Comments by "Fernando Jackson" (@fernandojackson7207) on "uncivilized " channel.

  1. ​@yahyamohammed637 False: 5 Arab armies launched an attack to nascent Israel. They lost and then they played the victim.
    9
  2. ​ @arifabd There's plenty of evidence of continued Jewish presence in the Levant.
    8
  3. Grossly false. It was 5 Arab armies in 1948 who tried to prevent Israel from emerging as a country. Quoting a lie won't make it true.
    6
  4. Absurd. Israel's weapons are good enough that US aid is tied to no-compete agreements in the weapons industry. It developed the Iron Dome, David Sling and others independently.
    6
  5. @arifabd  Not sure of what point you're addressing. There's evidence of continued Jewish presence in the Levant for centuries. No such for Palestinians. At any rate, the Mandate of Nations grants the land to Israel in a legally-binding way. I've been polite with you, I'd appreciate the same in return.
    5
  6. @someboi4535  Not aware of any such, let alone older than Jews. What was their religion, economy, art, etc? And the League of Nations does have that right, as all the countries at that time were signatories and thus the Mandates are legally binding. But if you deny such rights, then you throw the boundaries of Syria, Iraq, etc., into question, as they all derived from Mandates.
    4
  7.  @arifabd  There were Jews living in the area for centuries. Do you deny that? According to International law, Utis Posidetis Juris is the law used to determine boundaries of newly-formed countries. It was used to determine the boundaries of Iraq, Syria, others. I suspect you're not too upset at the 850,000 Jews forced out of Arab countries, are you? Nor are you upset at Jordanians , Kuwaitis, etc forcing out Palestinians, are you? Nor are you upset at how Palestinians are mistreated in Syria or Lebanon. Nice try, but those arriving were mostly fleeing the Holocaust. Your dear Mufti Amin Al-Husseini cooperated with the Nazis.
    4
  8.  @arifabd  It isn't according to International law. And they weren't, with few exceptions, displaced. Notice some 200,000 stayed and became the current 2.1 million Israeli Muslims. How do you explain that happening? There's evidence to the effect Arab leaders asked them to leave when they launched the war against nascent Israel. Moreover, 850,000 Jews were forced out of Arab countries. They've moved on, however difficult it was. Does that upset you too?
    4
  9.  @arifabd  I'll be heading to work and will reply when I get back.
    4
  10.  @dannyburrito7305  Many were descendants of those who had lived in the area for centuries.
    4
  11. @primordial1675  Er, no. Still, it was 5 armies against one. Israel has, produces, several advanced weapons and improves on those from the US.
    4
  12. @aghyad2867  Even if that were the case, it's FA FO. And, no, the 1967 war was in response to Nasser threatening to block the Strait of Tirana, removing UN envoys. That's considered an act of war. It makes no sense for fledgling Israel initiate a fight with so many Arab nations against them. And, no, they didn't have unlimited weapons last I checked.
    4
  13.  @aimanmarzuqi4804  By what account were those " Palestinian" lands? The region was called Palestine , had been ruled by the Ottomans since 1517, but there was never an independent entity called Palestine.
    4
  14.  @moin_khan1996  Just what might was that? They had no access to weapons in Germany.
    4
  15. My question to the poster and producer of this video: Should any other country exist? Should you personally exist?
    4
  16.  @aimanmarzuqi4804  I was referring to your claim of land theft. The land was ruled by the Ottomans from 1517 to 1917. As such it wasn't a Palestinian entity, which I thought you were referring to.
    4
  17. @aimanmarzuqi4804  That has been debunked too many times. And there's evidence of continued Jewish presence in the Levant. Try again.
    4
  18.  @arifabd  Relevant according to what, who ? Not to international law, for one.
    3
  19.  @arifabd  Jordanians, Iraqis, Kuwaitis, forced out Palestinians. Did they have a right to do it?
    3
  20. @fredflinstone6601  Er, no. Nasser threatened to block the Strait of Tirana, blocking access to the sea is an act of war. And Portugal was then a poor backwater, I doubt they had any advanced weaponry.
    3
  21. @andini2145  So you suggest all Arabs that have established themselves in the West return to Arabia too?
    2
  22. @arturferrao7353  Just what specific International law is being violated? 850,000 Jews were forced out of Arab countries, yet they've moved on. Descendants of those supposedly displaced have never been granted right of return.
    2
  23. ​ @t4nvirt4hs4n8  Look up Mufti Amin Al-Husseini, who cooperated with the Nazis.
    1
  24. ​ @smostar569  There's no genocide taking place. Genocide means there's a plan, organized, effort to destroy a group. What evidence of such is there?
    1
  25. ​ @nvm649  Comparison is nonsensical. Jews never attacked Germans repeatedly, fought in self-defense.
    1
  26.  BradleyUK58  Don't you know? Any Jew who agrees with them is automagically right, truthful / sarc
    1
  27. @nomoreinternet6270  Mufti Amin Al-Husseini met and cooperated with the Nazis. That's for those who tell you all the hatred begun when Zionists arrived.
    1
  28. It's a cheap shot and grossly false accusation.
    1
  29.  @nvm649  And those like you to make grossly invalid analogies. Comparing a war in self-defense that has unintentionally killed at most 15,000, with an act of targeting Jews that killed 6 million. Complete nonsense.
    1
  30. @CalculusBridge  most don't hate Arabs, but hamas and their supporters.
    1
  31. @comingviking  Finkelstein is a clown who has no real talent, so appeals to outrageous claims. He was even denied an adjunct position at Hunter College.
    1
  32. False. There's plenty of evidence of Jews living in the area continuously. Notice: Judea: Jews . Arabia : Arabs
    1
  33. ​ @q8backpacker  There's evidence of continued Jewish presence in the Levant for centuries. And Arabs come from the Arabian Peninsula. Have them return there then.
    1
  34. Why should Palestine exist as a nation? A video worth of lies and cherry-picked bullshit don't make up for a cogent argument.
    1
  35.  @arifabd  I don't need any education from you. I've watched diverse sources and know the _ specifics _ of the case. Give it a try.
    1
  36.  @arifabd  Sure, just what specifically do you want me to address?
    1
  37.  @arifabd  I'm not sure, I haven't seen it in a while. I doubt there's any numbers dating so far back. But it's irrelevant to determining the boundaries or rights to land in a legally-binding way. And not sure what you mean by " categories ". What categories are you referring to?
    1
  38. @afRolowkey  There are both lilly-white, redhead or blond Palestinians as well as brown, black children, so, no, not " white " Israeli children. Death figures by hamas have been put into question. But no, don't put words in my mouth, I do feel for all civilians. Death figures by hamas have been put into question I the Daily Sceptic, not a Jewish paper.
    1
  39. Why does any country have the right to exist? Why does the author or the speaker have any more right to exist than Israel?
    1
  40. It's called _ evidence_ look into it. The Mandate from Palestine by the League of Nations is legally binding , because all other countries were signatories. I guess in your world, evidence doesn't count for much. Not surprised.
    1
  41. How many sugar daddies have Arabs, Palestinians had? Iran, Russia, etc. I guess being 1.8 billion to Jews' 17 million isn't enough of an advantage?
    1
  42. @samuelbarton  If Muslim Arabs weren't around, Israel wouldn't be fighting at all. Can't remember any war agsinst them that was actually initiated by Israel, can you?
    1
  43.  @aimanmarzuqi4804  Can you provide evidence to that effect? There's plenty of evidence of Jews living continuously in the Levant for centuries. But that's not the basis for land allotment, which is rather Utis Posidetis Juris, which is legally binding. It is and has been used to mark the boundaries of every single newly-formed country.
    1
  44. I guess that the 850,000 Jews will be able to return to the Arab countries that forced them out, right? Let alone it was the Arab countries that led the great majority to leave. No other group has granted refugee status to descendants of those supposedly displayed.
    1
  45.  @benfirgdhs  That's a fairy tale, no real evidence.
    1
  46.  @bharatyaswaraj5641  They were forced out of several countries. And no one wants to take them in now.
    1
  47.  @wisdomisbetterthansilverorg0ld  Yet it's Muslim in Europe who are demanding Sharia in their countries.
    1
  48.  @arturferrao7353  That's doubtful, as there are 1.8 million Israeli Muslims today, with full rights.
    1
  49.  @arturferrao7353  Then explain to us just where the 1.8 million Israeli Muslims came from.
    1
  50. @Sp3ll633  Let alone that millions of others have been displaced or worse, yet , rather than brooding about it for 80 years, they've moved on, and don't use it as an excuse to kill and rape.
    1