Comments by "Fernando Jackson" (@fernandojackson7207) on "Secular Talk" channel.

@PraetorAkin Israel is defending itself. Hamas is still firing rockets at civilians.
4
@mohdridzuanisa2373 Do elaborate. Please be specific on just what I am blind to. Your name sounds Iranian; your country is imploding.
2
@mohdridzuanisa2373 There is no occupation nor theft. Several Arab countries, including Jordan , forced them out. Even if there was an occupation, which there isn't, they can't attack civilians.
2
@mohdridzuanisa2373 Er, no. Occupation means the occupying army serves as the government of the occupied group. That isn't nor has it happened. The rest of your point is then moot.
2
@mohdridzuanisa2373 Please be specific. Just what am I blind to? Certainly not the repeated terror attacks by Palestinians against civilians, way before October 7. Look up just two: Munich Olympics in 1972, Sbarro café. Plenty more where that came from.
2
Indeed, a genocide in which they give advanced warning of attacks, provide safe routes and let in aid. By hamas' own account, the civilian death toll by May was revised down to some 13,000 civilians. Many of the dead " children" were war-trained teenagers, usung rifles and other weapons. They had told us the same on genocide before the 7/10 attacks. Yet Gaza's population had increased by millions from 1948 to 2023. Some genocide.
1
@MadRedAlchemist They're defending themselves from years of terror attacks that killed thousands.
1
@09spidy Except no genocide is taking nor has taken place.
1
@sabin97 White people? Arabs have invaded , enslaved and forcefully converted millions. African Moors, Ottomans, both enslaved whites. Selective outrage.
1
@nploda1408 According to whom? None of former USSR satellites has sought to go back to communism.
1
@mohdridzuanisa2373 There are no 1945 borders, as Israel didn't even exist then. Tell your Iranian leaders to stop sponsoring hizbulla, who engage in drug and human trafficking. The borders of Israel are determined by International Law. Tell the Arab countries that forced out Palestinians, to take them back. Several Arab countries forced out Jews too.
1
@titilili88 Please elaborate on such apartheid, in a country where all groups have equal rights and an Arab Muslim was appointed to the Israeli Supreme Court.
1
@shireenshah6312 That's unlikely, to say the least. To the degree that an Arab Muslim was appointed to the Israeli Supreme Court. And Palestinians live under the PA , not Israeli government.
1
Er, no, by hamas' own numbers, the civilian death toll by May was around 13,000. And many of the children were war-trained teenagers. Israel is fighting back after years worth of terror attacks against its civilians that has left thousands dead. Somehow this show is ignoring this civilian death toll.
1
@dalekrenegade2596 And yet you can't point out any specifics.
1
@dalekrenegade2596 Be specific. Just what am I lying about?
1
Yes, they're fighting after years of terror attacks by hamas against Israeli civilians that left thousands dead. Don't they have the right to defend themselves from it? How is that genocide?
1
@Madridista8585 Colonel Richard Kemp argued the opposite, that Israel is being very careful. Given hamas won't wear uniforms and uses civilian buildings to lead its military operations, it is very hard to spare civilians. Hamas keeps firing rockets at Israel civilian targetson a periodic basis. Are you telling me Israel shouldn't fight back?
1
@Madridista8585 Stolen land by what account. On what basis does it belong to them? Jews had been living in the Levant for centuries before Islam even existed. Notice the Kingdom of Judea. The name Judea gives rise to ' Judaism'.
1
 @zizo015 Apartheid how? There are 2.1 million non-Jewish Israelis, all with full rights.
1
 @ulysesdiesta2772 Who is? Why?
1
 @zizo015 Yes, there were laws that treated whites differently from blacks. Not aware of any such laws in Israel, were 20% of the population is non-Jewish, yet have full rights.
1
@dalekrenegade2596 Please provide references, examples. Palestinians led the Munich Olympic attacks in 1972, Entebbe, Sbarro attacks, among many. Even several attacks on Jews before Israel existed, they cooperated with the Nazis. Look up Amin Al-Husseini.
1
@Madridista8585 Many countries don't. Mandelas's son disagreed. It depends on whether you're human or a bot. I doubt you can make a specific case that Israel is an apartheid state. A full 20% of its population is non-Jewish and enjoys full rights. That's not consistent with apartheid.
1
@russcontact Yes, after consistently being attacked by hamas, who killed thousandands of civilians, they wanted an end to such attacks. How dare they.
1
@Madridista8585 Col Richard Kemp testified to the contrary, that Israel was making an effort to avoid killing civilians. There's your evidence . But hamas wears no uniforms and uses civilian buildings.
1
@Madridista8585 Do tell us just how Palestinians own the land. Any deeds, treaties with Israel? By International Law, the land belongs to Israel. Specifically, by Utis Posidetis Juris, which has been apolied in every case of newly-formed countries.
1
@Madridista8585 https://youtu.be/DogPPJmUZYY?si=Tq7DGrLUzo0A-x7D
1
@Madridista8585 When was the _ first_ time a Palestinian state existed?Er, no, they didn't live there. There was _ never_ a Palestinian state. Jews had been forced out several times. Again, Judea gives the name to Judaism. In modern times, International Law; Utis Posidetis Juris, grants the land to Israel . Same law used everywhere, it only upsets you when Israel is involved.
1
@Madridista8585 Firstly, very few were forced out. Arab armies invaded in 1948, intending to commit genocide on local Jews. If Jews had sought to kill them, just how do you explain that there are 1.8 Muslim Israelis today? Let alone millions of others have actually been displaced; recently through ww2. Millions of Czechs, Ethnic Germans, Karelians. The creation of Syria, Iraq, displaced Kurds, Assyrians. You don't seem too upset at their displacement. There was no distinctive Palestinian civilization. No distinctive language, culture, literature, etc. They were at most nomadic groups. Arab armies launched a genocidal war against Jews in 1948 and lost. They don't get to complain.
1
@russcontact Wanted what? Putring an end to repeated terror attacks by hamas , which killed thousands of civilians. How dare they, right?
1
@Madridista8585 Palestinians were forced out of several Arab countries. Jordan even revoked their nationality. Why aren't you condemning those countries that forced them out?
1
@Madridista8585 You clearly couldn't counter anything I said. Your pretend concern for Palestinians is clear. Palestinians are , at best, treated like second class citizens in Lebanon, Syria. They're treated like garbage by hamas. Enjoy your Islamist agenda.
1
@wolfpacguy-v3y Those have been debunked. The student doing his thesis on Tantura dropped out; the data was forged. Nakba was caused by an attempt by Arab armies to commit genocide against Jews. If they were all forced out, how come there are 1.8 million Muslim Israelis today? USS Indianapolis was a mistake for which Israel apologized. It was dealt with to both sides' satisfaction.
1
@fahimaamin8025 Some 850,000 Jews were forced out of Arab countries. And it's those that either build illegally or give shelter to those who commit terror acts whose homes are torn down.
1
@russcontact How dare they fight back after years of terror attack against their civilians.
1
@d1rus592 https://youtu.be/yFverF8XbT4?si=JMELoQhAxX6Yphy4 There's no genocide. Civilians unfortunately die in wars. Israel is defending itself from years of terror attacks that killed thousands of civilians.
1
@d1rus592 Bet you're proud he's supporting maduro.
1
@d1rus592 Quite a misuse of the term. Your president supports maduro. Congrats.
1