General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Timeline - World History Documentaries
comments
Comments by "" (@Crashed131963) on "How RAF Bomber Crews Kept Britain Fighting with Ewan McGregor In WW2 | Bomber Boys | Timeline" video.
Night bombing scattering fire starting incendiary bombs that can not harm steel factories or railways but just start fires of homes. Bomb Dresden when the Russia's were almost at Berlin and about to end the war no matter what cities were bombed or not at that very late stage of the war. Heroes one and all?
5
So many docs with (It was the best plane of ww2) heard the same about the B-17 ,B24,B-29. Same with fighters , the best was the Spitfire,Mustang, HellCat,Corsair, Thunderbolt, Fw-190 and on and on.
5
They do that sometimes. The US built more B-24s yet all they take about in B-17s.
4
Dresden was 1st bombed when the Russians were about to reach Berlin there was no ("We did not know who was going to win") going on at that stage. Desdens would have been bombed long ago like Berlin and the rest if it was this important rail hub. Not 2 months before the war ended. Where was the rail hub in 1943,1944 or even early 1945.
3
Dresden was 1st bombed when the Russians were about to reach Berlin there was no ("We did not know who was going to win") going on at that stage. Desdens would have been bombed long ago like Berlin and the rest if it was this important rail hub. Not 2 months before the war ended. Where was the rail hub in 1943,1944 or even early 1945.
2
If Dresden was such a important railway hub why was it not heavily bombed like all the other German cities thought the war but only just two months before the war's end? Why would the Russian that waa unstoppable force almost at Berlin want a city that will be in their sector want a Bombed out rubble city rather than a intact functioning city?
2
Dresden was bombed two months before the war ended in 1945. It did not speed up the Russians from entering Berlin and ending the war.
2
Dresden was not hindsight. Why was it not bombed before almost the close of the war like all the other German cities if it was all of a sudden a important target? Also it was not hindsight that late in the war that Germany was defeated and the Russians were close to Berlin and continuing to bomb cities was not changing that one way or another at that late stage.
2
Dresden was 1st bombed when the Russians were about to reach Berlin there was no ("We did not know who was going to win") going on at that stage. Desdens would have been bombed long ago like Berlin and the rest if it was this important rail hub. Not 2 months before the war ended. Where was the rail hub in 1943,1944 or even early 1945.
1
The B-29 never was used in Europe so why mention it?
1
The B24 could fly further and higher than any other 4 engine bomber beside the late comer B-29. The land caster was the best handling it could be flown for hundreds of miles at tree top levels if need be. Best bomber for those Dam busting raids for sure.
1
@vivians9392 How much revenge do you need? A typical weekend Bombing raid on one German City dropped more bombs than were dropped on Britain in the entire war.
1
Being only lightly bombed a few times in 1944 sure does not make it sound like it was a important military target. The rest of the German cities where heavily bombed from early 1943 right through till the end.
1
When Dresden was bombed 2 months before the war ended the Russians were well on there dash to Berlin , Dresden being bombed or not did not change that fact in anyway. It was bombed because Harris had no other cities not already in rubble to bomb.
1
I live in the States. Navy-less Germany was not sailing over to invaded North America . The US had twice Germanys population and 4 times it's manufacturing capacity and resources and a 4 year monopoly on the A-Bomb. The US could beat 2 Germany's. I think my freedom was not threaten by far away little Germany,
1
Look at these war production charts. http://www.combinedfleet.com/economic.htm The US was in a league of its own. The Germans were well behind in making a bomb and all their good scientist fled Germany before the war.
1
The B-29 had them both beat.
1
Youtube without Ad-Blocker? I heard there are people out there like you.
1
@markharrison2544 The Russian Invaded Poland and Czechoslovakia in 1945 and stayed until 1990.
1
@markharrison2544 Thats is true. But the Germans chased them out in 1941 and the Russian in late 1944 chased the Germans out of Poland and stayed until 1990 .
1
Britain declared war on Germany first. Dresden was 1st bombed when the Russians were about to reach Berlin there was no "We did not know who was going to win" going on at that stage. Desdens would have been bombed long ago like the rest if it was important.
1
You would think bombing at night was safer than daylight bombing,. It was the whole reason Britain's stopped daylight bombing and left that to the Americains. Red Army running mine clearers would be up there.
1
MI6 Dresden was 1st bombed when the Russians were about to reach Berlin there was no ("We did not know who was going to win") going on at that stage. Desdens would have been bombed long ago like Berlin and the rest if it was this important target. Not 2 months before the war ended. Why no importance in 1943,1944 or even early 1945. 1
1
@Grandizer8989 Not sure about the Sherman. Even the Americans had no love for a sherman.
1