Comments by "" (@neutronalchemist3241) on "Classics Summarized: Dante's Inferno" video.

It has been noticed how the Dante main character of the Comedy, is very different from the historical Dante poet. He is weak, timorous (Dante was a war veteran) and not very bright (not understanding the meaning of much of the things that the Dante poet wrote). More than a self-insert, Dante gave his name to a proper character that was fit for the poem.
257
Canto IV >"il maestro di color che sanno" ("the master of the ones that know") Aristotle, Greek. >"Omero, poeta sovrano" ("Omer, sovereign of the poets"), Greek. Dante used the characters of the Omeric poems in the Inferno not because he despised Greeks, but because, other than the contemporary characters, for contrast, he needed characters that were not contemporary but still well known by the people, and that, in Dante's time, meant saints and characters of Greek mitology. But he couldn't put saints in hell, so he had to overuse Greeks. BTW, the oldest surviving complete translation of both the Iliad and the Odissey in latin is that of the Calabrian scholar Leontius Pilatus, whose works were known both by Petrarch and Boccaccio.Dante missed him by half a century more or less.
22
@discountplaguedoctor88 Actually, for being a 13th century Christian, Dante was VERY open-minded. IE he put both Averroes and Saladin (a muslim scholar and a muslim general, Dante does nothing by chance, he wanted to depict them) among the not-baptized virtuous. Averroes with the likes of Socrat and Aristotle, Saladin, the man that took away Gerusalem from the Christianity, with the likes of Caesar. That he didn't like Greeks is just bullshit, he described Homer as the "sovereign poet" and Aristotle as "the master of the ones that know". He used Greek mithological figures in the Inferno because he needed characters that were well known by his public.
14
@dreamerthief2216 It's significative that Dante previously put both Averroes and Saladin (a muslim scholar and a muslim general, Dante does nothing by chance, he wanted to depict them there) among the not-baptized virtuous. Averroes with the likes of Socrat and Aristotle, Saladin, the man that took away Gerusalem from the Christianity, with the likes of Caesar. Because for Saladin, to fight Christians was his work, and he did it in an honorable way. Mohammed instead is among the schismatics for having divided Christianity, and Ali, at that point, for having divided Islam. The point was not Christian or Islamic religion, but to have caused discord.
6
@iliveinsideyourhouse1367 It's actually the contrary. It has been noticed how the Dante main character of the Comedy, is very different from the historical Dante poet. He is weak (Dante was a war veteran) and not very bright (not understanding the meaning of much of the things that the Dante poet wrote). More than a self-insert, Dante gave his name to a proper character that was fit for the poem.
5
@Kyl5 Actually Dante was very famous in life, and his "canti" were already endlessly repeated in public, by professionals and normal people, when he was still writing the poem.
4
@deathknight75 He didn't bash Muslims and Greeks at all. Don't take this review for serious.
4
@ruialmeida818 13-14th century Italians WOULD NEVER IDENTIFY THEMSELF WITH DIFFERENT NATIONALITIES. One thing are political entities, another is nationality ESPECIALLY FOR DANTE, that was in favour of the Empire, so a sovranational political entity. The same order of the political stances in the Comedy stress that. Inferno is about Tuscan politics, Purgatorio about Italian politics, Paradiso about European ones. Petrarch (born in Arezzo, Tuscany) in a letter to Boccaccio (Born in florence, Tuscany) made fun of the Calabrian scholar Leontius Pilatus that, being Italian (Petrarch's words. For Petrarch there were no doubts that someone born in Calabria was an Italian like him and Boccaccio), pretended to be Greek to have more recognition.
3
all hope abandon ye who enter here
2
It has been noticed how the Dante main character of the Comedy, is very different from the historical Dante poet. He is weak, timorous (Dante was a war veteran) and not very bright (not understanding the meaning of much of the things that the Dante poet wrote). More than a self-insert, Dante gave his name to a proper character that was fit for the poem.
2
Not a fanfiction, since there was not a canon.
2
The entire "Dante hated Greeks" part is more a blatant lie than a misrepresentation.
2
@deathknight75 Not really. Dante put Averroes and Saladin among the not-baptised virtuous. Averroes between the philosophers, with the likes of Aristotle and Plato. Saladin with the likes of Caesar. It had not been by chance. Saladin was the man that took Gerusalem away from Christianity, but he did it in an honorable manner, so he was not at fault more than Caear was at fault for being a pagan. Mohammad was put among the schismatics because Dante believed to the tale, diffused in medieval Europe, that Mohammed was a Christian bishop who created a new religion "mixing that of Moses with that of Christ". He's among the bearers of discord because he brought discord into Christanity. The Muslim's Saladin job happened to be to fight Christians, so he was not at fault in doing that. While Mohammad's job was not to create a new religion "dividing the Christians", so he's among the schismatics. Mind that Alì is there for the same reason. To have caused a schism, this time among the Muslims. for Dante it didn't count Christians or Muslims. counted if one brought discord or not. Greek heroes are there only because, to make the comedy interesting, Dante needed popular figures, alternating between the well known contemporaries and the well known historical figures (IE, in Canto XXVI there is Odysseus, in canto XXVII Guido da Montefeltro). But well known historical figures in middle age Europe were saints and characters of greek mithology. He couldn't put saints in hell, so...
2
Gluttons are those that surrendered to material needs so that those needs determined all of their life (becoming search for unnecessary luxuries). Since they acted like beasts, by giving in to their instincts, like beasts they'll grovel in the stinky mud without shelter.
1
Not a fanfic, since there was no canon. Actually the Divine Comedy became the canon for the afterlife.
1
Not in the Commedia. He had his abdomen cut open but, like any other damned in that circle, he could walk. In the time he would have completed the turn of the circle, his wounds would have healed, then a devil would had cut him open again. He profetises to Dante that Fra Dolcino will join him in that circle.
1
@StephanFitzgeraldTay In middle age it was diffused the belief Muhammed was a Christian bishop before creating Islam. Notice that Ali is in the same circle, for having divided Islam.
1