Comments by "Sean" (@sean2015) on "Police pull over state attorney" video.
-
9
-
5
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
@RS-ti7bz I watched the video again and her windows do appear to be tinted (when you live in a sunny locale such as Florida or Arizona, it is a temptation to install tinted windows but you have to be aware that you may draw the attention of law enforcement and she should know that) not to mention that it appears to be late evening on an overcast day, thus, it would have been difficult if not impossible for any police officer to peer into a moving car and instantly determine the gender and race of the driver. The idea that she may have been profiled is baloney, though I'm sure CNN would love its viewers to think otherwise.
As far as the officer bringing up the issue of the tinted windows, this is another perfectly common thing for law enforcement to do, for example you may be pulled over for a license plate light being out, but the officer can (and almost all of of them do) look for other secondary infractions or illegal activity during the course of the stop, such as: open containers of alcohol, not wearing a seat belt (which is now a requirement in every state except New Hampshire), possession of unlicensed firearms, etc.,. When police approach your car, they will ALWAYS look around inside your car for any visible evidence that can be used against you (this is called the "plain view exception" to the Fourth Amendment).
1
-
1
-
@RS-ti7bz First of all, you should know that the person driving the vehicle is not always the registered owner. In addition to that, a vehicle could also be a rental car, or it could be registered to a business or to the government (duhhh). Since this Ayala woman is a state attorney, it's entirely POSSIBLE that she could've been driving a state-owned vehicle to or from court appointments (CNN does not specify whether this is the case). If so, this would explain why the officer initially had trouble matching the vehicle to its registered owner, and would debunk your entire theory that this was based on racial profiling.
Second, you've already more or less admitted that you were wrong when you said that vehicle registrations contain the owner's picture. Now you're doing a 180 and suggesting that cops can instantly recognize the race or ethnicity of a person simply by their last name ? Really? Does that mean ALL people with the surname "Ayala" are African-American? According to Wikipedia the surname is of Basque origin; it is a Hispanic name (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayala_(surname)). And when a car is flying by at 80 mph, do you honestly think a police officer has all that extra time to sit there perusing through computer records while they decide whether to peel out and pull the car over? The car would be LONG GONE by then.
Going by your logic, does this also mean that all people named "Murphy" are Irish? (well what about Eddie Murphy then? isn't he African-American?) Are all people with the last name "Malone" Irish? How about Karl Malone? (14-time All-Star and power forward for the Utah Jazz) or even the late Moses Malone, a Hall of Famer and former 76er (both of these men are...wait for it...African-American).
Don't rattle off baseless or questionable facts and then finish it off by telling me to go "look it up". Include a verifiable and credible link to support your assertions and then I'll go check it out.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1