Comments by "عبدالله" (@user-kj8yl6sn2z) on "World of Antiquity"
channel.
-
29
-
19
-
9
-
6
-
5
-
I believe that although archeology only searches for material evidence and rejects religion in archaeological matters, the texts of the Qur’an mentioned matters that were known in the texts of the Qur’an before archaeological discoveries.
For example, in Egyptology, in the Hyksos period in the time of the Prophet Joseph, peace be upon him, the rulers were called the king, not the Pharaoh. Therefore, when we read the Qur’an, in the story of the Prophet Joseph, the talk was about the king, and Pharaoh was not mentioned, while in the stories of the Prophet Moses, Pharaoh was called the rulers, while the Bible It is mentioned in the time of the Prophet Joseph that he was a Pharaoh.
Likewise, knowing Haman’s name was impossible before knowing how to read hieroglyphic writing, according to the opinion of the German Egyptologist. This is a famous story by Dr. Maurice Bucaille.
The fact that Pharaoh’s body was preserved is also mentioned in the Qur’an.
So why don't archaeologists benefit from the texts of the Qur'an to accelerate their archaeological discoveries and decipher some secrets?
4
-
3
-
3
-
the secrets of Dadan, the lost kingdom, the title of a new documentary film in National Graphic, international channels have begun to take a partial interest in revealing some of the civilizations of the Arabian Peninsula
I think there will be many opportunities for the makers of documentaries to reveal the secrets of some civilizations of the Arabian Peninsula, such as the civilization of Medin (Shuaib Caves), the civilization of Al-Maqar, the civilization of Thamud, the civilization of Ad, the civilization of Himyar (the groove in Najran), the civilization of Saba, the civilization of Yamama, the civilization of the Nabataeans in the Arabian Peninsula, the civilization of Lihyan and the civilization of Dilmun and the secrets of rock carvings in Jubbah, Shuwaymis and other civilizations.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@cackle6682 Dear your response is strange, but I will explain to you.
Islamic historians rely on the texts of the Qur’an, and the authentic Sunnah, which depends on an interconnected chain of transmission and conditions that prove its validity (you can search for the conditions of Imam Al-Bukhari in the authenticity of the authentic hadiths)
Other than these two things can be mistaken, whether in history or documenting the biography, unless they are conditions such as the conditions of the hadiths of the Prophet, such as an honest transmitter, etc.., so you will find a contradiction in the history books because some lie or imagine some stories without conditions to verify them.
Archeology: Archeology changes every year, new things emerge, and archaeologists differ in their analyzes, and they are not angels, and we do not accept everything from them.
And many things that archaeologists do not know as historical or religious information to rely on in archaeological research, so they get it wrong, so I enjoy their discoveries, but I do not believe them 100%.
My belief: Islam and my doctrine is Sunni, and my path is the path of the friends of the Prophet Muhammad who understood the religion directly from the Prophet Muhammad, so I do not innovate in my religion nor invent new rituals, my religion is the religion of the first generations of Muslims and I am on their path.
There is no such thing as: Fundamentalism in Islam (it is a Western media designation): Islam is only what the Prophet Muhammad brought, pbuh, this is Islam. Just .
Do you have a new question?
Are you going to try to bully me?
2
-
2
-
2
-
I will tell you about some archaeological sites in Saudi Arabia, such as:
1. Al-Ula: It contains 5 ancient civilizations, such as the Thamud civilization( Madain Saleh), the Dadan civilization (Cemetery of Lions in the Kingdom of Dadan), the Lihyan civilization, the Nabatean civilization, and the Mustatils civilization, which is still a mysterious secret. A tram is being built between ancient Arab civilizations to be the largest living museum in the world.
The civilization of Thamud is one of the greatest human civilizations, and they are the descendants of the great civilization of Ad.
Dadan civilization is one of the oldest Arab civilizations.
Al-Ula, the Hijaz region and the Arabian Peninsula are rich in very ancient rock paintings, inscriptions and writings from several different eras.
2. Qusayrat Aad in Al-Aflaj: Some researchers believe that they are the descendants of the great Aad people mentioned in the Qur’an (there is a documentary film about them on Al-Arabiya TV website) The stories of the people of Thamud in Surat Al-Ahqaf, Surat Hud, Surat Al-Tawbah, Surat Q, and Surat Fussilat
3. Caves of Shuaib, the Midian civilization, in which the story of the Prophet Shuaib, peace be upon him, was mentioned in the Qur’an. This city is mentioned in the Bible. Arab researchers believe that the Prophet Musa came to this area. A mountain, a well, and the springs of Musa are still known in this area, but so far they have not appeared. Archaeological signs prove it.
4. The Kingdom of Babylon in Tayma: King Nabonid moved from Mesopotamia to Tayma and established his kingdom. The wall of Tayma and Well Hadaj and other archaeological sites are still witness to the civilization of the Babylonians. Tayma is mentioned in the Bible as well.
5. The Kingdom of Himyar in Najran and the story of Dhi Nuwas, the Jewish king who burned the monotheistic Christians in Al-Ukhdood, and there are Hima wells registered in UNESCO, and there are many coins that you rarely find like them from their large numbers, and they were presented in the Najran Museum
6. Al-Maqar civilization: It is an ancient Arab civilization that is more than 9 thousand years BC. It is believed to be one of the first civilizations in the world where the large-scale domestication of animals, especially the horse, occurred during the Neolithic period. In it, human remains, animal figures, and industrial utensils were discovered. The civilization site is located in the Najd region in the middle of the Arabian Peninsula, Saudi Arabia, specifically in a middle area between the Tathleeth governorate and the Wadi Al-Dawasir governorate.
7. Al-Faw Civilization: It remained thriving for more than 600 years, from the third century BC until the fourth century AD, Al-Faw was a thriving city at the time of the Canadians, and they built palaces, markets, and temples in it built of stones carved with grace and great beauty, which still exist today. Among the most prominent features of the city are the tomb of King Muawiyah, built in the form of a small stepped pyramid, the tombs of the nobles and the upper house of the people, the commercial market and the temple.
“Al-Faw” is characterized by the presence of an abundance of antiquities, artifacts, towers, squares, and commercial markets. They built canals and planted palm trees, vines, and some types of frankincense and grains. They also used tree trunks and palm trees to roof their homes, and local and imported wood for their doors and windows. They cared about livestock, including camels, cows, goats, mutton, deer, and ibex.
8. Thaj is a village in Eastern Province : Its construction dates back to the era of the Greeks. Research and excavations indicated the existence of an integrated city surrounded by a wall, the length of one of its sides reaching 900 meters. The construction of the city dates back to the Greek period known as the Seleucid era, early third century BC.
9. The three-dimensional carvings of camels in the city of Sakaka, the oldest in the world, dating back 8,000 years
Jabal Al-Nisa: This mountain is located 150 meters northwest of Moissen Castle, and it is a mountain
The best expression I read was by Dr. Abd al-Rahman al-Ansari when he mentioned that this mountain is an integrated library of ancient writings.
In the Al-Jouf region, there are some monuments such as Columns of Rajajil, Marid Castle, and the Omar bin Al-Khattab Mosque, which has the oldest minaret in the world.
10. Tarut Island is one of the oldest civilizations in the region, dating back to 5000 BC. It contains Ashtarot burial grounds, the Phoenician burial grounds, the Dilmun burial grounds, Al-Faihani Castle, Al-Faihani Palace, Tarut Castle, temples, buildings and mosques, which are full of historical places.
It is the second largest island in the Arabian Gulf.
11. The mountains of Jubbah and Shuwaymis contain more than 17,000 inscriptions and archaeological inscriptions of different eras, such as the Iron Age, the Bronze Age, the Silver Age, the Thamudic Age, the era of the beginning of Islam, etc..
The Hail region is famous for the story of Hatim Al-Ta’i, who was one of the most generous Arabs before Islam.
There are some heritage villages that still maintain their urban style, such as the village of Rijal Almaa, the village of Dhi Zain, the village of Ashiqer, the village of Al Diriyah, Historic Jeddah, and Historic Yanbu.
Among the arts in Saudi Arabia: the art of the Asiri cat, the arts of Arabic calligraphy, the art of making Sadu,
The art of making plaster in Al-Ahsa, the art of making Rawashin in the Hijaz, the art of making Najdi doors, the art of carving in the wood industry in the Al-Baha region for doors, windows and latrines (and coating them with tar).
Some ancient Arab informants believed that the cradle of mankind was in Mecca. This thing cannot be proven or denied, and it needs a great archaeological research.
But as Muslims, we believe that the first house of worship was the Kaaba in Mecca, and this is mentioned in the Qur’an in Surat Al-Baqarah. The name Bakkah was mentioned in the Bible, and it is one of the names of Mecca in the Qur’an and the Bible.
I hope this will help you understand some Arab civilizations knowing that there are many other Arab civilizations such as the Palmyra civilization, the Saba civilization, the Nabatean civilization in Petra, etc..
I wish you good luck and success.
2
-
Dr. Miano How can there be consensus in the heavenly holy books, for example, the story of the migration of the Prophet Moses, peace be upon him, is found in the Bible, the Torah, and the Qur’an, and perhaps some details are not found in the Bible and vice versa, and Christians do not believe that the Qur’an is the word of God and Muslims believe that the Bible is distorted, so they do not know right from wrong
For example, the area of Maghaer Shuaib is one of the archaeological jewels of Saudi Arabia that Arab historians attribute to Prophet Shuaib or (Yathro) in the Bible and the neighboring areas that some Arab historians attribute to the Prophet Musa pbuh, such as Jabal Musa, the Rock of Musa, Well of Musa, etc..
As an archaeologist, how do I verify the stories in the three heavenly books?
For example, as a Muslim, I believe 100% that the Qur’an is completely authentic
Are you a Christian, how do you work on that and will your religious thought interfere with the adoption of the Qur’an or not, or will you resort to another method for exploration and inference despite the presence of texts that may help in excavating these monuments
Another example :
Mada'in Salih was known in the past among the Arabs as belonging to the Thamud civilization, the people of the Prophet Salih pbuh, and their story is detailed in the Qur'an.
Dr. Suleiman Al-Deeb, the Saudi archaeologist, appeared and said that it belongs to the Nabataeans because there are no earthquakes in this region because of their rejection of the message of the Prophet Saleh pbuh
But the Prophet Muhammad pbuh passed through this area on his way from Medina to Tabuk and talked about it
In the Qur’an, his example is described:
That the buildings carved in the mountains are dwellings and they were tortured in the village
In the Qur’an, it is called Hegra, and it is still the same name
In the Qur’an it is mentioned that the village is rich in palm trees and still is
Etc.. From the evidence that makes it clear beyond any doubt that Mada'in Salih belonged to the Thamud people.
But archaeologists insist that the dwellings of Thamud are cemeteries and that what is meant by Saleh is not the Prophet Saleh, but rather a prince who used to live in them, etc..
Archaeologists have lied what the people of Al-Ula believed in, what the Arabs knew in the past, what Arab travelers and historians knew centuries ago, and what the Qur’an strongly described for Madin Saleh, including carving in the mountains and palms, the name of Hegra, the passage of the Prophet Muhammad from the same road, etc... .
That's why archaeologists sometimes put horns in my head and don't make me believe their studies
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
I think that the city of Al-Ula should be on the list because we are not talking about one civilization, but rather several successive civilizations such as the Thamud civilization, the Kingdom of Dadan, the Kingdom of Lihyan and the Nabateans
Muslims, who represent a quarter of the world's population, are very interested in revealing the secret of the great civilization of Aad, whose story was mentioned in the Qur'an
I think that when it was discovered, it will place it at the top of the list. Some historians believe that Qusayrat Aad in the city of Al-Aflaj belong to this great civilization, and God knows best. There is a documentary film on this subject translated into English by Dr. Eid Al-Yahya
Antiquities in northwest Saudi Arabia because of their connection to the sacred books of the Torah, the Bible and the Qur’an, such as the caves of Shuaib, which are affiliated with the Prophet Shuaib (Ythro), and the nearby monuments, such as the wells and springs of Moss, which some Arab historians believe to be related to the Prophet Moss, perhaps should be on the list
The mysterious secret of the rectangles civilization in the Hijaz may reveal important secrets in ancient human history and may be nominated for the list
But I think that the most important secrets, which if discovered, would be the most important, are the traces of Adam and Eve, because they are the origin of the first humanity. Some Arab historians believe that Adam and Eve met in Mecca, but there is no material evidence for their words.
Also, many archaeologists say that Noah’s Ark is in Turkey, but some Arab researchers believe that it is in the Hijaz for a variety of reasons, such as / that the sons of the Prophet Noah used to live in the Hijaz, 2. The Jabal al-Judi mentioned in the Qur’an, some say that it is in Mecca and is known, some depend On the Tablets of Babylon and Assyria, which mentioned that the story of the flood occurred in the Arabian Peninsula, and you, Dr. David, can confirm this news or not, by virtue of your specialization in that.
Doctor tried to translate your clips into Arabic because the Arabs are very interested in archeology and we want to learn more from you.
Good luck .
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1