Youtube comments of Meiner Meinung nach (@meinermeinungnach4797).

  1. One of the heroic paradoxes of this channel is that the reason why you surpass by far any other military history expert while still fiercely re-establishing the centrality of evenemential and war history is that you take the time to study the actual political and social reality to a level to no other channel is even remotely capable of reaching. Seriously and literally no one 1) makes this kind of videos 2) knows the actual history behind it 3) explains it the way you do. Your output is fanatically insane and by now every person even remotely interested in history should be following you
    21
  2. Damn, the part on flavus was really painful. How did Metatron even come up with that?
    21
  3. Finally someone who teaches history from a traditional perspective, it's tiring to see people still believing in nationalism and socialism
    12
  4. Thanks for this
    10
  5. Thank you so much for this
    9
  6. Most countries in the world can't boast the history of a single city like Siena
    9
  7. This is great stuff. Basically you're the only channel making historically accurate (or at all historical) papal history content
    9
  8. You're a cultured person
    8
  9. Your content is amazing not just because of all the knowledge you pour out but you accompany it with the very specific art, maps and landscapes pertaining to the topic. It makes you learn Europe in an unique way and you seem to be the only person around to provide with such knowledge combined
    8
  10. This channel has a flavor of ancient, precious, traditional and mystical, corroborated by a mighty culture, education and explanatory coherence. It may be that not everyone understands Schwerpunkt's profound interpretative message, but this is certain: this channel has within itself the heart, conscience and power of Europe and whispers to the soul all that the hardness, strength and sacredness of the past it still lives today to reinforce its strings and make the celestial harmony vibrate in the deepest of man.
    8
  11. What impresses me the most is how you nonchalantly and in detail pass from modern to classical warfare, from the medieval to the contemporary one without effort: and you are "only" a Medievalist. How did you get used to this?
    8
  12. Simply the most trusted military history channel on YouTube. Schwerpunkt's disdain for "commercial" formats distills a content of absolute prestige that will soon overtake even the most well-known brands. True leadership at work
    8
  13. I don't understand how people still watch channels with animated flags and boxes when they have molten gold historical expertise sparkling from all pores here
    8
  14. I I love how you surpass the simplistic dichotomy republic-people/tyranny-seigneury by pointing out the statally-civic political cohesion of the communal establishment cooperating with a chosen temporary ruler as the top of Italian power and military effectiveness. Meanwhile we still have videos on youtube like "what was the life of a Medieval peasant REALLY like?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!"
    8
  15. Thank you Schwerpunkt! Jewish people will be free from the river to the sea 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🪖🦅
    8
  16. Beautiful channel
    7
  17. The only channel that actually provides with military historical culture and education. Unbelievable how people get satisfied with cheap information from the most popular channels that do not actually explain anything of this all
    7
  18. Your Holy Roman Empire playlist is huge: how do you even know all this?
    7
  19. This channel owns the Soul of Europe
    7
  20. One point that struck me was how the shift from the consular regime to the podestà system reflected a broader transition in governance and social structure in Florence. This change, as you pointed out, marked a significant move towards arbitration and stability amid the factional violence that characterized Florentine politics. I found it particularly fascinating how the introduction of foreign knights as arbiters sought to quell the tension among the city's varied factions. However, I couldn't help but wonder: What were the implications of these reforms on the power dynamics between the Guelfs and Ghibellines? As I watched, it became evident that these changes did not merely affect the internal workings of Florence but also intensified the ongoing struggle for dominance between the two factions. The answer lies in the very heart of your discussion! The emergence of the podestà was crucial in balancing the power struggle, as it provided a semblance of order while simultaneously allowing the Guelfs to consolidate their influence. The subsequent rise in citizen participation and the emergence of the populace's will created further layers of complexity, ensuring that the Ghibelline faction would find it increasingly difficult to maintain control
    7
  21. This channel should be used in schools
    7
  22. The most reliable military history channel on Youtube. Prestigious work
    7
  23. Whoever complains about the statement that "paganism" and "polytheism" did not exist should study carefully the hundreds of videos that Schwerpunkt expressly made on the subject and/or take a degree in history of religions. This content is not baby-food for the mentally feeble: you must work hard for a large amount of your life to even hope to get there
    7
  24. This channel is the heaven of every military historian worth of this name
    7
  25. I don't understand how people still follow other channels about medieval warfare. Your work is as competent as monumental
    6
  26. I hope WWIII doesn't break out because I want to keep listening to your lessons
    6
  27. High military historical expertise
    6
  28. How do you even have such far ranging military historical expertise?
    6
  29. This should be listened to in any school: any nationalism and socialism would immediately disappear if kids and their parents were schooled in the universal imperial tradition. The level of cultural underdevelopment in the world today is utterly appalling
    5
  30. Finally a proper Catholic history
    5
  31. This is the only history channel that actually matters
    5
  32. Excellence made history channel
    5
  33. I don't understand how people still follow other Medieval history channels other than this. This is like an encyclopedia
    5
  34. Popular medieval knowledge has become so limited that there are self-styled Westerners who have never even heard of the Patriarchate of Aquileia, let alone the Italian Communes. We can't thank you enough for covering European history in this level of detail now sadly unknown to the cultural, moral and personal horizons of the mob
    4
  35. From pagus to Empire
    4
  36. Glory to Schwerpunkt!
    4
  37. Your contribution to HRE history of warfare is outstanding. There's a space and a time that has completely been ignored by mainstream Anglo-Saxon culture and that was the very tree of European culture. France, Italy and Germany deserve a disproportionately larger recognition in the central centuries of the Middle Ages and beyond, I can't stand videos like Invicta saying just cliches and getting nowhere and making less educated believe that this is history or anything
    4
  38. Thank God, we wouldn't know how to do without this information
    4
  39. An incredible display of culture
    4
  40. I love your German warfare playlist. It's so detailed
    4
  41. Just checked on YouTube: this is one of the largest and most important battles of the 15th century, bigger than the Hundred Years War ones of the same period and you are the ONLY having made a video about it online. This speaks volumes about the sub-cultural darkness in which people world-wide live. They should surrender to the idea that anything they think they know is inadequate. You're an unmatched beacon of strategic culture, erudition and competence in the current world educational landscape.
    4
  42. This is easily the best Holy Roman Empire channel around. If you care about several, accurate political, military, social historical analyses for most Medieval polities this is the channel for you. I remember when I first came across it being skeptical as for most home made channels but this is a goldmine.
    4
  43. I love the explanation about how the German town system was superior to Viking society and how at the same time the fruit of a power vacuum and actual weakness of all those involved the region including the League. Tired of seeing people pathetically trying hijack historical topics to narcissistically pretend their places are "superior" for the exclusive reason that they are theirs. It's become a quite widespread mental illness among virtually anyone self-styled "passionated about history" (a history that they don't even know, starting from the very the places they come from). And your appreciation for the Hanseatic towns in spite of it and exactly for what they were shows how impartially objective and historically competent you are. This channel is a true pearl of European comparative history: either one works to learn what it's taught or they won't get anything of it.
    4
  44. It's amazing how certain prejudices can last both scholarly and popularly without any evidence. A testament to how distorted for specific ideological purposes the guilty average person's opinion is
    4
  45. Great one!
    4
  46. You're by far one of the most intelligent thinkers that I've ever listened to. Clamorous historical expertise and criticism here
    4
  47. Not quite: that was rather the reception of English common law in a colonial process. Here you have basically the German lawyers adopting the Roman legal categories from the Italian juridical tradition as half of Europe had been doing by this point
    4
  48. The audience of this channel is pathetic: watching only the Migration Era videos and snubbing the history of the Roman Church reveals all their radical cultural illiteracy
    3
  49. Simply the most reliable history channel on Youtube. Top quality content
    3
  50. I love Central European history. Thanks for making so much about it
    3
  51. Binging your Medieval England playlist content
    3
  52. I love your Medieval society playlist. It gives you that feeling of here and now that a Medieval peasant may have been in. Plus you cover all the millennium in detail, which is outstanding
    3
  53. This channel is an encyclopedia of Medieval Germany
    3
  54. Great one
    3
  55. ​ @andrewmaloney837  Correct, and we should be more open and honest about that. The US are so obsessed with racial categorization that they cannot picture the idea of peoples not fitting stereotypes: to them "mixed" means either non white or uniformly dark. The immigrants of course being always even more eager to fit this twisted logic in order to be accepted as the underdogs in society. They don't have the cultural-cognitive tools to conceive that it's recknowingly normal to find fair people among native Italians all across the peninsula throughout history and that any type of source speaks clearly about it. They must fuel the opposition of a rigid separation from Northern and Southern Europe dating to the 19th century, which is Nordicism but of course they don't understand it. Romanity today is just a trope that the common person, in spite of their uneducation, can discuss as they please without punishment, fitting their own fantasies of how ethnicity, demographics and migrations are supposed to work. It's at least funny to see how quickly they lose their temper as they have no idea how a historical claim is supposed to be backed like.
    3
  56. Thank you for this. This is really a cultured channel
    3
  57. I've never seen such an EXTENSIVE amount of Medieval French history so accurately described on a single Youtube channel. Check this guy's Medieval France playlist out and thank me later
    3
  58. Loved your great-grandfather's story
    2
  59. Thanks Schwerpunkt. These videos on the Italian Communes are amazing
    2
  60. These videos should be listened to in any school. European history is really beyond
    2
  61. For all the users fond of Carolingian history, I warmly advise you to check out Schwerpunkt's Frankish history playlist. Sometimes people don't even know what this guy has been doing so far: the world is going to change because of it and it's important to stay here since the beginning
    2
  62. The incredible value of this channel, among other things, lays in the completeness of every single time and place history treated in detail. Just check out Schwerpunkt's Frankish history playlist (for this video, for example) or just the various ones about every Medieval century. It makes you literally speechless
    2
  63. Excellent content! I love how gradually all of Medieval Europe is taking shape on your channel
    2
  64. This is the only history channel that actually matters
    2
  65. Allmächt'ge Jungfrau, hör mein Flehen! Zu dir, Gepriesne, rufe ich! Lass mich in Staub vor dir vergehen, o,'nimm von dieser Erde mich! Mach, dass ich rein und engelgleich eingehe in dein selig Reich! Wenn je, in tör'gem Wahn befangen, mein Herz sich abgewandt von dir, wenn je ein sündiges Verlangen, ein weltlich Sehnen keimt' in mir, so rang ich unter tausend Schmerzen, dass ich es töt' in meinem Herzen! Doch, konnt'ich jeden Fehl nicht büssen, so nimm dich gnädig meiner an, dass ich mit demutsvollem Grüssen als würd'ge Magd dir nahen kann: um deiner Gnaden reichste Huld nur anzuflehn für seine Schuld!
    2
  66. This channel is literally saturating in quality and quantity the military historical output on YouTube
    2
  67. This is the only history channel that actually matters
    2
  68. This is the only history channel that actually matters
    2
  69. Then check out his military archery playlist! There's plenty of stuff
    2
  70. Very interesting, thank you as usual
    1
  71. This is the only history channel that actually matters
    1