Comments by "AWResistance" (@AlanWattResistance) on "Sargon of Akkad"
channel.
-
12
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Skyswindler You have to interpret the Bible the way in which is was intended to be read. Many parts only make sense when read as allegory. For example, The Book of Jonah is a classic spiritual allegory, there was no man named Jonah, and he was never swallowed by a whale and spat out after three days. The entire story is explaining what happens to someone when going through a spiritual conversion, an internal change within their heart. Only people who have experienced it can fully interpret such a text.
"So just about anyone can make it say anything" This is why the Catholic church made Thomas Aquinas (A Philosopher and Theologian) their "doctor of the church", the Catholic church believes in tradition as a means of interpreting the Bible so that no one except the most knowledgable and wise can interpret it. Unfortunately, Protestants do not have the same teaching, they usually interpret the Bible almost entirely literal and based upon their own interpretation, hence why the Catholic church always opposed the reformation.
"Tell me, was it right or wrong?" Everything must be placed within historical context, it's very easy for you as a modern reader living in a modern comfortable civilisation to judge ancient people. Did God order them to kill all those people? Maybe, maybe not, we only have the authors word to go by.
1
-
1
-
Skyswindler If you could live forever you would; this means you love the world, it is your god, your object of worship. You don't want to leave, you want to be forever pleasuring the five senses, welcome to your god.
"There is nothing to misunderstand about killing chidren." Tell that to all the women who have had an abortion. Even today people are justifying the most disgusting acts of evil.
"Its just evil" What is evil? For anything to be evil you must have a standard of goodness. Without God (the ultimate good), evil is just something you happen to dislike, but that others may enjoy.
"This is the same way muslims defend Muhammad for being a pedo." I never defended anything, i merely pointed out the obvious. If you care so much about the murder of children, then i hope you campaign against abortion, otherwise you'd be inconsistent with your own morality.
"context" Example - A man brutally stabbed another man and he died, is he guilty of murder? You would say yes, but when i add further information......A man brutally stabbed another man and he died, after trying to rape and murder his daughter in their family home.....Is he now a cold-blooded killer? Context is everything.
1
-
1