Comments by "" (@jboss1073) on "OpenMandriva : The Non-Woke Linux Distro?" video.
-
5
-
3
-
3
-
@GeorgeZackrison " Many modern French derive their genetics from Germanic tribes,"
Yes, northern French.
" a unique exception is Brittany who are legitimately a Celtic culture and genetic group."
No, they are legitimately Briton, not Celtic. They have never been called Celtic in history. Only academic linguists after 1800s called their language "Celtic" - not their ethnicity nor their historical past names.
"Welsh are likely the most pure insular Celtic people who exist today. "
No, they are the most pure insular Briton people who exist today. They also were never historically called Celts.
"By Celts do you mean Gauls?"
By Celts I mean the people who actually called themselves Celts in their own tombstones and votive altars and ceramic items: the western Iberians and the southern French in Narbo and Massalia (ancient city names) up to the central French in Auvergne.
"Gauls survived in Briton (and a tiny amount in Turkey, Spain, and Brittany) after the Romans committed genocide against them."
No, you're confused. Gauls only survived in France and elsewhere in continental Europe but not in Iberia, as they never called themselves Gauls, but they did call themselves variously Celti, Celtici, Celtiati, Celtiatici.
Don't confuse "people who called themselves Celts in Roman times" with "people who post-1800s academic linguists started calling Celtic-speakers and the public thought that meant they were the ancient Celts which they were never".
2
-
@RemnantDiscipleLazzaro-Rev1217 There is too much misinformation on Celts due to British Romanticism and their Victorian Age. This is documented by Simon James in "The Atlantic Celts - Ancient People or Modern Invention?" and by John Collis in "The Celts - Origins, Myths and Inventions". The old theory that "Celts = Hallstatt and La Tene" was refuted by Patrick-Sims Williams, the President of the International Congress for Celtic Studies, in his paper "An Alternative to Celtic from the East and Celtic from the West", where he shows that Celts did not come from Central Europe during Hallstatt and La Tene eras (their ancestors actually came from Central Europe to Iberia during the Bell Beaker era, but they weren't called Celts yet, but a cognate of Schwabs, as we can see in Sefes being an older name than Celts in western Iberia) and that there is no proof that Hallstatt and La Tene even spoke Celtic. The epigraphic evidence for tombstones and votive altars with names such as Celti, Celtici, Celtiati, Celtigun, Celtiatici, etc, in western Iberia is Antroponimia Indigena de la Lusitania romana by José Maria Vallejo Ruiz, Hispania Epigraphica, Epigraphik-Datenbank Clauss/Slaby and Epigraphic Database Heidelberg. You can check everything I just said in all those sources. I hope you do check them.
1
-
@RemnantDiscipleLazzaro-Rev1217 There is too much misinformation on Celts due to British Romanticism and their Victorian Age. This is documented by Simon James in "The Atlantic Celts - Ancient People or Modern Invention?" and by John Collis in "The Celts - Origins, Myths and Inventions". The old theory that "Celts = Hallstatt and La Tene" was refuted by Patrick-Sims Williams, the President of the International Congress for Celtic Studies, in his paper "An Alternative to Celtic from the East and Celtic from the West", where he shows that Celts did not come from Central Europe during Hallstatt and La Tene eras (their ancestors actually came from Central Europe to Iberia during the Bell Beaker era, but they weren't called Celts yet, but a cognate of Schwabs, as we can see in Sefes being an older name than Celts in western Iberia) and that there is no proof that Hallstatt and La Tene even spoke Celtic. The epigraphic evidence sources for tombstones and votive altars with names such as Celti, Celtici, Celtiati, Celtigun, Celtiatici, etc, in western Iberia are: 1. Antroponimia Indigena de la Lusitania romana by José Maria Vallejo Ruiz; 2. Hispania Epigraphica; 3. Epigraphik-Datenbank Clauss/Slaby; and 4. Epigraphic Database Heidelberg. You can check everything I just said in all those sources. I hope you do check them.
1
-
@RemnantDiscipleLazzaro-Rev1217 There is too much misinformation on Celts due to British Romanticism and their Victorian Age. This is documented by Simon James in "The Atlantic Celts - Ancient People or Modern Invention?" and by John Collis in "The Celts - Origins, Myths and Inventions".
The old theory that "Celts = Hallstatt and La Tene" was refuted by Patrick-Sims Williams, the President of the International Congress for Celtic Studies, in his paper "An Alternative to Celtic from the East and Celtic from the West", where he shows that Celts did not come from Central Europe during Hallstatt and La Tene eras (their ancestors actually came from Central Europe to Iberia during the Bell Beaker era, but they weren't called Celts yet, but a cognate of Schwabs, as we can see in Sefes being an older name than Celts in western Iberia) and that there is no proof that Hallstatt and La Tene even spoke Celtic.
The epigraphic evidence sources for tombstones and votive altars with names such as Celti, Celtici, Celtiati, Celtigun, Celtiatici, etc, in western Iberia are: 1. Antroponimia Indigena de la Lusitania romana by José Maria Vallejo Ruiz; 2. Hispania Epigraphica; 3. Epigraphik-Datenbank Clauss/Slaby; and 4. Epigraphic Database Heidelberg.
You can check everything I just said in all those sources. I hope you do check them.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1