General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Arty
The Armchair Historian
comments
Comments by "Arty" (@arty5876) on "Downfall of Germany: The Western Front (1/2) | Animated History" video.
John Cornell no, germans were defeated in East before they started to diverting troops on West. Invasion of Italy was succesful only because Germany didn't had too much troops
2
John Cornell Hitler cancelled oparation Cutadelle after german armoured units in Kursk were destroyed or become bad shaped. In Italy Germany had small army of 160 000 men against 540 000 allies, Italy was disarmed, when in Kursk Germany concentrated 780 000 soldiers against 2 000 000 soviets. Even if Germany had 50-80 000 more troops in Kursk, they couldn't won battle of Kursk, but if Germany could have 220-350 000 more troops in Italy, Allies couldn't sipmy throw naval desants in empty undefended areas behind german lines, and push german lines to easy.
2
John Cornell also don't forget about battle of Stalingrad and soviet massive assault for nearly 1 000 kilometres after that. Don't forget about battle of Moscow and Rjew
2
John Cornell Western Allies were success only because Germany concentrated most of troops in the East
2