Comments by "Sedna063" (@Sedna063) on "Harris Sultan" channel.

  1. Purely by birth rate.
    3
  2. That’s what you believe…
    2
  3. You are very brave for saying this out loud with your face. I do not share your optimism on Pakistan, I believe it will grow worse before better, but I do hope that they can become more moderate.
    2
  4. Islam solely growths through birth rates. Not because people subscribe to the faith. And in any case, birth rates are falling too.
    2
  5.  @Ali-fr1vk  try making a census on this in any country in that region… very, very hard because there is intense governmental and societal pressure to remain a muslim, if only on paper. And that is morally wrong.
    2
  6.  @Abd-Al712  by birth rate only lol.
    2
  7. Don’t tell lies. Many Sunnis don’t revere their clerics either. Many of them are despised too. Just check the Arab barometer.
    2
  8.  KIDS WORLD  Nah. By 2050 India may have 25% Muslims but that would be it
    2
  9. Now you are really overestimating birth rates. The highest birth rates are in Niger at some 7. Hardly any Muslim family gets 13 children. In many muslim nations, people get 2-3 kids.
    1
  10. The fact that they are happy doesn’t mean this is because of their faith… Try and find how many sunni syrians are happy. Happiness isn’t the result of one faith
    1
  11. As current trends go, it is likely it will have a reduced role.
    1
  12. Masses morning… I knew how European communists used masses to demonstrate support. Half a year later, communism collapsed
    1
  13. Yes. But almost solely due to higher birth rates. So people who were born into the faith and brainwashed from day 1
    1
  14. Iranians are Iranians. You can’t make up a claim that they are all muslism. They aren’t
    1
  15. I would just pick the good, spirital sides but done the religious worldy laws
    1
  16. The comments say different and society in those countries say different
    1
  17. Because their faith is making rules for atheists and other non-beliefers and they don’t want to accept that
    1
  18. Good. Religions are important but they can be dangerous and highly destabilising. They should not hold prominent seats in politics
    1
  19. That is deism. I am a deist in the Christian tradition. I believe there might be a God who has started things but otherwise does not interfere and does not concern himself with trivialities of sexuality or punishments.
    1
  20. And you are God to judge this? Anyone who believes in God and Mohammed as prophet should be considered muslim…
    1
  21. @اقرأ | Read And who are you to say what is right or wrong? Awfully judgemental of you ain’t it?
    1
  22. @اقرأ | Read And you claim I don't know things. ...
    1
  23. Nobody says they won’t stay. But Islam may not hold the relevance it has today. Religious beliefs change. Check how that region believed 2000 years ago
    1
  24.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  I know basic demographics. Islam and most religions solely grow due to birth rates. Most Latin-American nations stay overwhelmingly catholic with strong growth of evangelical churches. Islam runs under „other religions“ in those countries. Demographic projections for 2050 leave little to no increase in Muslims as a percentage in those nations. Most muslim growth is in South East Asia and Africa. Due to birth rates. Since the islamic world is less developed, people have more kids which is the main contributor.
    1
  25.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  I have seen the forecasts. I know the Pew research findings. Save the effort.
    1
  26.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  I have read parts of it. Wasn’t to my liking. I don’t think the prophet is someone to emulate. Sorry, but this is just my opinion. And I find faiths highly intolerant of other faiths. That is true with Hindus, Christians, Jews, but most pronounced in Islam. Sorry. Not meant to insult you or your faith but I just want to make sure you know how many people in the world think about it. Our perception is shaped by actions and for me, those actions are not good enough or right.
    1
  27.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  I can read a book partly and if I don’t like it, I don‘t continue it. Simple as that. I don’t know anyone who said that Mohammed was the most successful person in history. I don’t know Bernard Shaw or Michael Hart. I have no opinion on them. But I can see why they might have said that. I am Christian although I consider myself a deist.
    1
  28.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  Now Ou are getting a bit heated. I have read the bible fully, although this has been years ago. I have studied history extensively. I didn’t read the Quran fully for the simple reason that I neither found it inspiring, I neither found it God-inspired and I found it repetitive. That’s my take on that. I have googled them. Hardly fellows I would read or fellows whose judgement I would trust or want to emulate. On guy was a communist and held love for faschists, defended Stalin and his purges. The other guy is someone who proposed some sort of white supremacy. I have made up my mind a long time ago. I do not care for Alis religious views or for yours for that matter. All I want is to be left alone with my interpretation of the world and that religious people don’t make laws in the name of their religion which I do not believe in. Frankly, this is very tiring. You do not seem to understand what I am talking about. I originally came and said that religious views change. I gave you an example to look at the religious beliefs of Iran / Persia 2000 years ago. Yet your response was entirely not committed to this but told me to read the Quran… Is this the extend of debating and argumentation? Read the Quran? Because that is literally the only thing I ever get from people like you.
    1
  29.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  I don’t know what goes on in Michael Harts head. I just know that according to the internet, he did. I don’t have any questions. I already found my answer myself. For me, there is a God but a being so immensely above us isn’t a God as written in the „holy books“. A God who created the universe is concerned who I am sleeping with? Or whether I believe in him or not? I worked in a psychiatric hospital once. Do you know how many people I saw there which claimed to have visions and prophetic dreams? Many. And this is what I believe happened with many religions. Fidgets of imaginations. Folklore elevated. Still no word from you on how religions evolve? There are also some people who studied those holy books and became staunch atheists…
    1
  30.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  Religion did evolve and do evolve… That’s a historic fact. As for Yvonne Riddle, sounds like Stockholm Syndrome to me. On further research; I really don’t think she is doing a good job to present muslims wordwide. Quite a lot if controversies and some borderline views. Honour killings apparently aren’t a problem for her, she supports a mandatory Hijab for women even if it is against their will. A terrorist who was responsible for a school massacre was a martyr for her; the family of his denounced his actions which she saw as more problematic than an attack on children. She sounds like she has a lot of problems and clings to something for a guideline in the world. Sorry but a woman like this who supports terrorists isn’t someone one should advertise.
    1
  31.  @muhammadabdulmateen8473  It is a very common excuse to claim to be „misrepresented“. The sheer amount of controversies is an indication that not everything can be misrepresented. As for why some people convert from Christian to Muslim, I don’t know. I didn’t discover anything that would have made me consider. And some people like rules. It’s their choice. I don’t mind that. I only want to be left alone with my version of faith. With nobody trying to make rules for me. Or telling me that I am wrong
    1
  32. Why don’t you ask some Iranians? They are right here!
    1
  33. Your level of knowledge is so disturbingly low… Many people leave Islam behind. Converts into religions make a very small amount of the total followers and the majority, the overwhelming majority of Christians remain Christians. He isn’t a Zionist btw (do you know what those are?) You just sound like a butthurt guy who can’t handle that people don’t follow your belief system. It doesn’t concern Ou what they believe in. It isn’t your business.
    1
  34. Christian countries don’t persecute atheists like many muslim countries.
    1
  35.  @Ahmed-ii7up  Yes, they are. Anyway, the atheist world faces much more daunting situations in muslim countries which often persecute them. Saudi Arabia legally defines atheists as terrorists. Is that fair? So you ask why there seems to be so relentless criticism on Islamic countries - well, those countries do threaten atheists and can you blame them for islamophobia when you are persecuted?
    1
  36.  @Ahmed-ii7up  Thank you. With acceptance of others the life of all of us would be better.
    1
  37. Are atheists forcing you to something that you don't want?
    1
  38. Many of them are agnostic, some follow other religions.
    1
  39. Purely due to birth rates. Most faiths have absolute number increases because so many people are born.
    1
  40. Most Europeans know this though. There is an active and prominent Iranian diaspora in the west
    1
  41. Sounds burrhurt
    1
  42. @اقرأ | Read Just sad when people like you can’t even argue with facts but need to involve some obscure superiority…
    1
  43. @اقرأ | Read First and foremost I am very much correct. Many scientific studies have pointed out that conversions from religions are very minor in the overall makeup of a religious group. There are some individuals but it is not a mass event. The growth is almost solely due to birth rates. Middle East and West Africa are 2 out of the three regions with the highest birth rate. Both are predominantly muslim and growing fast. West Africa will add almost 700 million people by 2070. The Middle East will add another 200 million. . Now go and check some demographics. This is the origin of growth. Nothing else
    1
  44. @اقرأ | Read Judgement day didn't come for over a millennium now and I don't expect it to come in my lifetime. People always predicted end-time scenarios and we are living as much in an endtime as people did 200 years ago. And you should check out the definition of "proof" in a dictionary because this isn't truth. This is your opinion, one I do not share. I think you would be served better if you were to widen your own horizon. Because it is frankly insulting to say that all 3/4 of the world who have a different faith are wrong.
    1
  45.  @Abd-Al712  why do they need to be punished?
    1
  46. Butthurt!
    1
  47.  @emolasker  Which is weird. The entire obsession with Mohammed. it is a cult.
    1
  48. First you sound really butthurt and b, who are you to judge?
    1
  49.  @n_165  Sunni Muslims in Iran are a small minority and I doubt they will become a minority anytime soon.
    1
  50.  @n_165  Yet both of them tend to overstate their numbers.
    1