Comments by "Jim Luebke" (@jimluebke3869) on "Joel Did Nothing Wrong - The Importance Of Ambiguity" video.

  1. "What does [the existence of replicants who are very humanlike] actually say about what it means to be human?" It's worse than that. Reading one of his novels dealing with Replicants, the main character was neurodivergent, and seemed to feel that these replicants had a better handle on what it meant to be human (and a better claim on humanity) than HE did, despite his being born human. That's just the sort of uncomfortable person Phililp K Dick was. I couldn't actually get through the whole book.
    4
  2. The people who insisted that Ellie had to die for them to succeed in their efforts, could have been wrong.
    1