDHARTH9245  kid, you better to back to school to learn things, you are so ignorant on everything, are you shamed of it? I guess not, totally shameless
    2
  30. the difference is there is no generation gap, so quantity mattered, now 1 stealthy fighter can kill 100 none stealthy, the more you make the more you loss, use brain, which you do not have any
    2
  31.  @SIDDHARTH9245  Indians still do not get the concept of stealthy means, it is not they cannot be detected, or perfect, the most important is the difference in RCS, as long as it has a detection difference than your jet, it will shoot your jet down, so kid, do not say J20 is not real stealthy, only shows you do not know how it works, Rafale without weapon bay, with 6 missiles its RCS is 10, J20, with embedded weapon bay, the RCS is much lower, less than 0.1. you can say it is not as good as F22 or even F35, which is fine, but important is it much less than Rafale sure to Tejas, so there will be a radar detection difference, which makes J20 can find Rafale or Tejas earlier and lock and fire missile first, then leave the area. understand now? kid go to learn first,,sht up your big mouth for some time?
    2
  32. the most important for India now is get a 5th gen stealthy fighter, all others are wasting money, since the aim of India is to fight China, China has stealthy fighter, the ratio of killing to a none stealthy is 1:100 , it is science. unfortunately, not any country wants to sell India stealthy fighter, PAF has the opportunity in anytime to get China's J35 stealthy fighter from China in case needed, while India cannot do a thing but taste fantastic tea again
    2
  33.  @SIDDHARTH9245  then you do not have anything better than 414
    2
  34.  @samgeno  NO
    2
  35. I am actually helping you, just all of Indians do not understand, but hey, it is your money, waste as much as you like, I do not give a fk. haha
    2
  36.  @SIDDHARTH9245  sure, with a dumb like you, haha
    2
  37. in military India is in a huge generation gap or generations gaps with China, Indians are still dreaming, China has 1. stealthy fighter (actually 2, J20 and J35.), 2. Hypersonic missiles (many kinds), 3, attacking drones (many kinds), 4 long range rocket artillery (with range 500 km), India has none of them, and will not have them in the next at least 20-50 years. how can you fight China with your old junks??
    2
  38.  @SIDDHARTH9245  our wood sticks have very good quality, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
    2
  39.  @SIDDHARTH9245  yeah, as long as we can beat the sht out of your army
    2
  40. you know a sht, go check concept of US 6 th fighter, that with canards too, stpd
    2
  41. For a jet engine, most important is the high temperature tolerance for turbine blades, the output power is directly related to it, or it will be distorted or burned. The high quality steel alloy can make Kaveri 10, which using it, the max power was 71 kn. cannot be used in Tejas, so India used GE404, with power of 81 kn, still too little, so the junk cannot be sold to any other country. simply total useless GE 404 should used Ni alloy, can stand higher temperature, in GE414, now it should have used Ni-base single crystal turbine blades, which can stand higher temperature, single crystal made the turbine blades stand higher temperature since it can resistant to the pull strength evenly to all direction, GE 414 with power output to 91 kn, may be little bit better version now, not not much. The next generation is ceramic material made of turbine blades, all jet engine with above 150 kn need this kind of engine, also in ceramic engines, there are many generations already, in ceramic engine another import factor is coating for it. In today's world, the US is still number 1, but number 2 is not Russia but China. China has mastered ceramic material made of turbine blades with special coating, so China can make WS 15 with 180 kn. The US only sells GE 414 to India, which is generations behind the best US and China military engine, well if you think the purpose of India to get it is to fight China, which will be totally useless on that. France got the original design wrong, France is also in the lead in ceramic engine material, however, France is only good at making medium sized engine, like the one used in Rafale, with M88 max power only about 70 kn. same for RR so France and RR cannot make 5th gen fighters. India with GE414 is the same, we can predict India will never or in at least 40 years or 50 yrs with no 5th gen fighter, by that time, the world will be in 7th gen fighter era. so we know India will never catch up
    1
  42.  @mth469  why you cannot sell a single Tejas to any other country??
    1
  43.  manusharma5225  yeah, will be out in 40 years
    1
  44.  @User86559  we kill all your junk in a few minutes, no need to have 1500 hours totally waste of time
    1
  45.  @User86559  it is not on paper, WS 15 now already being put onto J20,
    1
  46.  @User86559  who told you WS-15 only 30 hours?? in your dreams?
    1
  47.  @User86559  In terms of service life, the service life of F119 is as high as 6,800 hours, while the service life of China's turbofan 15 is only 3,600 hours,
    1
  48.  @User86559  jet fighter is weapon, not a fancy car, it suppose to be destroyed in war, each air fight only about a hour even a few min, with Russian airforce, they just make engine for a few hundreds hours, that is enough for fighting, China is in btw US and Russia, engine service life is not as long as the US, nor as short as Russian's just enough to shoot down all your junk jets
    1
  49.  @mth469  like you know? so why not they crash like your Mig 21 and your Su 30 MKI??
    1
  50.  @SIDDHARTH9245  stpd dumb kid, what truth, you only have BS!
    1