Comments by "" (@jboss1073) on "History Debunked" channel.

  1. So when will you publish your refutation of Kevin MacDonald's "Culture of Critique"? Never? That's what I thought.
    43
  2.  @ThomasPaine1974  I am open to ANY arguments but I am open ONLY to arguments. I saw no arguments on this video to refute Kevin's thesis. I saw some whining and some displeasure at the existence of such work, but no refutation thereof.
    13
  3. Nice strawmen. But racialists believe it is about social darwinism, not planning explicit conspiracies. But please don't let this bother your strawmen.
    12
  4. No, British people are not Celts. Stop being so misinformed. Britons are Celtic-speakers - not Celts. The name "Celtic languages" was given by George Buchanan due to his belief that they came from the Celtici of Spain, hence the name "Celtic" languages, from the Celtici from Spain. It was never meant to imply that anyone in those northwestern islands are "Celts". They have no historical relationship to the word "Celts" ethnically - only linguistically from 1582 onwards and more prominently from the 19th century onwards.
    11
  5. All statist governments are left. All dictatorial, totalitarian governments are far left. This includes both C. and N.
    7
  6. 5:00 - "too straightforward" or too naïve?
    6
  7.  @nickmiller76  I'm confused, what is the point being made here? They are the same people.
    5
  8.  @bluegoose777  Before 449 AD everyone in the British isles was ethnically Briton, which were the direct descendants of the local Bell Beaker population originating from 2,500 BC. After 449 AD, southeastern Britons became half Saxon. "This is fascinating to me... I was always told that the Britons (the pre-Roman peoples of Britain) were a Celtic people. " No ancient source has ever called them that. Strabo visited the Britons and did not call them Celts. Strabo lived among the Celts of southern Gaul, in Narbo, so he knew the Celts very well. Strabo, Siculus, Herodotus and Pliny the Elder all places the Celts originally in Iberia, both in modern-day Spain and Portugal. Pliny said the tribes in modern-day central Portugal called themselves "Celts" by their surnames. Those exact names that Pliny wrote about were found in tombstones in Portugal dating from 100 BC to 200 AD.
    4
  9. ​ @crabby7668  "Iirc he only did short straight hops like most of the rest. The big thing about the wright's was their mastery of control, so they could turn and moanouvre the plane ie what we all expect from a plane these days. The rest couldn't." I'm sorry to say you remember incorrectly. Not only could Santos-Dumont's 14-Bis turn and manouvre and be fully controllable - not on its first flight but on its late November flights onwards after ailerons had been added - but his flight is the one recognized by the Federation Aeronautique International as being the first flight - and not the one by the Wright brothers. The lack of mention of Santos-Dumont only shows the ignorance about the official history of this subject.
    3
  10. Our enemies hate what is natural.
    3
  11. This is correct. Racism actually led to cooperation between Germans and Jews, both having had the same ethnic goals at the time.
    3
  12. To destroy it and leave way for a lesser people to win over us.
    2
  13.  @TomasFunes-rt8rd  Thank you for engaging. I actually don't judge by skin color but by genetics. They are the same people because they are genetically within panmixia levels, which means they are not differentiable for purposes of mating. In other words, Fst genetic distance between African-Americans and Sub-Saharan Africans is within 0.01.
    2
  14.  @TomasFunes-rt8rd  " For example, "panmixia" is something discussed about ANIMALS rather than humans. " Humans are animals. We are not aliens. I am a natural animal of this world and so are you. Everything we do is natural to our species. Elon building rockets is just as natural as ants building anthills. " Now, "racial hygiene" or "racial purity" is very poor consolation for worsening economic and security environments, plummeting living standards or out of control guerrilla uprisings. " Far from it, no one is seeking any purity, just social trust.
    2
  15. Nathan Cofnas thinks he has refuted the Culture of Critique.
    2
  16. It is incorrect. The planes made by the Wright brothers were not considered manageable by anyone but the Wrights themselves who had trained hundreds of times on their 1902 model. To this day their planes are not considered to possess the "fully controllable flight" trait. The first fully-controllable, sustained, powered, manned, heavier-than-air flight was by Alberto Santos-Dumont according to the Federation Aeronautique International.
    2
  17. ​ @neddyseagoon9601  "There again, it took Bleriot next to no time to build a very much better and very differently laid out plane that exceeded even their efforts." Bleriot built with the knowledge from the 14-Bis by Santos-Dumont, which was properly the first sustained, controlled, powered, heavier-than-air, manned flight, as recognized by the Federation Aeronautique International.
    2
  18. Parasites don't just leave.
    2
  19. AJs are not genetically Slavs, they cluster with southern Italians and Greeks.
    2
  20. Never forget the holocaust. 67,000 died.
    2
  21. "Take note of Brazilian inventor Alberto Santos Dumont, who many claim also preceded the Wright brothers." None other than the Federation Aeronautique International claims that the first flight was by Santos-Dumont. The author of this video is ignorant regarding the official history of the subject of early flying machines.
    2
  22.  @TomasFunes-rt8rd  When you say "deeply racist" all it really means is "deeply loving of one's extended family". I don't understand that as an insult.
    1
  23.  @Jaco059  Well they're nothing like us either so we shouldn't have them here. Better to send them to Africa. They're more like them.
    1
  24.  @Codysdab  It's perceived as being awful or wrong because there is ONE TRIBE who takes advantage of people not knowing that by infiltrating their countries with foreign ethnicities.
    1
  25. The now-called Indo-Europeans are what we called "the Aryans".
    1
  26.  @LordJinkies  "The name "Iran" is intended to be a reference to "Aryan", acknowledging that start." Right, which makes this impossible: "I think "Aryan" is a reference to the constellation or God, Aries, " Since the name "Aries" only existed from Latin onwards, which happened after the Iran/Aryan reference.
    1
  27.  @LordJinkies  "Both "Iran" and "Aries" could also be corruptions of an earlier word." Both those words come from a PIE root *ar-, so it is possible, yes.
    1
  28. It's not a niche topic, it's the background to our tragedy.
    1
  29. If it had been debunked we wouldn't need all the laws to protect the sacred sacrifice.
    1
  30. Christianity IS the Jewish faith which is why it has no place in Europe.
    1
  31. Forget winning the Paris prize, his flight is the only one recognized by the Federation Aeronautique International as having been the first flight. That is the official history of the subject of Early Flying Machines.
    1
  32.  @R4W88  That is from Wikipedia, something invented not in ancient times. That proves nothing. So they say that. What is their source? I'll save you time: what prior to 1582 connects the word "Celt" to Ireland or Britain? The answer is nothing. What object in ancient times was found in Britain with the name "Celt" on it? I'm trying to make you understand why the name "Celt" has nothing to do with Britain except linguistically and only post-1582 and because of a reference to the Celtici of Spain that the phrase "Celtic languages" was created. Also the clue was in the beginning: "the MODERN 'Celts'" which is "no Celts at all" since calling people based on the language they speak would have us calling Mexicans "Spaniards". You're not a Celt just because you speak Celtic. Just like the French are not Romans for speaking Romance.
    1
  33.  @coen8677  "The peoples who inhabited the Isles before the Romans arrived were Indo-European Celtic people. " There is no valid academic basis or argument to call those people "Celtic". Only linguists call them so, only after the 19th century (hence you cannot push this label backwards in time), and there is no evidence whatsoever those people all called themselves Celts. Only in Iberia are tombstones found with the name "Celt" dating from the Roman period. "As a scientist who took history as an elective, I see you fell for the modern rewriting of British history, which is nonsense." I didn't, actually, and I would gladly have this discussion live with you any day, any time. You may read Simon James' "The Atlantic Celts - Ancient People or Modern Invention?" and John Collis' "The Celts = Origins, Myths and Inventions" to catch up on how Britons and Celts only got conflated due to Romanticism in the Victorian Age. Also read Patrick Sims-Williams "An Alternative to Celtic from the East and Celtic from the West" to find out that "Hallstatt and La Tene" were never Celtic. Finally, read Hübner for a calm and slow explanation of why only in Iberia are ancient people found who actually called themselves Celts by tribal name and personal name all over epigraphic evidence such as hundreds of tombstones, votive altars and personal ceramic items, all bearing the name "Celt" with various suffixes, which is a mark of local, native, original naming, not of a foreign people having arrived. I hope this helps. If it helps you think about it: the problem is there is no ancient object nor ancient text linking Britons to the name "Celts". On the other hand Iberia is littered with ancient tombstones with exactly that name followed by various different suffixes, all native and all shared with Lusitanian. They are actually all found in Lusitania, the place that academics love to tell us "was not Celtic". However you may read Hübner and learn that they were wrong.
    1
  34.  @popandy2956  The English are usually half and half, half Briton half Saxon. Your DNA results are just breaking it down differently.
    1
  35. @ Unless you're from Iberia you're not a Celt. If you're from Britain or Ireland you're a Briton or Gael.
    1
  36. @ Source: Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft, 1839-1861, entry Celtici. You're welcome.
    1
  37.  @Alektoum  That's not an argument.
    1
  38. Exactly, the ads here on YouTube already illustrate this issue, it is a true brainwashing.
    1
  39. The first flight is recognized by the Federation Aeronautique Internationale as having been done in France by a Brazilian named Alberto Santos-Dumont. His flight was the first made by a powered heavier-than-air machine. Before the Wright brothers, there were planes stable enough to fly but without full controllability. The Wright brothers invented the opposite: a fully controllable flyer that sacrificed stability; it also needed to take off into a headwind; but it was so unstable that it was "almost unmanageable by anyone but the Wrights, who had trained themselves in the 1902 glider hundreds of times prior". The plane by Santos-Dumont was both stable and fully controllable and could take off like a normal plane.
    1
  40. "The right and the left are the same" says the midwit.
    1