Comments by "Thetequilashooter1" (@Thetequilashooter1) on "" video.

@bubbalo3388 I seriously doubt that. Nothing replaces realtime knowledge. When it comes to future designs, background knowledge is key so that you don’t make the same mistakes. Whenever you’re copying others, it means that you’re always behind. Look at drones as an example. While China has copied US designs, their payloads, duration and range are all inferior. It just shows what’s inside what matters most.
3
@breadnewbie6326 It’s not the opposite. For future research you need to have know how. If you have not gone through the trials and tribulations to build that knowledge, you’re not going to have the same knowledge base as the original creator. It’s why “know how” itself is considered intellectual property, and depending on the technology it can be licensed to others.
2
@breadnewbie6326 What kind of example are you looking for? You mean of Chinese copying? The J-15 floppy fish is a copy of the Russian Su-33. There are tons of examples of Chinese IP theft.
2
@breadnewbie6326 China did copy from the blueprint of the F-16. Examples of advanced Chinese weapons that incorporate American know-how include the Chengdu J-20 and Shenyang J-31 stealth fighters and electromagnetic catapult launch systems. In fact, In 2016 a confessed Chinese spy was sentenced to 46 months in US prison for stealing designs for the F-22. That’s just one of many examples. A few years ago, Russian state media Sputnik had criticized China’s J-15 aircraft for its many drawbacks. Moscow also accused Beijing of reverse-engineering a Russian Su-33 that it brought from Ukraine to produce its own carrier-capable aircraft, the J-15. China steals all the time.
2
You’re the one lying. “Two years after his arrest in Canada, Su Bin, a Chinese citizen you ran Lode-Technology, has pled guilty in a California federal court to carrying out a series of cyber espionage thefts of U.S. military secrets that included the C-17 Globemaster, and Lockheed F-35 and F-22 stealth fighters.”
1
@snizami Yes, it’s an accomplishment, but without stealing the technology they couldn’t have come up with the product on their own. You’re trying to downplay the theft, when it’s well known that both Russia and China have long histories of intellectual property theft.
1
@breadnewbie6326 I know a thing or two about IP and licensing. I can’t tell you how often my office wouldn’t file a patent application. The scientists of course think they’ve invented the next best thing to sliced bread, but in reality a large number of them aren’t worth the patent costs to protect them. I used to be a licensing agent at a Tier One University, and more often than not we wouldn’t even file an application. Some Principal Investigators would file with their own money, and in these cases the University would release the IP to them. Our bread and butter was licensing University IP to the PI’s start-up company. Before boasting about the numbers of patents, you need to look into their value. It’s well known in the IP community that China files many worthless invention disclosures. Google Bloomberg, China Claims More Patents Than Any Country—Most Are Worthless. If you don’t have a subscription with Bloomberg, Google CIGI, Innovation/Intellectual Property, and you’ll find: It’s not necessarily the high numbers of patent filings, however, that turned China into a global patent powerhouse. The rapid increase of patent filings, including the PCT applications, was to a large extent a result of a great leap of patent applications boosted by subsidies of governments at all levels and spurred by the central government’s quantity-first and subsidy-driven instructions to improve China’s patent level. Instead of being innovation-driven, most of China’s patent applications are driven by other motives, such as seeking government subsidy or job promotion, reputation building for individuals or universities and institutions, or acquiring certification as national high-tech enterprises.
1
@Vhvjdow0ajsbcdhcuei3o22-om4sm If that was the case then China wouldn’t need to continue to steal technology, but that’s not the case.
1
@breadnewbie6326 I don’t know why my prior comment didn’t post. Just to keep it short, most of the Chinese patent applications are worthless. China’s led in application for around 12 years, and there’s a reason why China is still behind and stealing from others. Google CIGI, What Do China’s High Patent Numbers Really Mean. What you’ll find is that instead of being innovation-driven, most of China’s patent applications are driven by other motives, such as seeking government subsidy or job promotion, reputation building for individuals or universities and institutions, or acquiring certification.
1
@breadnewbie6326 Google about the value of the patents that have been filed by China, and they’re not worth much.
1
@Ryomichi Reverse engineering only teaches you about the final product. It doesn’t teach you about the learning process it took to get there
1
@breadnewbie6326 Read up about Chinese patents, and you’ll discover they’re mainly worthless. See below. Most of the patents of utility model and design are of low quality and essentially useless. According to Bloomberg, 91 percent of design and 61 percent of utility model patents filed in China became invalid during 2013–2017 due to their holders’ failure to pay the annual fee.
1
@Vhvjdow0ajsbcdhcuei3o22-om4sm It only knows about the final product. It does know about the trials and tribulations that it took to get there. In intellectual property terms it’s called know how. To say that a person who copied the design is just as knowledgeable as the person who created it is ridiculous.
1
@breadnewbie6326 One example of what? Why don’t you read up about Chinese patents. Most are worthless. Just Google it. A good article is from Bloomberg that says “Most of the patents of utility model and design are of low quality and essentially useless. According to Bloomberg, 91 percent of design and 61 percent of utility model patents filed in China became invalid during 2013–2017 due to their holders' failure to pay the annual fee.” Another article that discusses it is from IP Watchdog, Weak Chinese Patent Applications and China’s Burgeoning Patent System.
1
@breadnewbie6326 Look at how China stole the designs to the F-22 and F-35, yet China still can’t build fighters near as capable. There are many examples of Chinese IP theft. You’d have to be completely ignorant to not be aware of it.
1
@breadnewbie6326 How about China’s theft of the Russian Su-33, which made China’s infamous Floppy Fish, J-15? Is that the kind of example that you’re looking for?
1
@kamsunleong6648 Better examples of IP theft are like how Russia stole the design of the Space Shuttle to make the Buran. Russia also stole from the US the Sidewinder missile, a-bomb, the B-29 bomber to make the Tu-4, the Christie suspension system for the T-34 tank, the proximity fuse, guidance systems, the Zircon missile from the U.S. X-51 Waverider, and from the British the jet engine from Rolls Royce. Russia and China both have very long histories of copying. And who says that the ISS is a copy, especially when Russia itself is an ISS partnering country?
1
@Ryomichi It’s fine that you disagree. But there’s no better learning than to build it on your own. When you learn by merely copy what someone else has done you don’t experience all the problems that it took to get to the final conclusion. Those same problems could arise again when trying to improve or even make a new product. For instance, if you copy all the answers from a person sitting next to you during a test you’re not going to learn anything. There’s no better learning than to do it on your own.
1
@breadnewbie6326 Yes, everyone learns from each other, but China copies and steals a lot more. I can't tell you how ofter I read about a Chinese person gettng arrested for stealing from American companies. The number of patents mean little when they're not worth much, Most of the patents of utility model and design are of low quality and essentially useless. According to Bloomberg, 91 percent of design and 61 percent of utility model patents filed in China became invalid during 2013–2017 due to their holders’ failure to pay the annual fee. That explains why one Chinese patent expert stated rather bluntly that only 10 percent of China’s patents have market value and that probably 90 percent of them are “trash.”
1
@breadnewbie6326 Continued from above…”Many terabytes of data related to the F-35 program are believed to have been stolen by Chinese hackers, including information on the F-35’s radar design – such as the number and types of modules used by the system – and its engine, including the method used for cooling gases, leading and trailing edge treatments, and aft deck heating contour maps. Chinese hackers also appear to have obtained material regarding the US Air Force’s F-22 Raptor and B-2 stealth bomber, as well as space-based lasers, missile guidance and tracking systems, and designs for nuclear submarines and anti-air missiles.
1
@breadnewbie6326 There are many cases of Chinese spies going to jail for theft of U.S. secrets. -Xu Yanjun was accused of a lead role in a five-year Chinese state-backed scheme to steal commercial secrets from GE Aviation. - a former Rockwell and Boeing engineer from Orange County, Calif., was remanded into custody this morning after a federal judge convicted him of charges of economic espionage and acting as an agent of the People’s Republic of China, for whom he stole restricted technology and Boeing trade secrets, including information related to the Space Shuttle program and Delta IV rocket. -Two years after his arrest in Canada, Su Bin, a Chinese citizen you ran Lode-Technology, has pled guilty in a California federal court to carrying out a series of cyber espionage thefts of U.S. military secrets that included the C-17 Globemaster, and Lockheed F-35 and F-22 stealth fighters. -Peter Lee a physicist born in China who worked at the Los Alamos National Laboratory and later for TRW Inc., pleaded guilty to lying on security-clearance forms and passing classified national-defense information to Chinese scientists on business trips to Beijing.[34] He compromised classified weapons information, microwave submarine-detection technology and other national-defense data,[28] and the Department of Energy later concluded that his disclosure of classified information "was of significant material assistance to the PRC in their nuclear weapons development program . -Chi Mack copied and sent sensitive documents on U.S. Navy ships, submarines and weapons to China by courier. In 2008, he was sentenced to a 24+1⁄2-year prison term for espionage. There are many many more examples.
1
@breadnewbie6326 Here are more examples: -Ko-Suen "Bill" Moo pleaded guilty to being a covert agent of China. Moo attempted to purchase United States military equipment to send to China when he was arrested by undercover United States agents. Some of the equipment included an F-16 fighter jet engine, an AGM-129A cruise missile, UH-60 Black Hawk helicopter engines and AIM-120 air-to-air missiles. - Fei Ye, and Ming Zhong stole trade secrets in designing a computer microprocessor to benefit China, although prosecutors did not allege that the Chinese government knew of their activities. In December 2002, they were charged with a total of ten counts, including conspiracy; economic espionage; possession of stolen trade secrets; and foreign transportation of stolen property. In 2006 (five years after their arrest), they pleaded guilty to two counts each of economic espionage. - Anne Lockwood, Michael Haehnel, and Fuping Liu In February 2009, three former employees of Metaldyne Corporation were sentenced to prison terms in federal court in connection with a conspiracy to steal confidential information in order to assist a Chinese competitor, the Chongqing Huafu Industry Company ("Huafu"), of Chongqing, China to compete against Metaldyne in the field of powdered metal parts. - Kevin Patrick Mallory was arrested and charged under the Espionage Act on charges of performing espionage on behalf of the Chinese government.[61][62] Mallory was given special communications devices for communicating documents to Chinese intelligence agents, including documents classified as top secret. -Xu Jiaqiang pleaded guilty to charges of economic espionage, theft, and possession and distribution of trade secrets, after having been accused of stealing the source code to IBM software. The list goes on and on…
1
@breadnewbie6326 Google List of Chinese Spy Cases in the United States, and you’ll find a very long list of Chinese spies who have been convicted of stealing US technology for China.
1
Google List of Chinese Spy Cases in the United States, and you'll find a very long list of Chinese spies who have been convicted. And that's just the US. There are many cases from other countries, too. @breadnewbie6326
1
@breadnewbie6326 They’re not direct copies, bolt for bolt, screw for screw, etc., but they were heavily influenced from stolen documents. Like I said, just Google about all the Chinese who have been convicted of intellectual property theft. You name it, China has stolen it. From missiles, to sonars, submarine technology, aircraft, helicopters, even utility vehicles, China has stolen confidential information to help develop their own equipment. And you can see the influence from the information in the overall designs of the Chinese weaponry. China’s thievery is well known, and it’s why Russia wouldn’t sell the Su-33 to China. China wouldn’t assure Russia that it would not reverse engineer the technology. That’s IP theft. You can play all the word games you want, but China steals a lot of technology from others. Without this theft, the Chinese military wouldn’t be as advanced as it is today.
1
Don't give me that BS. China wouldn't need to hack into systems to just "get an idea from others." Why do you think that Russia wouldn't sell the Su-33 to China? It's because China wouldn't assure Russia that it wouldn't reverse engineer the aircraft. That's a lot more that just getting an idea. Why are living in denial? Google about all the Chinese spies who have been jailed and prosecuted for IP theft. The list is huge, and it includes every kind of weaponry that you can imagine. From various kinds of missiles, aircraft, helos, subs, noise reduction technology, satellite data, aircraft, etc. China has stolen it. China even recently tried to get a Taiwan pilot to fly a Chinook to a Chinese carrier so that China could steal its technology. It's what China does. It steals. You can play all the word games that you want, but it doesn't change reality. @breadnewbie6326
1
@breadnewbie6326 Why are you underplaying China’s thievery? Chinese spies wouldn’t be jailed for over twenty years to just get an idea. That’s absolutely ridiculous.
1
@ex0duzz It’s still theft. China didn’t pay for the technology, and it couldn’t have created its design without stealing the technology from others. Many Chinese spies have gone to prison for stealing technology. They wouldn’t be going to jail if China developed the technology on its own.
1
Moderator, why are so many of my comments being removed? It makes no sense they’re backed up with credible sources.
1