红火树 RedFireTree
Hindustan Times
comments
Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "26 Rafale-M Jets, Scorpene Submarines To Join Indian Navy Fleet; PM Modi To Ink Deal With France" video.
4
3
We do not need stealthy fighter completely stealthy to radar detect, what importance is only the difference in RCS,. let us just for the purpose of illustration to those do not know anything about stealthy, assume naked J20 and Rafale, just as Indian claimed, J 20 is not stealthy, fine, assume they all have RCS 0.5 which is reported for Rafale, fine, however, one major difference is J20 has internal weapon bay to put medium range 4 PL 15 in in the center and 2 more side bay for PL 10, short range missile, Rafale has no internal bay, it needs to put missile outside, now , RCS of J20 is still 0.5, Rafale with 6 missile its RCA jumped to 10, now the RCS for Rafale is 20 times bigger than J20, this difference will reflect on the radar detect difference, J20 can always find Rafale first, lock it first, shoot missile to it first. and leave the area first, Rafale needs to escape missile attack
3
3
2
not listen to me, at least you should listen to what your former IAF air marshal , he said, "India paid too much attention to the platform, not weapons on the platform, Rafale has no edge over JF-17 III with PL 15 medium range missile" . Now Pakistan bought 24 J10C with PL 15, which is much more powerful than JF-17 III, your Rafale M has no match to it, no need to mention to fight China AC jet, J15, or J35 stealthy fighters.
2
2
2
2
Buddha said, "endless bitter sea in front, repent, the land is nearby", the only key issue between India and China is our land South Tibet is now illegally occupied by India, return it, China will not put any more military pressure to India, so India does not need to spend so much money on useless weapons, but put it into the development of the country in R&D and in education, healthy care, infrastructure, ....................everything will be fine.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
India is a very poor country, with average income less than Bangladesh, yet, the government just spend huge amount of tax payers money to buy extremely expensive and useless weapons, however in this mother of democracy and the largest democracy the people who paid for this huge money, the ordinary Indian people cannot do a thing about how the government waste their hard earned money, while at the same time India is at global hunger index 107 with 5.7 million kids in malnutrition, what a joke of this kind BS democracy. The worst is, if the weapon can fight China which is the purpose of buying them, in reality, they are totally useless against China more advanced weapons
2
2
@amitsolanke1927 i knew it, as I just said,
Indians have no ability to judge nor ability to check the fact and real data, so if a Chinese or a Pakistan says something, then it is must be bad for India, they will not listen and they will go to opposite direction, so in here, just tell the truth, such Rafale M is a just waste of money for India, then Indians will full support for buying it, and waste that money. haha. very predictable.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1