General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
ItCouldBe Lupus
Ryan Chapman
comments
Comments by "ItCouldBe Lupus" (@itcouldbelupus2842) on "Ryan Chapman" channel.
Previous
1
Next
...
All
We all should.
2
You have no idea what CRT is
2
Why not?
2
He's wrong and that is not what CRT is or wants people to think.
2
Every fascist movement in existence has been cloaked in lies, posturing and disinformation. It doesn't matter if you call yourself a socialist, if you kill all the real socialists and send people to death camps then you're a fascist. Actions matter more than words. I can define myself as a kind and gentle person but if I do it while punching you in the face then you probably shouldn't take my word for it.
1
Exactly! Fascists lie, what they call themselves is not what defines them.
1
The N@zis were fascists.
1
Wait, Hitler wasn't a fascist because he was vegan and incompetent? What? Are you ignoring all the death camps and eugenics? Fascism is a loser ideology about blood and soil, that describes Hitler perfectly.
1
This isn't objective at all, he's very biased and completely subjective
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. No they weren't. The called themselves National socialists because it made them more acceptable, they killed all the real socialists on the night of the long knives. They were supported by Capitalist corporations and put people in death camps, they believed in Eugenics. That's what fascists do, they lie and call themselves one thing but do something else. They didn't believe in almost anything socialists believe. Just because a political party has a certain name that they give themselves doesn't mean that name accurately describes what they are. Actions matter more than words and titles. They are textbook fascism. Socialism doesn't believe in scapegoating or final solutions.
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. What's the difference between a socialist and a national socialist? Once again most of your evidence is just things Hitler said, I'm inclined not to take him at his word. It literally doesn't matter what he referred to himself as, that's irrelevant. Are you claiming that the Nazis didn't kill or imprison all the socialists? What things did they believe that socialists also believe?
1
This is not an in depth explanation
1
Free markets will always lead to big corporations and eventually to fascism.
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. Then why do fascists always work with big corporations? I know the myth of the free market is that it allows competition but those with the most money always win that competition, that's always going to be corporations. Capitalism leads to fascism, we're seeing it right now in the united states'.
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. Do you think fascism and socialism are essentially the same thing?
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. and you think the workers had ownership of the means of production in Nazi Germany? Socialism is a Leftwing ideology, fascism is a far right ideology. What you are saying doesn't make sense.
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. I don't know any socialists who would agree with that definition. Socialism is a stepping stone to communism, a transitional system out of capitalism into communism. Communism is the final step, not under the umbrella. Who defined this umbrella of socialism? Where are you getting this from? Why is your definition more accurate than all the socialists who are alive today? Seems like your definitions are out of date and narrow.
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. Who decided that was the definition of socialism? Where are you getting that from? If it literally is the definition then it shouldn't be hard to cite where that originated.
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. Hey, so do you consider National Socialism a right wing branch of socialism that is different from the left wing branches of socialism?
1
@Historia.Magistra.Vitae. So it doesn't bother you that everyone who was fighting the Nazis called them fascists and so did all the people running from them? Because they don't meet the narrow definition that you read in a particular book? You don't think ideologies evolve over time, depending on the point in history and the needs of the movement? Sorry to ask you so many questions, but you've thus far asserted yourself as an authority on the subject, and while I'm not sure if I agree with you, I am sure that I am not at all an expert on the subject. What do you think of Umberto Eco's 14 defining features of Fascism?
1
If the Nazis weren't fascists then what were they?
1
@janvarga4023 What's the difference between a fascist and national socialist?
1
@ES-qm5hr Nazis are fascists.
1
Yes it is. They weren't socialist. They believed in Eugenics and final solutions.
1
The GOP is a fascist party, it isn't an echo. GOP followers are asking their leaders at political conventions when they can sign up for the firing squad. Literally. The GOP embodies all of Umberto Eco's 14 defining features of Fascism.
1
Can you define national socialism? How does it differ from Socialism? Seems like Hitler had more in common with fascists than socialists, considering he killed all the socialists.
1
Previous
1
Next
...
All