General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Fernando Jackson
Yishai Fleisher
comments

Comments by "Fernando Jackson" (@fernandojackson7207) on "Yishai Fleisher" channel.

@MacedoMacedo74 It's you who are meaningless. Three military have testified to the fact that no genocide has taken place: Sir John McColl, John Spencer, Richard Kemp. But I'm sure you know better than people with military training and field experience.
18
@arturturk5926 Those who make those claims do little but parrot what they hear from others who are just as ignorant as themselves. Informed people; people in the military, such as Sir John McCall, John Spencer, Richard Kemp, all say otherwise. I wouldn't get information about, say, Physics, from butchers, dress designers, etc., who know nothing about Physics. Let alone the data itself points in the opposite direction.
10
 @MacedoMacedo74 You don't in any way speak for the rest of the world, but rather for those who barely even know the meaning of the term, let alone have any evidence for support.
10
@ranro7371 Muslims invaded, enslaved and forcefully converted millions. Sounds pretty imperial to me.
8
@jessoliver2955 They were forced out of Jordan, Kuwait, raised hell in Lebanon. But that's all swept under the rug, since Israel wasn't involved.
7
 @SalvadorOchoa-p9k Defending themselves isn't the same as trying to kill them. Gaza's population grew by millions since the end of ww2. Some genocide.
5
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k hamas has fully brought it on them. Israel hasn't.
5
@lydarivera Just how did I do that? I'm defending Israel and the truth.
5
@lydarivera May your slander towards me bounce back at you tenfold.
5
 @farouqmj1147 It's called self-defense. Look into it. Just why were Palestinians forced out of so many places?
4
 @bushwhackeddos.2703 At the end of the day, Judaism stems from JUDEA, while Arabs originate from the ARABIAN Peninsula. Al-Aksa is built on top of Solomon's temple. Try again.
4
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k There is no genocide. It's an absurd, indefensible claim. Gazan population increased by millions between ww2 and 2023. Giving advance warnings of attacks, allowing in aid, providing safety routes, are not consistent with genocide.
4
@jessicamason2526 And? Since when is that a basis to claim exclusive rights over a land, one already populated by other groups ?
3
@RonaldLynch-id5iz Have Elon take them to some other planet , where they can have their own country.
3
@ashbeck1736 The world pre-Ww2 was nasty and brutal , with frequent wars; look at Europe alone, where they butchered each other periodically, yet they had no major war since. Not a perfect system, arrangement, but I'm not aware of a better one.
3
@ashbeck1736 Israel became a country naturally, per the Mandate System, as so many other countries: Irak, Syria, Lebanon did, in their ancestral lands. Notice: Jews: Judea, Arabs: Arabia. The region of Palestine had become stateless as a result of the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire. Several states, including Israel, Syria, Lebanon, etc. were created to provide locals a state. I don't see anythIng strained or unnatural about Israel, nor the way it was created.
3
 @scytaleghola5969 The crowds I saw depicted were quite large. And there was a massive one , per aerial pics, in Baghdad.
3
@herteert299 From what, other than hamas, who beat the hell out of anyone who disagrees with them. And hamas keeps itself sheltered with access to food , water, electricity in the tunnels, why their civilians languish outside.
3
@eduekhaya8727 Who's lying? About what?
2
@jammin3858 And yet now many demand that Israel , who had nothing to see with it, take them in.
2
@jessicamason2526 And? Chinese-, Irish-, German- Americans, have blood from their respective ancestral countries. That doesn't give them rights in those countries.
2
@patlong8449 Invaded? You mean invaded a country/nation that never existed?
2
 @wingsoffreedom3589 Three colonels who have been in the field: Sir John McColl, John Spencer, Richard Kemp, beg to differ with you and with others without knowledge nor experience.
2
@ashbeck1736 Well, at least that process has been aided by the US. Providing the world with the Web/Internet by itself has been more helpful to humanity than anything any other group has done, by several orders of magnitude. And unfortunately not the whole world has turned away from barbarism.
2
 @SalvadorOchoa-p9k What, defending itself from repeated terror attacks on its civilians?
2
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k When? It was 7 Arab armies that launched the war in 1948, rather than negotiating. But the two have been opposing, fighting each other for centuries.
2
 @ranro7371 So, you're saying Hebrew, which existed centuries before Islam did, stems from Arabic, really?
2
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k It was done through the exact same method used to create Syria, Irak, Lebanon: The Mandate System, which was _ legally binding_. Palestinians weren't forced out. They were encouraged to leave by other Arabs. Still, they were given a home in Jordan, Kuwait, but got themselves kicked out. Move on and take responsibility for your actions.
2
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k hamas brought their suffering on them. After hamas led repeated attacks against Israeli civilians that killed thousands, Israel fought back. Stop blaming others for your actions.
2
Under UNCHR, thousands of refugees were placed in a few years. Under UNRWA, the number of refugees increased from 700,000 to 5.9 million. UNRWA must renew its charter to continue operating . Next up is in 2026. Let's organize so it's not renewed.
1
It's become a cult. Reason, evidence, don't apply to their beliefs.
1
@mbormann6046 They don't, and most of what they say has no basis in fact.
1
@susancohen8009 Or in most Arab countries, including those who pound their chest on how much they care about Palestinians, yet ignore their mistreatment anywhere except ( supposedly) in relation to Israel.
1
@saintadolf5639 Do tell, Adolf. Sources would be great too.
1
@racinmoeherdez4434 Yes, in people's imagination. No such actual nation exists. Palestinians had a home in Jordan, Kuwait, and were kicked out of both. But Israel bad, and they should take in Palestinians, who have vowed to destroy them. Right.
1
@jessicamason2526 And? That has never been a basis for claiming rights to land. And even then, there's no cultural connection between Caananites and current Palestinians.
1
@MommaFig1 Besides, a group having lived in a region for some time has never been a basis for granting land ownership.
1
@spacecats2185 And by that token, Jews that were forced out of Arab countries should be given compensation or allowed back in.
1
@eduekhaya8727 Who's lying? About what?
1
@MommaFig1 Groups have been going in and out of the region for centuries.
1
@patlong8449 No lands have been invaded.
1
@wingsoffreedom3589 I (mis)understood you were claiming Israel was responsible for genocide.
1
If she has a criticism to make, she should do it privately, within the family, religion.
1
How are local prostitutes going to find clients?
1
@arturturk5926 Three colonels: Richard Spencer, Sir JohnMccall, John Spencer, who actually know what they're talking about, have testified to the effect Israel is making a concerted effort to avoid, minimize civilian deaths. Go find a new reason to hate Israel, genius.
1
Evidence. Look into it.
1
This situation does not meet the definition of Occupation by the Hague, which says an occupation takes place when the hostile army replaces the function of the government of those occupied. No such happens, as both Area A, gaza( pre 7/10) , have their own government.
1
@BiharyGabor Er, no. hamas runs its police force, army, education system. They were even voted in. The Idf doesn't patrol Gaza. If it did, the repeated attacks against Israel, the building of tunnels, wouldn't have happened.
1
@BiharyGabor As agreed to by _ both sides_, and in agreement with Oslo. If Palestinians don't like it, have them take it out with their representatives in the PA, who signed the agreement.
1
@BiharyGabor Er, there is no forceful imposition when the PA has agreed to both this arrangement, to Oslo, without any duress involved. Thus, by the Geneva definition, there is no such. Israel neither makes nor enforces laws in Area A. Please provide references to the contrary. All of Judea and Samaria are still technically, formally, Israeli land by Utis Posidetis Juris, as J&S were part of the Mandate for Palestine .
1
@BiharyGabor Do tell is just what specific international laws has Israel violated. Not quoting the UN, whose Human Rights council includes Russia, China, Iran. UN advisory opinions aren't International law, nor legally binding. Same for its resolutions, notwithstanding that hizbollah ignores 1701.
1
@BiharyGabor Controlling access to Israel by gazans is what every country does. Restrictions to prevent the regular attacks by hamas against Israeli civilians, don't violate International Law. Gazans were able to travel to and work in Israel freely. Until they started walking in with self-immolation vests and regulary killed or hijacked Israeli civilians. You want to deny Israel the right to self-defense. Notice Egypt blockades gaza, and several countries forced out Palestinians. Why don't you ask Jordan, Kuwait, who forced them out, to retake their Palestinians?
1
@BiharyGabor https://youtube.com/shorts/Xq3CcALmq2o?si=u4UyuhNdp8IBNX3x
1
@BiharyGabor I'm not sure of their status, given Oslo has been repeatedly violated. As of 1967, they were part of Israel proper, by Utis Posidetis Juris. I believe at this point, they're administered in accordance to Oslo.
1
@BiharyGabor Er, no, upon transfer of Mandate land, Israel automatically acquires the boundaries of such land. Just like several other countries like Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, etc., that evolved out of the Mandate system. I told you, beyond that, I'm not clear, as Oslo was the governing scheme since 1993, after which it was violated repeatedly. Thus I'm not clear on its status at this point. Funny how those like you only question Israel's claim to its land, but have no concerns for the ownership status by other countries.
1
@BiharyGabor If you keep calling me dishonest, I will stop exchanging with you. I'm providing answers to the best of my knowledge. Do tell, just _ what_ have I misrepresented?
1
@BiharyGabor Just what is it Im not being honest about? Be honest yourself, rather than throwing about the term without any basis in fact.
1
@BiharyGabor It was you who falsely claimed Israel was occupying Area A , as the PA is the government there, where law enforcement is based on Oslo, which has been _ agreed to_ by both parties, contradicting your claim that Israel forces itself on the PA; the authorities in Area A. Spare me your moralizing.
1
@BiharyGabor The terms by which the Idf operates in Judea and Samaria, _ have been agreed to_ by both sides. As such, it is _ not_ forceful, nor has it been impossed / done under duress. When the terms have been agreed to, there is no dictatorship by the Idf. Want to see dictatorship, look at hamas, which is in its 17th year of a 4-year term, which governs without any controls, opposition party nor free press. And you endorse the sham of the UN, UNRWA, who have artificially kept this problem ongoing. UNCHR was able to place all its refugees in a few years , while in 75 years, UNRWA has increased the number from 700,000 to 5.9 million. UNRWA considers any descendants of refugees of 1948 to be refugees themselves, so that, even those that have acquired nationality in 3rd countries are still considered refugees. So, the likes of 28-year old Bella haddid , born in Washington DC, worth around $23 million, a supermodel, is a refugee, and, as such, can claim benefits from UNRWA. Spare me your lecture. I'm done with this exchange. My " lack of answer" is the result of vague, unverifiable claims and appeals to authority, as you demand sources without providing any yourself. Good day/night, etc.
1
@BiharyGabor You have _ repeatedly_ made vague, unverified/unverifiable claims yourself. Your claim of occupation is , has been countered by actual International Lawyers such as Eugene Kontorovich, who has taught at the University level and publishes a column in mainstream papers. I won't take lectures from you. I'm done here. Good day/night, etc.
1
@BiharyGabor Enjoy parroting baseless UN and otherwise nonsense. Now I understand how you reach your conclusion. By citing shills within the UN. I have _ already_ adressed the opinions you misrepresented as facts. Kontorovich's opinion stand or fall on their own, independent of your questionable claims. Not surprised of yet one more person giving a pass to hamas, to several other wars. You accomplish nothing in terms of swaying my opinion. Clearly this isn't your real goal.
1
@BiharyGabor Regards to Mrs Dunning and Kruger.
1
To tell the truth?
1
 @ashbeck1736 The world is currently more peaceful and prosperous than at any point in time. I doubt that would be the case if it had been left to its own device.
1
@ashbeck1736 Well, it's an opiniin, not like I can run a double/triple blind experiment to verify it. If you check " Our World in Data", you see the exponential decrease in poverty rate, increase in literacy, etc, after ww2. If the US, West wanted to keep others down, they wouldn't have provided the technology of the Web for free. Sorry, but this comment section doesn't allow me to see your comment in full, so I'm guessing beyond the first few lines of your comment.
1
@ashbeck1736 Ok, I was unable to read your comments beyond the first few lines, so I couldn't be certain of what your comment was. Not sure if you mean that helping Israel defend itself from attacks by several Muslim countries with more than 10x its population is what you mean by intervening in their (ME) affairs.
1
A
1
@anniesue4456 Well, sort of agree, but how much can you compress into a few hours per week? A class on just , say, Eastern history, could take up a whole school year. I did well by doing a lot of reading outside my classes, and aced AP classes.
1
@ashbeck1736 I didn't report nor flag your answer. The only tragedy about Israel is the artificial one brought about by Palestinians and their supporters.
1
The process by which Israel became a nation is the same as that by which Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, several others, became a country.
1
@jamesarthur2140 Nothing specific. No evidence on him getting paid. No surprise.
1
@mochithepooh5368 But this assumption is made, used by many in their arguments.
1
@squid_3 There were versions based on local Jewish culture. Unlike with any Palestinian culture.
1
@artificialconstruct-c8m Jews had been living there for centuries. Judea: Judaism.
1
@chuknorth Just what fairy tales are those?
1
 @RWZiggy Which has never been documented.
1
 @lm1275 Surely you can provide sources, refs, right?
1
 @lm1275 Educate us on the topic by providing _ specific_ sources, refs, from 3rd parties.
1
 @JayDee-x2b No, I'm not that old ;).
1
 @lm1275 Can you provide a number /code for such FOIA release?
1
 @farouqmj1147 Made up, most likely. Provide 3rd party refs otherwise.
1
 @asadmadmuj6729 And you can surely provide 3rd party references, right?
1
 @maryreis3339 Republicans don't have an equivalent of the Squad.
1
 @nrm55 Yes, the refusal to negotiate and subsequent genocidal attack by Arab armies. Hmm.. thousands of refugees placed in a few years by UNCHR, and 0 placed by UNRWA.
1
 @lunarvvolf9606 A mistake for which Israel apologized, dealt with to the satisfaction of both countries.
1
 @billmontgomery3737 Well, even if true, just how many could there have been? Let alone there are Muslim, Christian Israelis.
1
 @Janet-p3d If you want to call others liars, why don't you provide actual 3rd party reference of your own?
1
 @hemispace641 You went around and asked, checked, on all of them, I'm sure.
1
 @John-te4ei You remember something made up. Israel is defending itself, however you dislike it.
1
 @5EK5HUN8 A rumor that was never documented. At worse, it was a few ones, who may have been Christians or Muslims. Just how can anyone tell what their nationalities were?
1
@jprules2578 Any verification? Israel buys US-made weapons, tests and improves them, providing a military base for the US. An ally indeed. Else is just rumors. Just what would Israel gain? And the authors of the attacks were Saudi. Do you think the Mossad would even be in contact with Saudi terrorists?
1
 @brucephillip6456 Surely you verified that was their religion. Did you pull their pants down?
1
@farouqmj1147 Any refs? Celebrating what?
1
@lunarvvolf9606 Just what am I lying about _ specifically_? Just how am I " Tying the free speech" of anyone?
1
@lunarvvolf9606 Those with scruples who accuse others of lying provide evidence. You haven't.
1
@lunarvvolf9606 Why are you clinging to something from 57 years back? Do you claim no apologies were offered? Both countries seem to have moved on.
1
@lunarvvolf9606 Ok, my bad, I guess I misunderstood. Still, what's the point of dredging up events from 57 years back?
1
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k No one is taking nor has taken any " Palestinian land", as, among other things, there has never been any nation of Palestine. And, no, you clearly don't know the US helped, as the US didn't help Israel until recently. And good job ignoring that Iran, NK, Russia, a good chunk of the current 1.8 billion Muslims , want to destroy Israel. That , some 10 countries and 1.6 billion , against Israel's 9 million, is fair to you. Israel is mostly self-reliant in high tech; one of the world's top in several areas, independently of US support. Unlike your Muslim countries, who have produced nothing of value for several centuries. Try again.
1
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k Israel by itself is among the top 10 tech powers of the world , despite its population of 9.2 million. It does better than any of the Muslim countries with several times its land size and population. Unlike its Muslim enemies, it's forward looking , and it doesn't kill nor harass women just for not wearing along a dress code, nor for showing too much hair.
1
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k Done, as there's no such thing outside your imagination.
1
@SalvadorOchoa-p9k You clearly know nothing. It was Iran, UNRWA spending billions , providing weapons through tunnels, together with support from China, Russia, NK . They wouldn't have lasted a single week without them. I know history; go fool others who don't. You clearly don't understand anything either about land ownership that you can't do anything beyond parroting a few tired old lines.
1
I don't see how that changes the gist of the point.
1
 @tewodrosarage286 Crazy how, for telling the truth?
1
 @g2a9-qx8cf Do tell is just what lies he told. Be specific.
1
 @mohammedzabar-l1r Do tell just what is it he said that is wrong or false.
1
@sidprice6214 Just what that was said is not the truth? Be specific.
1
Dutch Parliament.
1
 @techknowsimply365 By what, whose account? References?
1
 @Resh012 Lost? It's spoken today. By civilized people.
1
 @randallsmerna384 They ethnically cleansed them. Not sure of your point otherwise.
1
@GrouchyMonk2025 It isn't artificial. Unless you believe several other countries such as Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, tens of others who were created through the Mandate System, are artificial. Alloting land to displaced groups as a result of the dissolution of the Ottoman, other empires, isn't artificial.
1
 @GrouchyMonk2025 Just what, _ specifically_ on his account, is debatable?
1
@jumbojumbo6866 And gazan deaths are the result of hamas' actions, directly or indirectly. A hamas has failed to provide shelter while keeping themselves in the tunnels, where they have reliable access to food, water, electricity, while gazan civilians languish. And hamas itself have killed their own for daring to disagree with them. There is too, shoddy construction standards, which have led to homes collapsing.
1
 @Boris-pn3tp Just when has Israel killed anywhere near 300k Palestinians?
1
@GrouchyMonk2025 Your premises just don't hold up. Jews had been living there for centuries and had built their culture in the region. Notice, Jews: Judea, Arab: Arabia. And, no, it was not " centuries ago"; Jews had been living there continuously over the centuries. But I can turn things around on you and say that Arabs ( allegedly, as many are recent arrivals) living there, does not grant them rights to the land. There are other issues: Palestinian Arabs were granted Jordan. Secondly, they were not forced out by Jews, some of whom actually asked them to stay, but rather Arab leaders asked them to leave. Then there's the fact that Palestinians had found refuge in several Arab countries, which then forced them out. Why not give these countries the burden of absorbing the Palestinians they forced out. Lastly, Arabs launched a genocidal war in 1948 . And they lost. When a group launches and loses a genocidal war, they don't get to complain. If Palestinians were forced out, just where did the current 1.8 million Muslims come from? Some 850,000 Jews were forced out of Arab countries. That apparently is a non-issue. There is no such " theft". The Mandate System works as it does because it's essentially impossible to distribute land in a way that pleases everyone. Several other countries were born through the exact same Mandate System, where some local groups were displaced: Syria, Irak, Lebanon, etc. Wonder if you call that theft as well. Ultimately, millions have gone through similar or worse than displacement and have moved on, rather than brooding and nursing resentment for 76 years. Have Palestinians do that. There is no such theft beyond your opinion; neither laws nor precedent supports claims of theft of land.
1