Comments by "Joshua Taylor" (@joshuataylor3550) on "andrew gold | heretics." channel.

  1. You're a complete fool. Trump is honestly a villain.
    23
  2. He didn't leave willingly, he's still not admitted he lost
    15
  3. They literally are.
    12
  4. Or maybe vote against the guy who literally denied he lost and will do again.
    10
  5. ​ @jacksonmcnuggets7488 physicality still aligns with their gender expression. Reducing the dysphoria felt. Hence the surgery.
    10
  6. Yes, happily. Free speech, right? She IS very clearly prejudiced to people based on their race. I.e., racist. Facts don't care about your feelings.
    9
  7. Do you feel proud of monetizing outrage?
    9
  8. You're confusing sex and gender
    8
  9. ​@maryj5593 he's just appealing to outrage, gets more clicks (and our comments) for coming out for trump.
    8
  10. ​ @sebastiansirvas1530  no one is claiming sex is spectrum, only gender.
    7
  11. ​ @robertmarshall2502  just stop accusing anyone of racism and it will go away.
    7
  12. Ooo, I know why! He was bullied at school.
    6
  13. ​​ @andrewgoldheretics  They never have been the same thing. Surely you acknowledge that humans (even arguably some animals, particularly primates) have always had societies where gender was expressed across a spectrum of what we define as masculine through feminine. Nearly always but not exclusively, in line with biological physicality (sex; chromosomes, gonadal hormones, genitalia etc.), female corresponding to the feminine (often grouped under the term woman) and male corresponding to the masculine (often grouped under the term man). Spectrums will have plenty of overlap in the middle, leading to the emergence of gender identities such as non-binary (which I'm sure you feel unduly threatened by, or at least you pretend to for money). Unlike this guy (and you) I'm an actual physiologist studying sex differences and it's widely acknowledged that gender is something different from sex. The phrase 'biological sex' is a tautology, inherent in the meaning of sex is the fact it's biological. Gender is inherently social and as physiologists we do not study gender differences. You are correct to identify that until about the millennium these ideas of sex and gender were not commonly understood amongst the layman and society at large, but in reality, these distinct but related concepts have always existed. Language, society (and how one reflects the other) is constantly evolving, always has, always will. Whether or not this makes you emotional is besides the point (facts don't care about your feelings). To your final point of outrage, it sounds like you are very much in favour of self identification into any gender the individual wishes and they shouldn't be bound to the stereotypes of society (wonderfully progressive of you). Yes of course an individual can identify as a boy/man with long hair and nails and this entirely unrelated to their biology (be they XX or XY) that is almost binary (intersex people exist, though they are few). Maybe this will help it settle for you; transwomen are women, but they are still male.
    5
  14. These are not justifications hahaha.
    5
  15. This is most outrageous outrage sale you've done yet. Get a real job and contribute to society.
    5
  16. This man is purposefully confusing sex and gender for outrage. Do we really not believe there is no such thing as social expression of gender?
    4
  17. No one is saying sex is on a spectrum, they're saying gender is.
    4
  18. Apologising makes you strong, not weak.
    4
  19. Oh come on mate, is everything racist these days? Get a life.
    4
  20. ​ @3lannister  of course not pal. Accepting reality is always healthy. The question is does your reality require a behavioral shift? For 99% of alcoholics it's better not to drink. For 99% of trans people it's better for them to live their lives in the gender identity they are. The statistics show this to be true. it doesn't matter if this makes people upset. It's also true that the 1% of people who detransition are living a tragedy. But doctors still need to give advice on the weight of the evidence.
    4
  21. This guy is literally insane haha.
    4
  22. Thanks, I've been saying this for a long time now
    3
  23. ​ @eiyukabe  language changes to reflect society as it's understanding progresses. Whatever you call them two different concepts exists, a social expression of identity falling along a spectrum and a mostly binary biological division related to reproduction strategies. They are not the same and deserve two different names.
    3
  24. ​ @liverpoollou246  he pretends people are saying sex is in a spectrum when they are only talking about gender.
    3
  25. Grow up
    3
  26. Where you getting these stats from? '17% in the boardroom in sports'?
    3
  27. Almost none
    3
  28. What a stupid thing to say
    3
  29. Grow up
    3
  30. Grow up
    3
  31. He doesn't even define mutation
    3
  32. 38:00 I laughed out loud when you said you don't want to make yourself morally better than others after spending the entire interview until then doing exactly that.
    3
  33. Poor you
    3
  34. Couldn't even be bothered to research how to pronounce her name.
    3
  35. ​ @eiyukabe unlike you I don't see this as some kind of game with 'teams'. I'm just interested in describing reality. Words have always updated their meanings throughout history. Do you refuse to use the word gay with reference to sexuality because it wasn't always used in such a context? Gender describes the conceptualisation of the social expression of gender identities whether that upsets you or not. Facts don't care about your feelings. I am by no means saying that all novelties are positive, I am also not saying that progress is inherently positive, I'm simply stating the change seen as time moves in a single direction: progress. I hope you can progress from your ignorance and your emotional outbursts that will only damage yourself.
    2
  36. To be fair, both have tons of evidence. Creationism doesn't
    2
  37. you're an outrage farmer. Be ashamed of yourself. There are a lot more cis pedos, should we prevent them from existing too? Come on pal, get a real job.
    2
  38. People have to know who you are first
    2
  39. ​ @matthewatwood8641 it's a hypothesis that many publications have accepted based on the evidence they collected. I'm much less interested in your 'feelings', which is not even a hypothesis.
    2
  40. ​ @jayhanson-hs5vg  life isn't a video game
    2
  41. Exactly, no one ever claimed sex was a social construct
    2
  42. Tommy Robinson is very right, far far far right.
    2
  43. ​ @StillAliveAndKicking_  seems to talking quite a lot...
    2
  44. If she's in the highest tax bracket then she can afford a child 😂 does she not hear herself?
    2
  45. Yes, happily. Free speech, right? She IS very clearly prejudiced to people based on their race. I.e., racist. Facts don't care about your feelings.
    2
  46. Gender is not sex. For the 10000000 time
    2
  47. It's safe for you to come out now. Be your true self before you die.
    2
  48. I'm starting to think you might be trans curious Andy?
    2
  49. ​ @RKingis learned a new word did you? Well done 👏🏻
    2
  50. ​ @SquirtlePower809  thank you for sharing. I believe you.
    2
  51. Calling her him, revealing your bias
    2
  52. ​ @thentheychopped  there's zero evidence. Calling it truth is incorrect
    2
  53. IBA are banned because they're Russian cheats
    2
  54. ​ @RCGWho so says the entire planet. Come on, it's all run by Putin
    2
  55. Simply untrue
    2
  56. When did Normans stop being Norman?
    2
  57. Everyone agrees, but gender is too
    2
  58. ​ @thentheychopped  god is make believe
    2
  59. Absolutely, just not female.
    2
  60. ​ @CMA418  in the closet 🏳️‍🌈
    1
  61. ​ @eiyukabe I taught you but you've refused to learn
    1
  62. This guy is right wing
    1
  63. Youre confusing transgender men and women all the time its embarrassing
    1
  64. You're having a psychotic break; please seek help.
    1
  65. Yeah he's a mug
    1
  66. ​ @andrewgoldheretics  you're an outrage farmer. Be ashamed of yourself. There are a lot more cis pedos, should we prevent them from existing too? Come on pal, get a real job.
    1
  67. Bit too fabulous if you know what i mean.
    1
  68. You're proving her point
    1
  69. ​ @PaulDavies-x4z you're a rapist
    1
  70. Thank you!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Exactly correct.
    1
  71. ​ @SwipeWright1  You're missing the point entirely, almost like you're doing it on purpose for outrage cash... We know they're are only 2 sexes (exc. Intersex people, though they are few). Why are you pretending gender doesn't exist, and that that doesn't exist on a spectrum? Gender as a social reality, distinct from but related to sex as biological reality is also accepted by the overwhelming majority of scientists. It's weird as well because evolution neatly explains its existence, yet you pretend people are conflating gender with sex, but that's just you!! Recognising these facts doesn't mean males run against females or anything. There's good sense to make sport sex based and not gender based.
    1
  72. Faith is still based on scientific evidence vs. Religious texts.
    1
  73. Neither could you
    1
  74. He whined about diversity as much as she did
    1
  75. Wasn't it shocking the other guy knew the most common biscuit used in that game?
    1
  76. So you don't believe in liberty?
    1
  77. I feel sorry for the existence you must lead
    1
  78. The healthcare system alone would collapse overnight
    1
  79. They are 1% of trans people
    1
  80. Is mostly correlated to gestational testosterone
    1
  81. ​ @Katienixton intellectual?! 😅 I guess he's a thick person's idea of white intellectual is.
    1
  82. You're proving her point
    1
  83. Andrew you're a cunt and you're wrong
    1
  84. No one is claiming this, this is exactly why gender and sex describe the two different concepts you outline
    1
  85. ​ @SwipeWright1  Why do you purposefully confuse sex and gender for outrage? You should feel ashamed of yourself. Absolutely no one is claiming sex is on a spectrum, only gender. The entire scientific community accepts they're distinct but related concepts.
    1
  86. Racists are all over the world.
    1
  87. Theory of evolution... Both have plenty of evidence
    1
  88. ​ @alecfoster4413  grow up.
    1
  89. No exactly, your unconscious bias means they're more likely to be black.
    1
  90. You're clutching at straws
    1
  91. She's not transgender
    1
  92. You're the one people are laughing it. You're denying reality
    1
  93. Makes it more likely though
    1
  94. She wouldn't be hitting males in the female category.
    1
  95. Why do you have the right to the wealth you hoarded?
    1
  96. Intersex people exist
    1
  97. I imagine you also say things like 'women bring it upon themselves but dressing a certain way'.
    1
  98. IBA and IOC have the same rules. IBA say chromosomes XY, IOC say XX.
    1
  99. I think he identifies as a man
    1
  100. Pretty gay
    1
  101. Ads on the bbc?!?
    1
  102. Right wingers say that men have vaginas now haha.
    1
  103. So if homophobia causes transition then it's reasonable to assume that transphobia causes detransition?
    1
  104. Graham Hancock is a lunatic.
    1
  105. Theres male and female AND the gender spectrum. Sex is not gender.
    1
  106. Islamo-woke??! Please.
    1
  107. You are a racist. grow up
    1
  108. You snowflakes offended? Let people live their lives
    1
  109. Almost like they cherry picked the bit that would get you hard.
    1
  110. Oh I don't think the interviewer is an athlete.
    1
  111. Yeah the interviewer is a prick
    1
  112. George Floyd died from a knee on his neck. Asphyxiation.
    1
  113. Must be pretty awful to do that though. Probably why she's ok with Stormy Daniels
    1
  114. So brave 🏳️‍🌈
    1
  115. So men have vaginas now?
    1
  116. That doesn't make sense. Trans people don't rape children.
    1
  117. This is utter bullshit, there's a lot more straight cis pedophiles.
    1
  118. Yeah by Andrew
    1
  119. British broadcasting corporation*
    1
  120. It's been recognised for longer than when your ancestors invaded.
    1
  121. Did you even listen to her?
    1
  122. ​@andrewgoldheretics you support a rapist.
    1
  123. Creationism is Jewish mythology, every culture around the world creates mythology to deal with the unknown quantities of existence. Science comes from the scientific method (an attempt to find truth empirically) that was actually pioneered by Islamic scholars and perfected by Brits during the scientific revolution.
    1
  124. You're a mug
    1
  125. 1:00:00 he panicked when she said something feminist
    1
  126. Well obviously. So are right wingers.
    1
  127. Gay
    1
  128. Talks a lot for a cancelled fellow
    1
  129. That's bullshit
    1
  130. This whole channel is a vanity project based on his own victimhood
    1
  131. Tomboy is a masculine girl, sissy is a feminine boy. Gender lies on a spectrum these are informal terms that describe some portions of that spectrum. 'take it like a man' means 'behave in a more stereotypically masculine way'. 'act like a girl' means 'behave in a more stereotypically feminine way'. Thanks for the points 💯
    1