General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
yonathan rakau
Whatifalthist
comments
Comments by "yonathan rakau" (@yonathanrakau1783) on "What if Russia Never Colonized Siberia?" video.
sad settled civilization noise
10
@hugosetiawan8928 france winning napoleonic wars that empire gonna collapsed anyway after he died the system was just ineffective for such large place, if they see napoleon weakened at some point they will rebel all at once
10
@mint8648 why? Look at austria and prussia after napoleon failed in russia, not to mention russia was a french ally at some point, the death of napoleon will be a disaster for the empire
7
@mint8648 it wont be that easy, why do you think countries like those in mesopotamia for example collapsed? Look at hammurabi sucessor, he was a great general and ruler but in the end the number of people that took arms againts him after hammurabi died was even bigger
7
@mint8648 he was having a hard time controlling spain, i doubt he will able to do it for long especially after he died, italian one probably but considering whole europe would see that napoleon death crisis as weak point they will attack all at once and declare independence from spain to austria to prussia and helped by GB
4
@mint8648 dude you need to consider that france was too dominating european theather and nobody wants that, they would just declare war on them and i already prove it by analisis if you keep stubborn and dont accept that fact i give you by analisis go ahead believe in what you want, the continental system and hamsburg empire was different, continental system was incredibly unstable and in the end the hamsburg got kicked out of italy too, hamsburg gave a perfect counter balance to france and the ottoman empire
4
@mint8648 hamsburg was too powerfull that even the pope ask the french to destroy them, in the case of napoleonic france, they would dominate all of europe which is what everyone in europe never wanted at all, the thing is after they were defeated by russian all of those nation declare war on france, whole europe wont allow such hegemon to simply too powerfull but whatever you are wasting my time go ahead
4
@abhinavs8109 ah wait not civilized settled pick the wrong word there
3
@mint8648 continental europe would just break free in the end not forgetting british empire still existed and spain is resisting bitterly but maybe bonaparte would still rule france
3
@mint8648 well, napoleon beat them and they bow down to napoleon as the emperor, thats what i mean, do you think they will let france had such power? the balance of power is broken and i say ONCE NAPOLEON DIED. Its not like if your father a great general your child will be one too
2
@mint8648 he can retain spain as long he live, theres no guarantee that napoleon the 2nd is a good general, he also served in the austrian army then died of fever or smthng so he may be short lived, Napoleon the 3rd however, we already know how he wasnt a millitary genius look at his invasion of mexico, italian wars, etc
2
@mint8648 except if napoleon could have an heir as genius or even more than him which is unlikely seeing how people like hammurabi had an heir yet that heir wasnt as good as him, he wouldnt able to hold spain as austrian, prussia, GB and spain attack at once
1