Comments by "Jeffrey Wilheim" (@jeffreywilheim5970) on "uncivilized " channel.

  1. ​ @BorsosGabor2023 Yes, why are the Israelis moral and decent whereas the South Africans seem obsessed with spreading the lie that Israel is committing a genocide in Gaza?
    1
  2. ​ @shaharzamir88 Be careful about presenting facts. They go right over the head of pro-"Palestinian" people.
    1
  3.  @ammumeme5789  Here in the reality-based community, we understand that Zionism is the ultimate example of decolonization.
    1
  4.  @ammumeme5789  Pretty much every country in the Middle East has fallen prey to Arab colonialism.
    1
  5. "[The Mizrachi Jews] had more in common with the 'Palestinians' they were colonizing than with the white settlers they were doing it alonigside or under." Funny how you can't find an actual Mizrachi Jew who shares this perspective. That may have something to do with its being a baldfaced lie. Kind of like your assertion that this incident in Israel's early history proves anything about the inherent nature of Zionism or of the "Zionist entity"--or, as normal, non-antisemitic people call it, the state of Israel.
    1
  6. Where exactly does your obsession with the status of genetic testing in Israel come from?
    1
  7.  @OddWoz  Dear heart, what is your obsession with the DNA of Jews? Jewish identity isn't created or confirmed by DNA. You don't get to deny Jews self-definition any more than you get to deny us self-determination.
    1
  8.  @claudebeland7462  Provide a source for this law.
    1
  9. It's hard to know anything about "apartheid Israel" when Israel is not, in fact, an apartheid state.
    1
  10. Wow, this is propaganda that would make Goebbels blanch. To help bring your viewers back to the fact-based world: 1) Jews, not "Palestinians," are the indigenous people of Israel, with records of Jewish presence in the land going back as far as 1208 BCE. "Palestinians" are a fake nationality concocted by Yasser Arafat and the KGB in the 1960s in a cynical ploy to rebrand Arab terrorism against Jews living in their 3600-year homeland as "Palestinian liberation." Prior to 1964, these people called themselves "Arabs" and largely rejected the idea that they were a distinct nationality. It is inaccurate and racist to claim that Zionism is just an "excavated ideological story" and that Israel Jews have "no roots to keep them settled" in their homeland of 3600 years. 2) As the indigenous people of Israel, who have maintained a presence in the land for 3600 years despite not always having sovereignty or being the majority of the population, Israeli Jews have deep ties to the land, including festivals built around the agricultural cycle in the land and commandments that can literally only be fulfilled in the land. 3) The term "Nakba" does not refer to the displacement of Arabs during Israel's 1948-1949 war but rather was a term invented by an Egyptian academic to refer to the "catastrophe" of the Arab armies' failing to defeat Israel and throw her Jewish population into the sea. In other words, when "Palestinians" commemorate the Nakba, they are commemorating their failure to commit a genocide of Israeli Jews. 4) Zionists in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries were not "colonial settlers" but people fleeing persecution in other countries who returned to Israel in hopes of reconstituting their ancestral homeland, ending the Jewish diaspora, and ensuring that such horrors would never befall them. 5) Contrary to the fantasies of pro-"Palestinian" apologists, Israeli Jews (the people you mischaracterize as "settlers") have not been leaving Israel in large numbers since October 2023 and in fact many Israelis living abroad have come back to defend their homeland. The Jewish people is more united against the "Palestinians" than it has been in decades. 6) Israel's war against Gaza that began in 2023 was a response to the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust and cannot be called a genocide by any reasonable standard. Israel fought a justified war of defense against a genocidal terrorist organization that embedded itself in the civilian population and engaged in war crimes by hiding soldiers and weapons in schools, hospitals, and mosques, making them legitimate targets under international law. In the midst of this so-called "genocide," Israel facilitated the vaccination of "Palestinian" children against polio and repeatedly warned civilians to get out of harm's way by sending text messages and dropping leaflets--something no other army in history has done. 7) Polling showed that roughly forty percent of "Palestinians" in Gaza wanted to relocate outside of Gaza BEFORE October 7th, a number that has surely only grown in the course of this war. 8) It's amusing how you constantly reference Native American forms of spirituality that have no connection to the "Palestinians" whatsoever but don't discuss the actual fundamentalist, jihadist religion that "Palestinians" themselves embrace and regularly propagate through their own media, a religion obsessed with the idea of exterminating Jews.
    1
  11. @flickrebeat8936  Jews are from ISRAEL, dear heart. There are no laws against DNA tests in Israel. The majority of Israeli Jews are descendants of Jews ethnically cleansed by Arab countries after 1948 and hence not European or white. So if you're going to tell Israeli Jews to "go back where you came from," remember that that includes Cairo, Algiers, and Baghdad.
    1
  12.  @justiceriser8970  Nope. "Palestinians" are mostly descendants of Arabs who conquered the Levant in the 7th century or of Syrians and Egyptians brought in by the Ottomans and British as cheap labor. Facts don't fit your bigoted anti-Zionist narrative
    1
  13. @justiceriser8970  Wrong. There is no strand of DNA a person has to have to be a Jew. Converts to Judaism are just as much Jews as any person born Jewish, Israel is just as much their homeland, and they have just as much right to make their home in Israel. We're not obligated to accept your racist attempts to redefine who we are.
    1
  14.  @flickrebeat8936  Jews are from ISRAEL, dear heart. The majority of Israeli Jews are not Ashkenazim but Sephardim and Mizrachim hailing from Spain, North Africa, and the Middle East. There is no prohibition on genetic testing in Israel. But hey, why let facts get in the way of your antisemitism?
    1
  15.  @nataliekhanyola5669  Hasbara is something any decent person should be proud to be engaged in, dear heart.
    1
  16. Be careful about confusing these people with facts, dear heart. They don't understand what they are.
    1
  17. The people calling Israel an apartheid country are the racists, dear heart.
    1
  18. Yes, it's hard to fathom the moral depravity of the "Palestinians," isn't it?
    1
  19. Dear heart, no matter how many times you tell that lie, Israel is not a "settler colonial" country. Jews are the indigenous inhabitants of Israel, and settler colonialism does not encompass a people returning to and establishing a state in their own homeland. But thanks for making your racism and antisemitism so clear. It makes it easier for decent people to avoid you.
    1
  20.  @Faris-bk6xu  There's a well reasoned response. Lol
    1
  21.  @CaptainSpackJarrow7  Why don't you go buy yourself a basic book of Israeli history and read it before we proceed?
    1
  22.  @CaptainSpackJarrow7  No matter how many times your say otherwise, a people's returning to its own homeland is not "settler colonialism."
    1
  23. Decent people aren't proud to be called antisemitic, dear heart.
    1
  24. ​ @Jean-rg4sp Yes because you clearly didn't understand what you teach very well.
    1
  25.  @arifabd  Wow. Ignorance of history, racism, and antisemitism all in one three-sentence post. Your schoolteachers must be so proud.
    1
  26.  @arifabd  Yeah, see, there are books written by actual historians as opposed to Noam Chomsky, Norman Finkelstein, Ilan Pappe, or whatever self-hating Jew spewing lies you get your ideas of Jewish and Zionist history from. So take your own advice and crack open a book.
    1
  27.  @jameswilliam26  Dear heart, we know perfectly well where our ancestors are from. They're from Israel. Stop kidding yourself that we care about your assessments of our authenticity or that Israel is going anywhere.
    1
  28.  @arifabd  Yeah, see, when you post antisemitic claptrap, YouTube identifies it as antisemitic claptrap and removes it. The solution is to stop posting antisemitic claptrap.
    1
  29. Here in the reality-based community, as opposed to your world of antisemitic fantasy, we recognize that non-Jews are not the arbiters of what is or is not an authentically Jewish name. Here in the reality-based community, as opposed to your world of antisemitic fantasy, we recognized that Jews returning to their ancestral homeland adopted new names not to sound more "Middle Eastern" but to sound more Jewish by casting off names forced on them by Gentile governments elsewhere.
    1
  30.  @PizzaMargarita144  Here in the reality-based community, we have a thing called common decency. Here in the reality-based community, we understand that part of common decency is using for people the names they choose to use for themselves. Here in the reality-based community, we understand that, upon moving to Israel, many Jewish families chose to adopt Hebrew surnames as a symbol of their connection to the land of Israel, casting off surnames that had usually been imposed on Jews by Gentile governments. Here in the reality-based community, we understand that it is not for non-Jews to decide what is and isn't a Jew's "real name." Here in the reality-based community, we understand that if the Mileikowski family chose to adopt the name Netanyahu upon arriving in Israel, that is their real family name. Here in the reality-based community, we understand that Israel is the eternal homeland of the Jewish people, and that all Jews are entitled to consider it so, even if some of their ancestors lived in Persia, Paris, or even "freakin' Poland." Here in the reality-based community, referring to the prime minister of Israel as being "from freakin' Poland" is not only inaccurate as he never lived in Poland but offensive as it suggests Jews ought to return to a place where they were systematically slaughtered. Here in the reality-based community, we understand that Jews have more right to their homeland than genocidal terrorists like Yasser Arafat and Mahmoud Abbas. Glad I could clear that up for you.
    1
  31.  @nataliekhanyola5669  Yes and it ingnores that that poverty was due to Arab persecution.
    1
  32.  @AbdoMSG  You have images of Arabs older than 80 years. No such thing as a "Palestinian" exited until Yasser Arafat invented the fake nation of "Palestine" in the 1960s.
    1
  33. But that would force her to tell an accurate story of Israeli history instead of peddling this "white settler colonialist" crap she pretends is Israel's history.
    1
  34. Imagine anyone equating Israel with Adolf Hitler.
    1
  35. Nope. Jews are indigenous to the land of Israel. But repeating the "settler colonialist" myth will surely earn you your Little Nazi merit badge from the Hitler Youth.
    1
  36. yeah see the "Palestinians" aren't the natives. They're mostly the descendants of Arabs the British brought in from Syria and Egypt to work the land during the Mandatory period.
    1
  37.  @Sagii154  Jews have lived in the land that is now Israel for 3000 years. Despite waves of armies that occupied it , Jews never completely disappeared from the land of Israel nor ever ceased seeing it as their homeland. The Zionist movement that began in late 19th century Europe raised money to buy land from Arabs under the Ottomans and later the British. So you can take your antisemitic lie that Jews were never in the country before 1948 and shove it.
    1
  38. So basically you took the actual history of Israel and removed anything from it that makes clear the "Palestinians" are the aggressors and responsible for their own fate?
    1
  39. If Nas is a second-class citizen in his own country, why is he so eager to show his love of Israel? Just what rights has he been denied as an Israeli citizen?
    1
  40.  @TaraDG  Nope. Nas doesn't live in the West Bank and enjoys full equality with Israeli Jews. But thanks for telling me you didn't watch the video without telling me you didn't watch the video.
    1
  41.  @omeritzics  And not even the West Bank.
    1
  42. Nope. Jews have a history in Israel going back 3,500 years. The "Palestinians," on the other hand, are mostly Arabs who were brought in as cheap labor by the British.
    1
  43. Wrong. The majority of Israel's Jews are Mizrachi or Sephardi, meaning they or their ancestors came to Israel from the Middle East or North Africa. 850,000 Jews were expelled by the Arab countries before, during, and after the 1948 war--a fact that conveniently gets left out of "Palestinian" narratives. Jews have lived in Israel over 3000 years. "Palestinians," by contrast, are mostly descended from Egyptians and Syrians brought in by the British as cheap labor.
    1
  44.  @Cookie_360  Yeah, see, you're not really entitled to decide who is an "authentic Jew" for the purposes of living in Israel. Jewish tradition has always allowed conversion, and converts and descendants of converts are just as much Jews as any other Jew and just as entitled to live in Israel, no matter what they look like.
    1
  45. Nope. "Palestinians" are mostly descendants of people from Egypt and Syria the British brought in as a cheap labor supply. A majority of Israeli Jews are Sephardi and Mizrachi, meaning their ancestors came from the Middle East and North Africa. Try again.
    1
  46. "Here they are, defending themselves against a genocidal terrorist organization that is attempting to create another Holocaust." There, I fixed it for you.
    1
  47. Or better yet, support YouTubers who aren't racist, anti-Zionist, and antisemitic.
    1
  48.  @ServusDei-57  Yeah, see, that's actually easy to explain. Western media construct stories on the basis of things called "facts" and "evidence" and therefore don't report on "atrocities" that don't happen. That's how they miss them.
    1
  49. Nope. Israel is a free and democratic state, not a communist one. Try again.
    1
  50.  @MohamedMohamed-tr2rz  No actually we didn't, dear heart. Try reading actual works of history instead of antisemitic conspiracy claptrap.
    1