Comments by "Adam Bainbridge" (@AdamMGTF) on "Paper Skies" channel.

  1. 58
  2. 6
  3. 4
  4. 3
  5. 3
  6. @renanpardillos9919  I admit my knowledge of french history is limited to pre 1945. I only have a general overview of the years since. So I'll focus my reply on what I do know. Firstly I apologise if you thought I was implying that you were from the UK. I wasn't. The UK based comments were to the op who is originally from poland and living in the UK. So onto the meat of what you've written. I'd like to point out your wrong about the UK gaining better working conditions thanks to communist or socialist governments. We have never had such a government in the UK. We have the Labour party (which is currently in power and had a major revision prior to Tony Bair becoming the party head in what is known as 'new labour '). But that is NOT a socialist or communist party. It is on the left of the conservative party (in power from 2010 until this year) BUT and this is important to this conversation. The labour party maybe considered on the left in the UK. But in most countries it would be considered a center party. In the UK we haven't had any real support for socialism represented in parliament since the 50s and even then it was single digits territory. Standards of living in the UK have contributed to rise constantly since the 60s (we of course had to pay off huge debts and rebuild after ww2, I'm sure muchlike France). So i hope you understand when I say what you have said about how we gained workers rights here is simply incorrect. In fact we gained works rights largely through direct democracy. IE trade unions and their influence on industry and politics.Though it could be considered a double edge sword as they became very powerful in the 70s and 80s and the strikes ended badly for the workers involved (the old joke was that the trade unions won and the working man lost. Mind you they were mostly industries that were not making a profit and or were heavily subsidised or nationalised and as such had no future in capitalism anyway. Obviously I can't comment on how things went in your country. But given the amount of strikes you have had none stop for decades.... Isn't that an argument to suggest your system hasn't been good for the working man? In the UK we haven't seen major strikes since the 1970s. In France they seem to have been constant since I can remember (so the last 35+ years). I would never say that socialism/communism is just about a big military and depressing concrete housing. But it I would say it's about controlling things that are better left to improve through natural competition.
    2
  7. 2
  8. 2
  9. 1
  10. 1
  11. 1