Comments by "Andy Dee" (@AndyViant) on "American Dives into Australian Reddit (r/Australia)" video.
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
The Barassi line concept I've discussed before.
All of Australia (AND New Zealand, btw) once all played Aussie Rules football to some degree. We had Aussie Rules and Rugby as competing winter sporting codes, and summer had Cricket. Gradually Rugby became more prominent in the working class industrial areas of NSW (meaning Sydney, Newcastle, Penrith, etc) and New Zealand, and Aussie Rules in the areas more influenced by Melbourne (which included Tasmania, Adelaide and Perth, and also included the south west of NSW). Most of south western NSW is closer to Melbourne or even Adelaide than Sydney. Northern Territory of course went the way Adelaide did as it was administered as part of South Australia for so long.
I can't really comment much on why NZ dropped Aussie Rules and even Rugby League until it's recent revival. Maybe a Kiwi follower can flesh that out as I'd be interested.
Perth's the mystery here, since unlike Adelaide it is too far away to be really under Melbourne's economic and cultural gravitational pull. I guess they just prefer the game, and 19th century maritime shipping along the southern coast kind of makes it more Melbourne influenced than Sydney influenced, although you would also think that there should have been a competing Cape Town influence.
Also worth remembering how much bigger than Perth (and Brisbane) Adelaide used to be. Maybe I'm understimating its own influence because Adelaide has been the laggard of Australia's big capitals for decades.
Brisbane, due to the same geography and economics reasons as Perth in the end fell to the influence of Sydney and became a more "Rugby" region (although it held on to a stronger Aussie Rules culture for far longer than Sydney did), and honestly most of the rest of Queensland went to Rugby as quickly as most of NSW, before Brisbane did.
When Rugby schismed into Rugby League and Rugby Union the "Union" side of the game became very much a sport of the elite schools and League became the working class man's sport. Of course this split had almost no influence at all on the Aussie Rules states.
1