Comments by "bas kir" (@vinsin328) on "Why is Pakistan failing and how can it be fixed? | DW Analysis" video.

  1.  @Ron-pm3qk  but for different reasons.
    35
  2. It is an international channel not limited to Germany.
    3
  3. Pakistan especially West Pakistan which got the best resources of the Indian subcontinent has the best agricultural land, 50% of coal, the best cities (Lahore and Karachi), 40% of railways, 25%+ land for 16% of the population (West Pakistan - 20%+ land for 6% of the population), $100 Billion Aid from the USA alone, refused to pay the debt they own to India ($30 Billion at least by now) etc.
    2
  4. The public would be given some lolly pop and they would be happy for the next 5 yrs.
    2
  5. Average Pakistani are happy that they are not at least ruled by Kafirs/Hindus. They don't feel bad why do you feel bad? Please explain.
    2
  6. You can always convert and move to Pakistan, why rejoin?
    2
  7. Three main reasons - 1) Pakistan is a Nuclear power state with a radicalized population, 2) India is a swing state politically (yet not fully secular and liberal) 3) Pakistan is the most strategically located country in the world initially to stop Russian expansion and now for Chinese expansion.
    2
  8. It has to do with Kashmir. Jinnah initially didn't want J&K and signed a standstill agreement but later he changed his mind and sent the tribals and military to attack and get the J&K by force and also to rape/loot/kill Hindus. Later in UN asked Pakistan to vacate the captured land so that a plebiscite could happen. Pakistani Military refused.
    2
  9. The failing state has not failed yet. It may take 5-10 yrs.
    1
  10. Pakistan was a movement against democracy. Pakistan was not created to have a democracy.
    1
  11. Then it cannot be revived ever. 5 yrs is too much.
    1
  12. That is against two nation theory.
    1
  13. how?
    1
  14. how?
    1
  15. That idea they have given up a long time back. Democratic ideas are based on secularism and liberalism (human rights). Pakistan movement was an anti-democratic movement.
    1
  16. How many of them have nuclear weapons? And what do you care, it is there choice?
    1
  17. That is against Two nation theory.
    1
  18. Depends upon whom you ask.
    1
  19. The hunger index is a different thing. In India majority of people are vegetarian which results in stunting and poor growth of brain and physical growth. 80 crores of people in India are dependent on the Indian government for food. Indian government only provide them carbohydrate, no protein, no good fats and forget about minerals/vitamins.
    1
  20. You are right, but the people are happy as long as they are not ruled by Hindus/Kafirs.
    1
  21. Then who won the 1947-48 war with India.
    1
  22. India is not even a regional power forget superpower (which India is not even aspiring for). Pakistan doesn't need to leave anyone. Importing goods from India instead of China will not help Pakistan's economy much. India also doesn't trust Pakistan much for transit-trade.
    1
  23. And who should do it? Why did India give POK to Pakistan if the idea was to get it back?
    1
  24. It would not be that easy. That transition requires at least 2 generations.
    1
  25. To have that you need close to at least a $4 trillion economy. Even $10 Billion are difficult.
    1
  26. how? Why Indians have so much problems with maps?
    1
  27. Who were the various Afghan wars and the 1947-48 Kashmir war.
    1
  28. India is ruled by BJP not a Hindu Nationalist Government. There is no Hindu in BJP philosophy.
    1
  29. People in power or pure politicians don't care about people, only power. People with power will only act when the heat will start impacting them. Pakistani people don't care much either, their main concern is they should not be ruled by Kafirs/Hindus.
    1
  30. That is based on the International Map. Germany (DW) didn't force India to sign the Panchsheel agreement. When the whole world begged India not to do so then why you have done that? Please explain first before pointing fingers at DW.
    1
  31. That is never going to happen. IMF's job is not to do those things. IMF is a bank which gives loans with the lowest interest rate. IMF just bothered to get its money back with some interest.
    1
  32. Excessive Brahmavad is also India's problem. Why does food terrorism exist in India?
    1
  33. What is your problem? They don't have a problem with that.
    1
  34. ??? so the foreign investment is not coming to Pakistan because imports from India are not allowed. What is so special about India's exports to the world?
    1
  35. And who will do it?
    1
  36. If you wanted J&K then why declare that as an international disputed territory. Which developmental activities they are not spending?
    1
  37. The same thing can be said about Brahmavad also. India has food terrorism. Indian children are not given non-veg foods in Indian Schools and now even colleges. Forget beef. You put animals above human beings.
    1
  38.  @anuragchakraborty8766  How Hindutva is Gobar?
    1
  39. You are right it should be shown as part of China. DW didn't force Indians to sign the Pancheel Agreement. India has never objected to it. Indians used to call the gifting of Tibet a symbol of Hindu-Chini Bhai Bhai. You are not the Indian government.
    1
  40. how?
    1