Comments by "Voryn Rosethorn" (@vorynrosethorn903) on "KaiserBauch" channel.

  1. I recommend the Japanese manga 'A Bride's Tale' which is set in historical central Asia and contains a lot of information about the culture, dress and social systems that are not widely available in English. It also has some of the most beautiful art, as the author has a very keen eye for detail and an intricate style.
    159
  2. The fundamental mistake in these is thinking that anyone has the intention of solving these problems through the institutions who made them. This is like responding to the prospect of socialism in 1890's Russia by saying 'I'm not sure the emperor would do that, and he has support from state institutions, the orthodox church and peasants, like 80% of the population of Russia are peasants, nothing will happen, this is all because people are overly within their revolutionary movements'.
    134
  3. Some sort of remigration will, whether it's the muslims moving back to a Turkish or Persian dominated middle east, or the Germanic people's moving back to Russia. But the two groups together are like Turks and Greeks. This issue we have now is that the people who created the situation remain in power.
    119
  4. The reason why the Pakistanis in particular are a point of tension is massive child abuse rings run by them that the police covered up and the legal system gave joke sentences for. As this is ongoing and targets the working class the resentment is beyond considerable. Understandably the grievances are immense.
    92
  5. Spoke to an Irishman, he said Ireland would willingly rejoin the union if it was to start a crusade.
    60
  6. I preferred it when the death cultists went on about the imminent return of Christ rather than making up predictions about the weather.
    57
  7. It's not really contestable, homogenous societies are much stronger and safer.
    56
  8. Hungarians are Mongolians but with a somehow even more nonsensical language. Russians are culturally Mongol slavs (with a historically Germanic leadership) cosplaying as the late Roman empire. Or maybe they are just the Roman Empire: stepp nomad edition, it's hard to tell.
    51
  9. Education is a major problem, it either needs to be heavily reformed (which won't happen, there aren't enough people with the skills to run a better version), or abolished (just in terms of state mandated education), which would work better for some than others, like anything.
    49
  10. A. It doesn't seem to be happening, the opposite in fact. B. At least one cause is it being pushed as deliberate policy in order to divide the society and import a cheap workforce, so no. C. This is not a plague, it's nearly or more damaging over the long term but it's not like shortage of labour is going to be an actual problem (see above), likewise it is very apparent that many traps are in place to gather up the wealth as the more prosperous generations leave us, one is inheritance tax but basically every other component of western economies is structured around asset stripping the generational wealth the boomers still hold. I predict the intention is serfdom, not anything positive, and without a popular revolt led by well organised and coordinated rebel elite, not to mention well funded, then they will get what they want because humans are compliant with power when isolated from support networks, almost certainly a part of the ongoing attacks on any form of social capital that is not filtered through state and corporate institutions. We are by no means in a hopeless predicament, but unless persistent, widespread and radical action is taken we will have one of our own making.
    44
  11. The exponential drop in numbers caused by the same logic as compound interest applied to fertility works just as much in reverse. If people actually have lots of kids within a few generations the population will recover. The bit that matters is making sure people have kids. The debates around if things are too late only adds credence to those rationalizing their desire to cop out as actually doing something about issues like these is potentially a lot of work, and it's much easier to complain than it is to confront issues.
    44
  12. This is probably correct.
    44
  13. There is actually more, but it is suppressed better and has much less political expression. The grooming gangs are a massive issue and much of the working class personally know victims, likewise many of the imported ethnic groups are irreconcilable. If liberally applied central repression by the courts and police lets up for a second or the government gives and impression of weakness a lot of groups will kick off, and unlike in France it will go all the way. The hatred is tangible and real, the community behind the grooming while well organised has made intractable enemies of every group other than the urban liberals, when central authority starts waining (which it will, it has burnt all legitimacy, justification, good will and loyalty, and is morally moribund and financially insolvent) then matters will likely be shifted into military organisation, alliance structures and tribal loyalties. On a wider level the solutions looked at by young people basically split, women wanting bureaucratic oligarchy and men wanting a Franco, I have to doubt the viability of either given the severe lack of competence within our institutions. Whatever happens however there will be severe ethnic conflict. By holding the lid on a boiling pot all the political class is doing is guaranteeing an explosion of extreme resentment, grievance and vendetta.
    43
  14. When people say things can't stay the same they mean that we cannot continue with the current government and very often system of government. They are fully aware that the current political parties won't admit their mistakes let alone rectify it, and indeed that from the elite perspective what is happening isn't a mistake at all. What they are saying is that they will restructure the political framework as necessary, I think you misunderstand the contemporary climate, we are in a sense politically at some point before 1920, the only thing stopping kinetic action from the (largely disenfranchised) opposition is means and opportunity. If their is a world war then expect for us to reach the post-war period very soon, the demoralisation is already near the Russian provisional government level. Indeed one of the notable things in the current climate is how much the motivation precedes the means.
    38
  15. Arranged marriage and the total destruction of social liberalism, money is less of a factor, though pensions and welfare are stealing by the childless.
    32
  16. We have common heritage and civilisation, united we stand divided we fall, organisation of our communities is a first step but without coordination we face defeat in detail.
    31
  17. Here's to the next ten.
    29
  18.  @DeoVindice999  There are no heterogeneous states in africa, africa is tribal and incredibly ethnically diverse.
    28
  19. IQ has gone down over the last century, we aren't happier, such simplistic models have absolutely no value at all even if you can pick up some correlations if you stare hard enough for the specifics to all fudge.
    28
  20. The whole family type things is largely rubbish. Britain historically had many types, but the nobility kept the Norman tradition of oldest son gets all, so did most merchants (with the younger sons becoming employed by the company or setting up offshoots under the main family, part of my own family became rich using this very east Asian tactic), farmers also (specifically in England and Wales, in Scotland it was more communal and in Ireland it was split between sons by the Irish and was the English way with the English and scots). Equally our political developments are not natural, the rights were a clever undermining of noble demands for privileges by universalising them, medieval England was extremely centralised and the aim of the kings was total control through the Anglican church, the non-conformists are at the root of the failure and of the liberal political tradition. We had Filmer, without the glorious revolution and the disempowering of the king we would have become our own strain of absolutist, and that remained a strong strain of toryism for much of it's early history. The idea that we are innately liberal was made up by whig historians and held to by people with no imagination, even now liberal democracy is not a popular system among the population, it is the incumbent one. Equally the English as a people are not even slightly liberal, they are ridiculously conservative, the liberal elite idolize France and find their own people boorish and uncultured. Much of the traditional elite are even less liberal, thus they were destroyed by inheritance tax. The English respect the past, tradition, authority, responsibility and breeding, the lower stadia of society is not ambitious and they like things being in their place, a lack of responsibility or care bothers them, as does unsuitable people leading, they hold it as natural for a noble to lead, but hate managers and people who don't acknowledge their own place. The destruction of jobs and pettiness towards the working class has caused massive damage, the fact is that such behaviour is at odds with the acceptable functioning of things, they are fine being ruled over, but they want respect, they want care and they want a ruling class who have those in their blood, they don't like being treated with derision by some upjumped member of the middle class, and they don't like airs, so pretending to be French or above the local concerns grates like nobody's business. The current ruling class is not just hated, it is seen as illegitimate, among the younger generation this is even more extreme, with many openly hoping for a Franco.
    28
  21. Traditionally in England the elite were rural based, it is a change in the elite itself, we have no responsibility to play by their rules, we have a duty to overturn them.
    22
  22. Many of these ideas seem mutually contradictory, non-democratic republicianism, etc. I don't want a secular society I want Christian monarchy, local autonomy and a crusade.
    20
  23. So people were economically better off under Tsarism or the industrial , then, which is why they had loads of kids. And the late Soviet union was more capitalist than them, which is why they had few.
    20
  24. You forgot that you are dealing with genetics, intelligence is genetic and only the Pacific islanders and Australian aboriginals do worse. Not matter the ethnic make-up of elites a country in that section of the world competent enough to remain a country will be ruled with kinetic power by a small aristocratic style elite. Without them the society will start to resemble the bronze age collapse, the majority have trouble conforming to a complex society, let alone maintaining or building one. Even the elite tend to be on the lower end of average by the standards of anywhere else. Also by giving them free stuff they start trying to create Malthusian cycles, as they don't have the capability for production improvements to break out of it, nor can they because the foundations for it can't be built due to the inability to compete with what is free. It's the welfare trap on a national level.
    20
  25. That is an example of the decayed cultur cultural attitudes and social institutions, part of the overall problem.
    19
  26. Home educate, muligenorational homes are preferable but boomers be cringe, and the heart of the problem. Living in Yurt is one possibility, or multiple people to a room, you can bathe with a basin and towel, the Victorians did. Cut costs, large families, community robustness and tradition are what decides the survival of a people, not material affluence or egalitarianism.
    19
  27. That is only possible in a high trust universalisitic society. We will have to go back to clan structures to have protection in numbers, shared economic power (I mean go luck buying a house or getting a job without pooling resources and influence) and shelter for our women.
    19
  28.  @ffff7164  Let's all get rejected from art school together.
    18
  29. There were riots in the diverse parts (it should be noted that most diversity is replacement), armed gangs went around looking for English people and the police did nothing. There were very serious assaults, the police also did nothing. Most of the English protests were in heavily working class areas, which have been victimised by these groups for decades. On top of this once you account for house prices being insane most of these regions are eastern poland levels of wealth. These people are pretty fed up of being under a tyrannical and evil government.
    18
  30. This is however mostly a problem with the education system, and we are seeing a rise in home education as well as a groundswell of Christian conversion in the younger generation that is largely invisible as they are disenfranchised from the liberalism of the churches, though there is the issue that this is overwhelmingly a male phenomena.
    18
  31. There is always an elite caste, humans are hierarchical and stuff needs to be organised to be done, egalitarianism has been helpful to the current elite as it justified their displacement of elites based on sentiment and bonds of loyalty to people, place, God, the King and oaths. They replaced it with a meritocratic system with a more static class system than feudalism, one in which they rule by exception, "for my friends; everything, for my enemies; the law".
    18
  32. If you call us that then so be it, all it does is mark you, it means nothing to us.
    18
  33. The 1950's were already deep into this problem, the negative associated trends largely started in the 1920's, the birthrate started to downtrend even long before that. What is lacking is strong social institutions and motivation.
    18
  34. Profile pic checks out.
    16
  35. The author is female, she also made Emma, a romance about a Victorian maid, which shows a great deal of love towards my culture and country.
    16
  36. I think it's something like 15% of immigrants we bring in who actually work, most go on benefits or join the shadow economy.
    14
  37. Apostate.
    13
  38. Women are social creatures, they support whatever force manifests as dominant in a society.
    12
  39. They have plenty of both. It is after all a regime based in large part in hedonism, our ancestors would understand it perfectly, however rather than this long description they would adequately sum all of it up with the word 'satanic'.
    11
  40. It is wrong to claim that feminism didn't double the labour force, women before it were not in the same type of work, they were mostly involved in cottage industry, family businesses or very localised jobs, this meant they could still look after and have kids. Once they are in professional company work they are heavily dissuaded from having children and pushed towards greater workforce participation, as women are psychologically agreeable this has marked effects and as they have bills to pay they can't easily escape. Traditional societies had substantially different priorities, they were not profit based but religious and formally hierarchical. The priorities were family, salvation of the soul and a stable social order. This radically factored in to how they acted, to a degree that is hard to imagine for modern people, as we are fish in the waters of the current.
    11
  41. Given them to either Russia or Ukraine as minesweepers.
    11
  42. I would happily live in destitution if my daughters could be safe. It's not about money, it's about us existing in the first place.
    10
  43. Regime change.
    9
  44. Honestly I don't think spreadsheet logic takes into account human free will at all. What happens will not be decided by trendlines and theory based on an expectation that you can extrapolate from the current, but by people making real choices in the real world. Napoleon decided the future of Europe, not data scientists.
    9
  45. It causes genetic problems, also it is the death of a people, two in certain cases.
    9
  46. The housing solution is multi-generational homes and not giving everyone an individual room. Also Japan has very cheap rural housing but everyone moves to the city to try for jobs that largely aren't available and haven't been since the crash.
    8
  47. They cost money to have over here.
    8
  48.  @TheJosman  Yes, it is up to us to save ourselves from extinction.
    8
  49. On top of this the Chinese nationalist support the CCP is relying on is not ideological communist but Chinese traditionalist, if it comes down to hard tacks they would support a return of the imperial system, the central government largely retains their support due to foreign policy, or the fact they consider the growth in the power of China and resistance to the American imperial project to be their primary priority.
    8
  50. Place faith in God and organise, organise, organise. There is something called basket-weaving, become a part of it.
    8
  51. He's talking about the slave trade, but given your origins your family were more likely the traders. Seems like you managed to attract a boomer.
    8
  52. My experience is that democracy has absolutely no legitimacy among young men already. Basically it splits Christian monarchists, secular authoritarians. Whatever happens Liberalism has grim prospects, the main alternative to a rightward swing (what women think is next to irrelevant in a conflict, especially when they aren't even married) is the Islamisation of Europe. This is one of the very few things that is a cause of optimism as to our prospects, that with liberalism's death we may be released of the force strangling our civilisation, and which has devolved us to this point already.
    7
  53. Depends who you marry and the social context, Amish for example are fine.
    7
  54. Tsar gave hard work and autocracy and it was at 7.
    7
  55. Not at all, the managerial regime is highly influenced by marx and the liberal thinkers. The opposition is just traditionalist in nature, meaning it is not very democratic or secular, but then both of those things are intrinsically liberal as expressed in our civilisation. Christianity and ethnic loyalties tend to be the most associated with the rejection of the current ruling system.
    6
  56.  @user-gc7pd3rg7f  It is alive in the hearts of it's believers and justified by the evils of the godless society in which we reside.
    6
  57. They can just force marriages or make baby farms, whatever the solution I'm sure it will be similarly horrific to the one child policy.
    6
  58.  @dasaauploads1143  I for one want Crusading back.
    6
  59. About 20% males in tribal societies die in war each generation, how many women die of child birth is highly dependent on diet but would usually be below that unless they are eating lead or get no vitamins. Of course the women will also likely have enough children for replacement before complications, modern women have a much higher rate of problems due to the pill, age, being fat, and very poor genetic health due to dysgenics. Of course there are lots of other factors and contexts but broadly the claim is false, I could probably point you to the specific exception that proves the rule, they are a small turkic people up in the mountains in central asia, they have the highest rate of childbirth mortality in the world, and thus a young woman shortage.
    6
  60. I imagine that it is a mix of strong traditional social institutions, like family and community, a cultural expectation of marriage and the political situation of coupling western investment with limited social influence due to the state basically being a Russian satellite. That said their are probably social reformers (or traditionalists) who are responsible for actually bringing the situation, and they deserve credit. While it would be somewhat harder we haven't seen Russian social institutions reformed back into a functional pre-soviet state, Putin stated that he wanted them to have more kids, but that is about it, it is fairly clear that the factors that are responsible for fertility are social far more than economic. Not only are social changes lacking, the response is changing the beneficiaries of taxes, not even something basic like going after abortion or contraception, something which would change dynamics without needing a vision of the society to be built.
    6
  61. I'm guessing the dislike of US servicemen is due to their low social prestige and bad reputation (for crime especially). The farmer thing is interesting and sounds like a major problem, I know that Tokyo is the socially prestigious place to be and they have major problems with the sex industry as that is how many women have to fund living there. I wonder what the solutions would be other than a campaign of national shame. Which is unlikely to happen given that western influence is starting to cause things to spiral.
    6
  62.  @nikitatrotsky6918  People would have said the same about serfdom in Poland in 1550, except we have a time limit, at current rates in 50 years europe won't be european, of course I don't think the current elite can hold power but if things take too long they will be toppled by a caliphate rather than the divided and shambolic opposition movements.
    5
  63.  @boatygatling4782  Why invade what you can buy. The Chinese have other priorities, so long as there is enough rail for transportation of food out from Russia Siberia is a low priority.
    5
  64. I am only implying because of this platform, significant disturbances are already taking place, it will be a long process but it will in no respect be peaceful. But some peace 's are unendurable, the one in South Africa for example.
    5
  65.  @chad1682  It's genetics.
    4
  66. The young are at different levels of diversity in different countries, but generally young women are left wing and young men are radically to the right. The minorities may look out for there own interests, but there are more than enough young people for a revolution, the state after all has the same demographics, it's the lack of support among the young that matters. How soon it manifests will be seen, but as the pot boils the pressure goes up rather than down.
    4
  67.  @cazwalt9013  I was memeing, they aren't even the mongol type of asians but from their own group along with the finns.
    4
  68. He's getting it from the Frenchman he cited, and yeah it's pretty wrong, inheritance laws and family structure shifted over time and was different in different classes and ethnic groups. Very often it was explicit laws rather than social traditions that shaped them. For example Tsarist Russia has very extensive laws around personal and family honour as well as succession and practically everything else, likewise they had many groups who did things differently, or didn't care about the law unless they were made to, usually they had their own legal structures. In Britain the Nobility continued Norman attitudes but the rest of the population was much more mixed. It's like trying to use latitude to predict urbanisation, maybe there's a correlation but it's basically a fluke, other factors lead to it happening.
    4
  69. How?
    4
  70. Appeal to wig history. Also there has been a resurgence of Christianity among the zoomers, it's main flaw is that it's almost entirely male.
    4
  71. They have an overly corporate business sector, but rents, living costs and the availability of work are actually much better than in the west. The main thing eating them away is despondency (most expected a corporate job and a standard of living they will never get) and the insistence that work hours equate to productivity. However in most regards they are in a much better situation, notably their elite culture is much better (for Japan, South Korea makes eastern Europe look above board) and most of the problems are caused by them importing western fashions in the same way as they used to Chinese ones without really understanding the underlying logic or motivations.
    4
  72. The child of such a union is more genetically distant from you than a random person from your people. If east Asian you are getting into a Celt being more related to an eastern slav than them territory. You are basically fabricating new races of men as the same applies on the other side, they are not of one group but rather of their own. In other words it's a terrible idea, shortsighted and exacerbates this problem in other countries. The only solution is to put your foot down and reject the current social norms of western society. Whether that is through Christianity or the political disenfranchisment of socially irresponsible groups and their interests.
    3
  73. Best I can do is a Hapsburg, one based out of Budapest.
    3
  74. Being an Englishman I see is as a repeat of the migration period (also known as the dark ages), but that period was a lot worse for Britain than the rest of Europe, with the Romano-British being wiped out in genocide by the Anglo-Saxons. We already have some truly horrific stuff happening with Rotherham and the like. I'm in the Christian camp, as far as I'm concerned it is the basis and only future for western civilisation. But liberalism must be utterly expunged, while if possible restoring the English liberties that formed the basis of it's justification for a parliamentary oligarchy usurping power from the anointed monarch and by it God. I recommend Robert Filmer by Imperium Press. As I see it we are in for very hard times, and we should start collaborating and building organisational structures now so that we aren't vulnerable to groups who are better organised and more cohesive. Really the trouble has already started.
    3
  75. Places without state pensions or with very low ones still have low birthrates, notably China, though also Russia to a certain extent.
    3
  76. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that people should watch an old anime called Shiki, I'm seeing a lot of people in the comments who seem to think paradigms don't shift much. That is not part of human psychology, changes easily happen in an exponential manner, a paradigm shift is radical, so long as power shifts then with that shift will come a totally different stance towards these things. Read here was like reading French liberals who thought that the King would oversee the revolution prior to it. If the current order loses power then we will not be thinking about things within the perview of their system, if they don't lose power then nothing with change at all.
    3
  77. There are notable outliers, especially among women who live in parallel societies (like communal religious groups) or frankly autistic ones (which women involved in this scene very often are, not to disparage them, they come out with a lot of valuable contributions).
    3
  78. Convert to Islam as you might as well be a Muslim. The heritage of the West is Christian.
    3
  79. Yes, many of these classes were themselves ethnic in origin, in a sense this is even taken into right to rule, almost all British nobility claim Norman ancestry, most have more recent (by that I mean medieval or early modern, most of the actual new ones have clear family trees so aren't able to make it up as much, that said the merchant family I was talking about claimed to have broken into Charles the First's prison and been personally conferred nobility for offering to break him out, supposedly the evidence was eaten by mice and the family were whig Methodists who were burnt in effigy for supporting the America revolution, the likelihood is faintly ridiculous in other words, there actual place in the imperial hierarchy was based on being a very prominent business family in the colonies). The loyalties were also religious, non-conformists, Catholics and Anglicans all have very different political and social sympathies. On top of this personal characteristics passed down through family lines, certainly liberteanism can be traced through family trees very easily, those who acted a certain way it one generation were often related to those who did so in another. In other words nations and countries are complicated things, they aren't run on a single software but off a confluence of groups, people's and idea's. This is why liberal reform in Russia never went the same as it did in England and never went how it was meant to at all. Personally one of the things I heavily dislike about the revival of late 19th century and early 20th century progressives is that racial science is very largely bunk, quite apart from the degree of relevance they very often are talking utter nonsense when trying to define these groups. It's like astrology for men.
    3
  80. Contraceptives means that people only have a higher fertility rate with higher sexual contact if stupid (literally, the sub-80 iq people are typically the only ones who have above replacement as they can't work out how to use contraceptives properly and are too lazy to do anything once they are pregnant, also children are less of a bother if you just don't look after them), the higher rates of sex does lead to more pregnancies outside of marriage (because contraceptives don't work 100%) but this is then want abortion is used for. The higher rates of sex only matter among the people who want children (as in are trying for them, most people who won't have children do want them but will never get round to it) or if contraceptives or abortion are banned (and well, contraceptives lead to a sickening social context and abortion is baby murder). Our options are encourage people to marry young (probably through a traditional religion) or force the circumstances into a state where they have to (which would basically turn this whole thing around tomorrow but would have to be enforced). Frankly we might as well do both.
    3
  81. They are Mediterranean or South European. Western Europe is sometimes considered more broadly, but usually it means Scandinavia, German, France, the UK and states in the middle when people.remember they exist. Switzerland is probably both western and northern European, but Spain exists in the same plane of existence to most northern Europeans as Greece or Cyprus, they are hot, by the sea and the economy is bad.
    3
  82.  @samalaimukhametova7290  Yes, I'm British, this manga is about central asia, her old one was about Britain, it was called emma, this one is a Brides tale. Emma is a competently done romance story about a maid. A brides tale is a masterpiece in the way of art, historical research and storytelling.
    3
  83. J. D. Vance is intellectually influenced by many of the thinkers talking about these problems. That is why those on the intellectual right were pleasantly surprised by his pick, he wasn't a neo-con so the future of the American right might well be something that actually wants to do stuff for the country and not just lower taxes and bomb strangers.
    2
  84. Give it time.
    2
  85. Same birthrate as Europe, it's basically liberal cultural values and social organisation.
    2
  86. To understand the actual value of these things one should consider Poland and Russia, Poland had a powerful nobility who exercised considerable freedom and power, Russia had the same but was also autocratic and religious. The Polish nobility failed to guard the interests of the nation, and lost everything as the price of their freedom, Russia was in many respects a miserable country, but there tenacity, high birth rate, and willingness to sacrifice meant that they became dominant. The current elite are not economically very productive, they are basically selling of the nation bit by bit in return for the industrial production of the outwardly poorer nations. They are selling the family silver in order to live the high life for a single generation. They also have no higher loyalties and few children. They are the dead walking. The populace has been debauched and is not in a good state at all, they have no real leadership and follow on in the mistakes of their betters. But they can feel the knife in their back even they can't form a proper vanguard. They are angry. The future is for young people willing to form a new elite and lead a revival, as part of this is the total rejection of enlightenment liberalism and loyalty to God and people. Such a vanguard will in a sense be both reactionary and revolutionary. It is clear that this will come from non-university educated young men, and that they shall be defined by a willingness to use force. Questions like what a certain demographic wants are a question of democracy, something which is increasingly not a moral question at all, but merely one of a few vestiges of legitimacy. You ask what will happen with college educated women, they will either become married mothers or else have the social safety net cut from beneath them. We are looking either at the death of a civilisation and people, or else at the death of liberalism and liberal democracy. There is not solution to fix the status quo, the status quo is itself the Gordian knot, and problem such that it has decided on its own solution, past that it is an issue of power and resolve.
    2
  87. Women are not to be taken very seriously at all, they usually don't know the first thing of what they are talking about, men stand by causes, women use them against other women, either to status signal, sabotage or force uniformity, if you treat them like serious people they will think less of you. The trick is to have their best intentions for them, that is you forward their actual interests (feeling secure, having lots of babies and being able to one up other women) on their behalf, all the ideological stuff would be windowdressing if not given hard power by the legal system and the resentful advice of other women. People who demand respect are pathetic, and should be treated as such, otherwise they are emboldened.
    2
  88. Also the Irish were made to split lands between sons by law, a cause of the famine, the whole thing is pretty wrong. It seems like the theory came before the categorisation.
    2
  89. Yeah, that doesn't exist in Britain.
    2
  90. Doomerism like this is a self-fulfilling prophecy. People who are demotivated are much less active. I was unlucky enough the other day to hear about research into the survival instincts of rats, if a rat was dropped it water it would drown in about 20 minutes, if it had previously been saved from drowning they would hold on for 7 hours. Hope is a hell of a drug. Also single young men predicts political instability far more than old people, the tension in places like Britain could be lit up with a match, they only thing holding them back is that they don't know how to revolt, why or when, they are all waiting for someone else to make the first move so if it fails they go down for it instead, if there is a moment of weakness from the state things here will go nuclear. And every year it doesn't happen the opposition is getting better organised, more radical and far more mainstream.
    2
  91. The Russians simply wouldn't let them leave. Also Europe is in way worse straits, they are economically doomed and are looking at the mass scale replacement of their populations by hostile Muslim migrants. Hopefully things will change, but if the current ruling class remains in place we are looking at the death of europe.
    2
  92.  @prohacker5086  By is that capitalism, or is it social causes and thus a counterpoint to the op.
    2
  93. Who said any of us were democrats or cared about democracy. In talking about these issues their are higher loyalties involved, those to family, ethnos and God. What is happening is not a refinement of liberalism but a rejection of it.
    2
  94. They won't, the western elite believe everyone is the same and they can use immigration to bring in a serf class, the reality is a repeat of what happened to Anatolia, 1000 years ago it was Greek now it is Turkey. Unfortunately many Indian nationalists seem to mostly enjoy the shoe being on the other foot rather than offering solidarity. Internally Europe is very weak, Christianity is almost extinct and the liberal ideologies don't even understand religious motivation and thin the Muslims are allies because they also want to deconstruct western civilisation. Here in Britain the government sides with them against the population, look up Rotherham, what happens is not fit for the youtube bots.
    2
  95.  @CruWiT  That is an old tactic in war, but the Chechens are a power block, not an existential threat being incubated within Russia.
    2
  96.  @VR36030  The free democratic method is mass importation, if the current regime isn't overturned by the native population it will be once the new population take over, our options are basically an end to liberalism, or a Islamisation of Europe happening under the logic of keeping the pensions paid up. terrifying and unnatural than the past. The 20th century was way worse than anything that happened in medieval Europe short of the Mongols (which only the Hungarians, Poles and Russians really had to deal with). But medieval times weren't really authoritarian, centralised power wasn't that strong, they ran on very strong social institutions. Many different communities lived in relative peace, bound only by faith and oaths of loyalty (under nationalism the deportation or forced integration minority groups was necessary as the idea of popular sovereignty made them potential nodes of power). A state education system is way more authoritarian on it's own than anything they had, it also meant that the values and skills passed down to children were subject to evolutionary logic, today we manage to retain utterly bizarre values only by the indoctrination of the youth into a dominant system of belief, one which is probably behind the fertility problems. abortion are banned and the parties invested in them are purged from the elite class then most of these issue will have nowhere to go but resolution, the majority of the population as ever will form their sense of morality around the law and tell themselves that they always supported what they are compelled to do.
    2
  97. Hmmm, I wonder why you would advocate this. In other news as a Brit I think everyone should summit to the rule of the British Empire, we have the most experience after all.
    2
  98. Rape capital of the northern hemisphere, and given the cultural enrichment of so much of the rest of it, there is some stiff competition.
    2
  99. That doesn't matter, what does is that the social norms promoted by religion include large families, a positive attitude towards children and a hatred of contraceptives. At least within Christianity.
    2
  100. The slaveholding is literally just an American import, it really doesn't graft well onto European experiences at all, also we have a very small black population who are recent and can't claim oppression as much for the reason they are so criminal and dysfunctional (most of it is probably influence from American black culture and the facilitation of the welfare state). In terms of colonisation the big one is Germany despite not really having that history before WW2, it is very much a deliberate policy by American intelligence working with the Frankfurt school to neuter potential rivals and create vassal states and the correct mindset nationally. This is especially targeted at the elite, the population are actually better informed. How progressive a country is is in truth how atheist they are and their proximity to US foreign policy and specific campaigns and client networks set up in the past. Progressivism really is the imperial ideology of America.
    2
  101. Dude, look up Rotherham, you aren't a scapegoat if you are literally worse than they say.
    2
  102.  @Adai_nagibator228  I must say, it has made me like your culture quite a bit, especially as our own ancestors were steppe nomads from the Pontic steppe and the traditions persisted for a long time. In particular a lot of the fashion and social elements were very much prominent in medieval and early modern Europe, though not the clan system or Islamic faith.
    2
  103. It was the first European nation with demographic problems, firm proof that they are caused by liberal values.
    2
  104. Population collapse is literally a collapse, it's like an inverse pyramid, it is in no way manageable.
    1
  105. Men want kids, this only works if she is under 35 and willing to engage in a serious relationship rather than date for fives years to decide.
    1
  106. They might manage something but they will have to fight off resurgent Turkish and Persian imperialism to do it. If they can beat every other power in the middle east without external aid, hold up an economy in a time of crisis and reform the whole political system to freeze the liberals out of power then they will be fine but those are big asks. They do however have a better chance than most European states just because they have an element who have both competence and power. In Europe improvement can only come with political revolution, and revolution is often as not in the habit of making things worse so that's merely the first condition in an insurmountable task.
    1
  107. Dozen+
    1
  108. Not that simple at all, most resources are owned at the top, the corps will buy it all up before you can make the capital. Also you will be crushed to pay for the elderly, and the society will be sectarian due to immigration. In short the solution is not patience.
    1
  109. Death tax is 50% in my country, also great, I can start thinking about kids in my 60's should they live long enough and not burn it in that time.
    1
  110. The belief in logic comes from the belief in a logical God.
    1
  111. You know a lot of wealthy people, there is nothing like that here, just depression and nihilism.
    1
  112. Longer, they came in Victorian times. Frankly good on them if true.
    1
  113. It's nice to hear from an Indian who isn't celebrating this.
    1
  114. The actual solution is older social norms, like arranged marriage and women not being educated.
    1
  115. Socialism argues actively for much of what has been built, it is materialistic and morally deranged (with it's ideals taken whole cloth from Rousseau, who believed that humans were innately good creatures corrupted by the existence of society, the ideal of communism is Rousseau's ideal on man free from all bonds, if you have even a basic understanding of human nature and history you will no this is insane, man was never pre-social and making him so is a form of torture, no wonder the social reforms towards this aim have lead to an immense mental crisis in the populations on which it is inflicted). Capitalism as an ideology has little to recommend it, but it is not like socialism is in any sense an answer, indeed they are as bad if not worse.
    1
  116. You did though, it went down when abortion was legalised, went up again when Stalin banned it and then went down again when it was legalised again. The Russian mother in 1914 had 9 children, Russia would have half a billion people today if not for communism, need I mention China.
    1
  117. It literally would, 4 hour shift would get halve wages, children would force the reallocation to resources. Which we have, we just prioritise luxury like individual rooms and not living with family. People in the past had plenty of kids with much less.
    1
  118. Home education is needed.
    1
  119. Machiavellian religion is self-contradicting, it won't happen.
    1
  120. Bots, scam, bots, scam.
    1
  121. Voting implies the continuation of liberal democracy.
    1
  122. Positive video for once.
    1
  123.  @Hasanaljadid  Less turks.
    1
  124. There are many discontented intelligent young men who could form such an elite, unfortunately they are ideologically divided and do not have the power base or independent wealth to do more than get on board with any likely contenders. At the moment the paypal mafia are seemingly positioning themselves in opposition to the regime and community building projects are in the works, but really anything is find so long as it can dislodge the current elite classes, who have utterly violated all right to rule. As for predictions beyond that, while take a look at some of the Chinese dynastic founders and imagine whether you would have guessed a prison guard could found the Han dynasty or the like.
    1
  125. Almost certainly, but it won't be public policy unless 4chan storms the legislative body, the future will merely be inherited by those who have children, and they won't practice female emancipation.
    1
  126. Having children over 35 has as high a rate of developmental difficulties as incest.
    1
  127. Amish.
    1
  128.  @LucasFernandez-fk8se  They have invoked a blood debt against my people, I don't see it that way at all.
    1
  129.  @deborafernandes1026  I mean, it's the basis of your entire biology and psychology and basically your entire function on a society wide level, this both makes women potentially more valuable than men as mothers but means that women who won't become mothers are just defective men, at least after feminism has twisted them into a parody of toxic male stereotypes. The calling of men is to be fathers and women to be mothers, without that you are just a human resource on a spreadsheet somewhere. People call have higher callings in monastic life but frankly the vast majority of singles in our society are just debased savages responding to stimuli and blindly following predatory social conventions. The fact is that the Amish will exist in 1000 years, the modern man will have trouble with ten and be extinct in 100. There is a reason that all successful societies repressed the rights of women, first off innate rights are made up nonsense and no one has them, secondly they didn't have to because women are pathologically socially conformist and largely are the enforcing body of social expectations, the problem is that this is related to prestige and the prestigious thing for women in current society is eat her children and become a wage slave for a soulless corporation enforcing the standards of evil on a deeply corrupt society. I large part however telling them that is pointless as unless they are autistic they will only move with prestige and social affirmation, thus it is up to men to build systems and women to beautify and preserve them in order to gatekeep other women. Amish and Muslim women don't care about your standards as they are low prestige within their social context, they can safely look down on you as a skank just as you look down on them as oppressed, and what can you say, they at least have a happy family and are respected by the men in their life, you aren't even respected by the men in your own society, and as a woman you likely know how much the respect of women outside your specific clique of long-time friends is worth.
    1
  130. Japan is under huge western pressure to accept mass immigration, if it does it won't last long, it will be flooded in very short order as land is cheap and it is known as a first world country. Probably the first wave will be fleeing westerners and the ones after that the same people who have invaded Europe.
    1
  131. The middle East was Christian until long after the Islamic conquest, what we see is the result after over a millennia of arabisation.
    1
  132. Because democratic is not representative, it is oligarchy by a managerial class running state institutions and large corporations, voting is windowdressing as a justification for power.
    1
  133. Lib dems basically, they buy up housing in rural villages, live segregated and get all their information from the media, living outside of reality they never see it for themselves. Meanwhile the working class live with the consequences, the upper class are mostly gone (inheritance tax having destroyed them over the last century) and the managerial class that runs things actively supports evil and has willing done most of what has happened.
    1
  134. Populist delusion, democracy is not representative. The majority population are not guilty of things imposed by the elite, they don't deserve what they get for the misfortune of being the victims of treason. Nor does the common man have much responsibility to change what he has no power over, it is our responsibility to such people to wield power in their interests and it is our duty to punish the evil that is the current elite class and their system.
    1
  135.  @prohacker5086  France Secularised before anyone else. It's do do with social institutions and prioritisation, we no longer have courting, tight community support networks and the norm of marrying young, nor do we have the religious motivation to put a large family above personal comforts and career progression. There are a lot of factors but most are social, the economic side is more about self-perceived security and prosperity than anything that if real outside of how it motivates action. A society wanting kids would have arranged marriage, strong communities and families willing to live in a single room and spend very little. The problem is that people would like a kid or two as a lifestyle choice before they hit 40 but after they have done everything else. Financial systems can be fixed, dealing with the nature of the society itself is far more difficult.
    1
  136. A recent UK government report said that the plan for the future of the country was a continuous inflow of Africans for the rest of the century.
    1
  137. There is a reason people talk about crusades, they want to burn down the world of there enemies after sweeping them out. For the same reason after reconquest the Spainish spent several centuries attacking North Africa and taking every opportunity to fight with the Ottomans.
    1
  138. They thought the King would be a liberal and that they would institute their ideas within the existing political system, they were wrong, people often are, as they have a normalcy bias. We will indeed see what happens, but I doubt it will be what is predicted in this video and others.
    1
  139.  @theinnerlight8016  They have literally mentioned it as a strength against Russia in recent policy plans.
    1
  140. This is deeper than national cultures, western culture is based on Christianity, for Asia to adopt the same moral assumptions they would have to become Christian. Many of the immigrants the West are Muslim, they will eat the societies out from the inside as the moral systems are not even slightly compatible. Also immigration does nothing about shit culture, western nations will lose their character hollowing out developing nations and then die because they have become nothing more than a failed economic model which feeds off foreign young.
    1
  141. Finland has had grooming gangs.
    1
  142. Hahahahaha, yeah let's try and logic women into making massive risks with their social prestige, I'm sure telling them about problems will really help them. Not, create solutions and then open the door to womem, a collaborative process is part of marriage, but not of relations between the sexes and engaging on that level is like trying to negotiate land rights with monkeys.
    1
  143. Economy is probably the overwhelming factor but certain ethnicities have a tradition of military service and it has become culturally ingrained, the Cossacks would probably be the most interesting group as they have the most contradictions, though if they are even such a group is contentious as one could argue that the Soviet effort to wipe them out was successful and what we see now is a conscious effort at recreation sponsored by the state.
    1
  144. Lol, it is internationally recognised as a state, and legally and in practice acts like one. You could similarly claim that America is not a legitimate entity because they were formed by rebellion.
    1
  145. Mohammad communed with demons, not God.
    1
  146. About the Asians you are wrong, there is considerable intermixing, some is native women converting, but a great deal is unwilling, the grooming gangs are massive and have affected the lives of 100'000's of women and girls at least. The Pakistani community is one of the most powerful within our highly corrupt and disgusting political system, that said they also hold a precarious position, literally every other group outside of the elite holds overwhelming enmity towards them, if things broke down they would be the first targets of anger not only by the British but the Black, Indian and Sikh communities, they are a protected class and have abused that protection to predate on everyone else. Gypsies are practically loved in comparison. Either this nation will be totally destroyed or it's elite will, there is no compromise, the only legitimacy at this point is in pure power, the ruling class have burnt up all good will and thrown patience on with it. This whole country is like a boiling pot with the lid on, it doesn't look nearly as volatile as it is. Ultimately people will take the form of resistance open to them, but they will remain implacable enemies of those who got us here.
    1
  147. Yay, more of the same. Who do you think has pushed all the policies that led to this.
    1
  148. This view is called wig history and it's false.
    1
  149. While this is true in a sense it fails to account for how culture and social norms effect the priorities of people.
    1
  150. They don't have kids and many of them express beliefs very similar to older doomsday cults. Increasingly said elite also is very ethnically and culturally distinct from the population, there is little chance of them having a road to Damascus moment, and even if they did it would probably not be in a stable way just like their current policies.
    1
  151. An upsidedown pyramid is literally a collapse in demographic terms. It might even be worse as it accelerates over time rather than being a linear fall.
    1
  152.  @chisaki703  Yes you are, the Russian army was literally deployed to stabilise your regime. Not like I'd deny that my own country (UK) and the rest of the West are all American protectorates.
    1
  153.  @FOLIPE  African-Americans are not only 10-20% Ulster-Scot, but also as they are. Which is to say that standardised test scores are worthless if they don't have any reflection in reality. More comparable are native African migrants, who genuinely are decent, of course they are also the cream of their countries, the people who should be back home leading. The old leadership were stupid, a bit like the current leadership of the west (which like is the west is because liberalism is a universalising religion, egalitarianism is baked into the moral system, as it a pathology in terms of the idea of the individual). Unlike them however they were reacting to immense international cohesion. Of course like with Israel; maintaining a hostile population was never going to work out, and unlike them they never had the stomach nor vision to admit that.
    1
  154. State power will have to be used to reverse these trends, an American way of looking at things will fail like it has in America, we need a new elite and different regime, not to plead for limits on those with more power than us.
    1
  155. Yes, probably, either with Islamisation or the total defacement of anything associated with the old regime.
    1
  156.  @alexk3604  Where did the Germanic tribes originate from, the problem the Romans had was that every time a tribe came out of the steppe they displaced everyone a bit to the west in a domino effect leading to a Germanic invasion of/attempted migration to Gaul.
    1
  157. Not 'we', the British elite pushing it but they are a very small class, they use media to make themselves seem bigger and education systems to propagandise. The vast majority of the nation are not self hating even with propaganda.
    1
  158.  @alexpotts6520  The first half of the twentieth century was practically dominated by the raise, fall and forced emplacement of democracies in the west. When a system loses it's legitimacy don't expect it to be very stable.
    1
  159.  @ivancho5854  Yeah, before my time, I have had to grow up with this propaganda everywhere. Got into history and found out that the temperatures go up and down and that is an important factor in understanding contexts. I mean it won't stop these people, it has become a livelihood and its not like logic is paramount, the claims of prediction of the second coming are outright denied in the Bible but it never stopped those people and you still have groups like the American evangelicals who are trying to fulfil doomsday prophesies through foreign policy, if you actually get into theology their claims are even more exhausting than those of the eco people.
    1
  160. Found the boomer, guess the Russian serfs also should have just worked harder.
    1
  161.  @samalaimukhametova7290  You can find both series, translated and free, on mangadex.
    1
  162. It won't be, women are social monitor devices, they will follow what they think is prestigious and what other women do, giving them a pay rise will only facilitate them continuing within the system, they still very largely follow it despite limited actual worth. Contraception needs to be banned and women removed from the workforce, welfare should be obliterated, and marriage and family brought back. Given how women are they will support it once it happens, just like they have always done irrespective of the actual cause. At least it will be a cause that actually makes them happy as women genuinely like children and security, while they mostly don't understand ideology even if they find it very important to give off the impression that they are part of whatever the current fashion is.
    1
  163. There isn't much of a distinction, black nationalists hate all white people, likewise with progressivism you are basically dealing with a form of national socialism targeted at whites (though amusingly the poor old Jews still aren't out of the crosshairs as these people categorise them as white). An enemy is an enemy whether they have you on the first or second course.
    1
  164. I would not trust the UK state media apparatus at all, we have know for some time that intelligence services have extensive planning on place to suppress discontent from the population. In many regards we are simply living in a Soviet style state, even more so now that we have show trials to go with the psychological operations. The whole mosque thing it seems like was a media narrative, the protest was on a road near where the attack happened and there happened to be a mosque there, the protests themselves were largely unplanned and were drummed up on Facebook and Instagram rather than Twitter, the sort of people who went aren't the sort to have much cared about narrative control or disinformation. As a Brit I can say this was utterly predictable, even if other groups cause trouble they mostly keep it to themselves, there is one group that has made themselves enemies of practically every other, and the working class has been dealing with their grooming gangs for decades now. The media lie more easily than they breathe, it is their entire purpose, all the rest is merely to gain trust for the lying. I wouldn't believe anything from them at all, if there were photographs they were almost certainly staged, if things actually happened they won't have reported on it. They are pure propaganda outfits, all of them. Every other institution is rotten to the core, the police are a partisan force, they side with some communities and actively facilitate them in victimising others. The legal system is an insult to justice. The public and private sectors are an incestuous grouping of corporate monoliths animated by pension funds and controlled by a managerial elite who are totally disconnected from responsibilities and standards. The political sphere is almost a mockery of the ideals of governance, they are corrupt, incompetent, arrogant, foolish and malicious, they have no virtues and are generally too insignificant as people to embody any great sins, they are merely children in charge of a vast apparatus of power, who don't understand it, nor do they try, they are content to play king on the castle while the country burns. There predecessors destroyed every institution and social norm sacred to the nation and these lot are just content to let anything left slip into the sea, along with our future and existence as a people. The only solution is revolution, the rotting edifices must be swept away and clear space created for the foundations of a civilisation to be relaid on whatever remains. There are so many problems that solutions are easy, everywhere you turn there are problems that can be fixed if only they would be seen to, but there are deeper problems as well, all the institutions must be destroyed, there is no saving what they have become, and thus a generation of men able to built are needed to see to new structures being built up. Our other option is to go out of history, to through inaction see our people go extinct and our children destroyed. I speak for many when I say I would rather have the hardships of now than have my children face it, as that is the duty of parents.
    1