Comments by "Arty" (@arty5876) on "Real Reporter" channel.

@vlad-dz6db с чего бы это вдруг российская армия является нацистской? И с каких пор современный российский правящий режим является нацистским? Это обычная бюрократическая коррумпированная клановая система, которая высосала из пальца символику после 24 февраля 2022. У Путина нет никакой идеологии. С чего это вдруг он нацист, если в Москве половина населения это узбеки? Напридумывали себе красивые сказки про "рижим"
12
Знак Z - это обозначение группировки "запад" в российской армии. В вооружённых силах всех стран Мира принятно использовать латинские буквы. Например американские войска в Ираке использовали знаки "V", а также есть фотографии времён Второй Мировой, где на американских и британских боевых самолётах нанесены знаки "Z" и "V". Иными словами, это стандартные буквенные обозначения подразделений во всех странах Мира. Просто в России само общество, сами россияне, чтобы выразить солидарность со своей армией, культивировали эти буквы.
11
We don't care about their forgivness
11
In all countries and societies across the World there is some small part of population, who want to serve in military, who want some adrenaline
8
Во-первых Путин или российское руководство никогда не говорило, что НАТО хочет напасть. Во-вторых, нападать и не нужно - сам факт расширения НАТО к границам России нарушает принцип общей и неделимой безопасности. А зачем НАТО расширяется к границам России? В-третьих, нас больше волновало не расширение НАТО, а пороховая бочка на Донбассе. В 2014 и 2015 году Россия выступила посредником в переговорах между Украиной и повстанцами на Донбассе. Украина два раза подписывала Минские соглашения в 2014 и 2015 годах. Россия заняла ещё тогда чёткую позицию, нацеленную на поддержку повстанцев и заморозку конфликта. Однако Украина по всей видимости не хочет замораживать конфликт. Украина хочела получить гарантии безопасности от НАТО, чтобы безнаказанно атаковать ДНР и ЛНР. Если бы Россия не напала на Украину, то Украина вступила бы в НАТО и безнаказанно атаковала бы Донбасс. Россия в таком случае не смогла бы помочь повстанцам. Так что у нас не было выбора и не было других вариантов. Если бы наши войска не зашли в Украину, то украинские войска атаковали бы повстанцев на Донбассе.
6
@prkp7248 there is no "independent" journalists. People have their own opinion, or paid by money. And no one could be 100% independent in their analysis. This guy is Russian, and he mostly reacts to Western media topics. Western media said more than one year ago, that our economy would be destroyed, that we would live in poverty. But de facto we overcame the sanctions very well, and West also caused a damage to itself, Eastern Europe, Poland, Baltics suffered from inflation even worser than Russia. We still have Western products as a significant part of our consumer market.
5
And what happened to the Germans? They were evicted from the bombed-out houses and taken to Germany, where they quietly continued to live, and where life eventually returned to normal. And Russia took Kaliningrad absolutely rightly for all the suffering that was inflicted on the Russian people during the war years.
4
@vlad-dz6db Украина хотела получить гарантии безопасности от НАТО, чтобы атаковать повстанцев на Донбассе. Россия начиная с 2014 года пыталась заморозить этот конфликт, решить всё путём переговоров. В 2014 и 2015 годах Россия два раза выступала в роли посредника на переговорах между Украиной и повстанцами. Украина два раза в 2014 и 2015 годах подписывала Минские соглашения. Однако ни Украина, ни повстанцы не хотят заморозки конфликта. Украина хотела получить гарантии безопасности от НАТО, чтобы атаковать Донбасс. Даже в таких условиях в конце 2021 года Россия попыталась решить всё мирным путём, через переговоры, которые проходили в Женеве. Но ничего не получилось, потому что Мировой гигемон (США) не считает Россию страной, чьи интересы можно уважать и чьё мнение можно слушать.
4
T-72s are Russia's best tanks? Not mentioning how many tanks Russia have and how little amount of Abrams tanks there were in Ukraine. If Ukraine had not 31, but few hundreeds of Abrams tanks, the casualities and amount of captured vehicles could have been higher
3
Yeah, because this is interview in Russian military. Author is asking some interesting questions to soldiers, but they are answering by words they were told to ask
3
Та мобилизация, которая проводится в России, она по сути добровольческая. Война не объявлена, идет так называемая спецоперация. А значит юридических обоснований для мобилизации нет. Ты можешь спокойно проигнорировать повестку по мобилизации, и тебе ничего за это не будет. В России за 3 месяца не было заведено ни одно уголовное дело за уклонение от мобилизации.
3
In Crimea in 2013, prior to annexation, according to statistics from the Ukrainian Interior Ministry, Russians made up 60% of the population, while Ukrainians made up just 16% of Crimea's population in 2013. In other words, Crimea is Russian territory, where the vast majority of the population is Russian. Crimea itself was originally part of Russia. Crimea was originally part of the Russian Soviet Republic. But in 1954, the Soviet government, by its short-sighted decision, handed over Russian territory, where the overwhelming majority of the population is Russian, transfered this territory from Russian Soviet Republic to Ukrainian Soviet Republic. In 1991 the USSR collapsed. Russia liberated itself and other countries from the USSR. For 23 years, since 1991, Russia was absolutely satisfied with the fact that Crimea was part of Ukraine, while Ukraine was a friendly country. But in 2014, a coup took place in Ukraine. Under such conditions, Russia was forced to conduct a rescue evacuation operation and evacuate Russian territory with 60% of the Russian population to Russia. The local population is happy to reunite with Russia. I know this because I myself communicated with the Crimeans live and in social networks. 60% of the population of Crimea before the annexation were Russians, and these Russians were happy to return to their native harbor, to return to Russia. The Ukrainian army gave Crimea away without a fight, which again proves that it is not Ukrainian. After the return of Crimea to Russia, an uprising began in the Donbass. In the south-east of Ukraine, Russians make up 50% of the population. And these Russian people raised an armed uprising, they wanted to secede from Ukraine. The war has begun on april 2014, when Ukrainian MOD announced so-called "anti-terrorist operation". Ukrainian punishers have deprived the Crimea of water supply. Ukrainian punishers carried out rocket and artillery strikes on civilians and civilian infrastructure in the Donbass. People in Donbas still do not have water, electricity and communications. Russia began to launch similar missile strikes against Ukraine only in October 2022, after 8 months of war. Ukrainian punishers did this already in 2014. Crimea was cut off from water supply already in 2014. In 2015, Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko said that "we will have pensions, they (the separatists) will not, we will have a job, they don't, our children will go to school on September 1, their children will sit in basements, and that's how we (Ukraine) win." This is a direct quote. The Ukrainian president said in 2015 that Russian children in Donbas would be kept in basements, and this is how Ukraine would win. And the Ukrainian humorous studio "Kvartal 95", where Zelensky worked, satirized Poroshenko's words, joking that "Russian children in the Donbas no longer need to go to school, Ukrainian artillery fulfills children's dreams." In Donetsk, there is such an attraction - the "alley of angels". This is a list of children who have died under Ukrainian shelling since 2014. Ukraine almost achieved victory over the rebels in 2014, but Russian intervention halted the Ukrainian offensive and reversed the front in August 2014. Ukraine understood that Russia would protect the Russian rebels in the Donbass. Therefore, Ukraine set a course for joining NATO in order to attack the DPR and LPR with impunity. Let's imagine a picture before the 21.02.2022 - almost the whole world recognizes Crimea as Ukrainian, and in general the whole world, including Russia, recognizes Donbass as the territory of Ukraine. Then Ukraine joins NATO, and attacks Donbass, and possibly Crimea. And Russia cannot do anything about it, because if Russia starts helping the rebels, it will be regarded as an invasion of Ukraine and the NATO article about collective defense will work. And there would be a nuclear war between Russia and NATO. So the most realistic scenario was: Ukraine joins NATO and attacks the rebels with absolutely impunity. There are nationalist battalions in the Ukrainian army, such as Azov. These guys wear Nazi symbols, they have tattoos of Hitler, and they hate Russians as a nation. Now let's think about what would happen if Ukrainian troops attacked the DPR and LPR - Ukrainian soldiers massacre the entire pro-Russian local population. Well, in general, there are many videos that are filmed by Ukrainian soldiers themselves, where they say to the camera how they hate the "separatists" and pro-Russian population. If the Ukrainian army entered the territory of the rebels, there would be a genocide. If we had not attacked Ukraine, Ukraine would have simply joined NATO and attacked the Donbass. And we, Russians, have no right to leave our blood brothers in trouble. In 2014, the Russian people in southeastern Ukraine started an armed uprising because they wanted to break away from Ukraine and become part of Russia. Just like Crimea did. And since 2014 there has been a war. Russia defends the right of the Russian people in southeastern Ukraine to self-determination. Ukraine wanted to join NATO in order to attack Russian rebels with impunity. Russia had no choice but to attack first.
2
Lol and how can this work in Youtube? Russian government doesn't control Youtube and all Russians can speak here freely
2
You are carrying some kind of nonsense. "Kaliningrad is a Russian bridgehead to attack Western Europe." First, Russia, like all other Soviet republics, withdrew from the USSR within the borders of the Russian Soviet Republic, which included Kaliningrad. At that time, to the east of Kalilingrad was the territory of the USSR, and to the west - the allied Poland of the USSR and East Germany. Where is Western Europe? There to Western Europe further than to Moscow
1
@tdrs1765 "East Prussia never was a Russian". So - Crimea never was Ukrainian. It was a part of Russian Soviet republic until stupid decision of Soviet government, who never thought USSR would collapse, with majority of population being Russians until 2014
1
And what kind of developed industry do the Poles have? Clean English toilets? Russia is the world leader in grain exports, the world's main energy power, Russia has its own industry in many areas, from cars to aviation, which has a weakness in that it depends on imported technology and components, and the quality is mediocre. But at least Russia has such an industry. Poland is not doing much better, except that Poland is begging for handouts from the West, and the Polish economy is heavily indebted. And when the European Union cut handouts for Poland in 2022, Poland immediately climbed to ask Germany for compensation of one and a half trillion dollars for the Second World War.
1
@tdrs1765 Lenin was a Jew and Stalin was a Georgian. The Soviet communists were internationalists who did not recognize the existence of nations. And what about the Russians? Russia was also captured by the communists, like all other countries. There was a civil war in Russia, and the real patriots of Russia fought against the communists
1
@benenivel1478 The fact that Polish engineers work for Boeing, Airbus and other large companies means nothing. You know, there are plenty of Russian engineers who leave Russia to live abroad and work in global companies. There is a difference between having your own industry and having your engineers leave your country and work for foreign firms. And the education system, which graduates such a number of highly qualified specialists, was built under socialism, when there was large-scale industry in all socialist countries, because. under socialism there are no foreign goods on the domestic market, all goods are of own production. And now Poland has no industry of its own. With regards to cosmonautics, which is developing in Poland, good luck to them with this, only in Russia the space industry has existed for 70 years, and the Poles still do not have it, Russia is one of the leaders in this area, second only to the world superpowers.
1
@benenivel1478 The system of engineering education was created under socialism, and was sharpened to serve the industry, which was in abundance in those days. So the Polish engineers who work for Boeing and Airbus are in many ways a legacy.
1
@benenivel1478 okay, fine, you won
1
@benenivel1478 I'm seriously, you won, Polska strong
1
@benenivel1478 physically I am in Moscow
1
@frez8141 автохлама? У меня рено меган 2008 года, с турбинным двигателем. Разгоняется до 200 км/ч, обалденная машина
1
@LaughingMan44 do you have any evidences of "murder" or "sexual assaults" by Soviet army? Do you have any documental evidence, any document, that shows the scale of crimes? Are you aware that Stalin introduced the death penalty for crimes against German civilians in 1945? And "mass rape" is generally propaganda of Goebbels. You believe and distribute Nazi anti-Soviet propaganda
1
They are non state militia, they can fight as partizans
1
@steamedham5412 there was talk firstly about quality of tanks, not crews. T-90MS is better than Bradley because Bradley is APC, or IFW, I don't remember clearly, while T-90MS is MBT. The quality of training is other story, and one single case doesn't represent general situation because of luck and probability factors, there were dozens of destroyed Bradley vehicles. In modern wars direct battles between tanks are rarity, in 99% of cases tanks or vehicles ars being destroyed by artillery, aviation or drones
1
@steamedham5412 wow, there was two cases instead of one case, this changes everything. 99% of all vehicle casualities are due to artillery and drones, and there is no difference in what vehicle is it. In 1% probablity that two tanks would have duel between each other everything is determined by who will shot and heat first, because modern tanks one shot each other
1
@steamedham5412 I saw only videos where ALREADY damaged tanks with NO CREWS inside being destroyed by grenades via FPV drone and open hatch. Russian tankers don't open hatches during the battle
1
There are no salary of 200 dollars anywhere in Russia, at now people even in poor regions receive ~300-400 dollars, and considering that prices in Russia are lower than in the West, this is bad, but isn't that bad. Average salary is ~400-500 dollars, considering the difference in prices you can live normally on that money, this is more than enough for all your needs. In Russia people consume the nearly same amount of calories as in the West, Russia even in the leading position of fatness problem in Europe. Prices are such that in Russia people don't spend on food more than 200 dollars per person in month
1
@Phaleel and this is a problem, yes, so both parents are working
1