Comments by "TheSuperappelflap" (@TheSuperappelflap) on "Why California Has So Many Problems" video.

  1. 10
  2. 4
  3. 3
  4. 2
  5. 1
  6. The real problem is the geography. Its simply not economically feasible to go and live in a place that is in the middle of nowhere globally, is extremely expensive to import or export anything to, has an arid climate and rapidly dwindling aquifers due to overly intensive farming, and doesnt have much to redeem it in terms of natural resources now that the gold and oil have mostly dried up. If I import something from the east coast of the USA to Europe its already very expensive. And thats not on me because I can literally see the smoke from the largest harbour on the continent from my house. Importing something from the west coast of the USA would be even more expensive. Importing something from China costs me 1 euro in shipping compared to the 20 to 50 euro it costs to import a single item from the States. To make California work it would need to become an autarky that is completely capable of supplying its own needs, without relying on global trade, because you cant compete in that market. That would mean being self sufficient in production of water, food, electricity, fuel, clothes, etc. I dont think its going to work. As a side note, American states are far more integrated than European states. Theyre not comparable. European countries are basically sovereign nations, except we have 1 European parliament that makes laws and policies that nations implement on either a voluntarily or obligatory basis, depending on the type of regulation. And there is a supreme court that can overrule national courts in case the EU laws are being violated, or human rights are being violated, or in cases of corruption and unfair competition through illegal tax exemptions, and technical stuff like that. Oh, and we have the European central bank that sets rent targets for banks. Now, I know those things also apply to the US, except for the human rights part because you guys dont recognize those, but your states have far more integration than that. Each of these nations in Europe has their own army, their own foreign policy, and their own completely independent finance ministries. If France wants to bomb Syria, or fuck around with economic policies in Africa, they dont need permission from the EU government to do that. If some country wants to implement disastrous fiscal policies that destroy their economy for decades to come (looking at you Greece) there is no mechanism to reign in control until they default on their loans and the wealthy northern nations have to bail them out. We dont have an FBI or CIA that is a federal organisation, each country has its own national police force and intelligence agencies, which cooperate, or dont, at their own leasure. You could say Interpol would be our equivalent to the FBI but Interpol is a global organisation, not a European one. States in the EU are also allowed to secede at will, as the UK has recently done. States are also free to have their own currency or join the euro. We have always had our own independent electricity and fuel production and only recently have started to integrate our grids so that we can use solar power from Spain when the sun is shining there and hydro power from Norway when the snow melts. And you cant ignore the language issue, every EU decree has to be published in something like 28 officially recognized languages, and nobody wants to switch their entire culture and education system to English, except for the Dutch of course, because we were already doing that anyway to increase access to international markets and increase appeal for our universities and companies for English speakers. The federal government in the USA has far more control over the states, or to put it in other terms, states rights in Europe are far less limited than in the US. We just got around to implementing a federal border control agency because the boat "refugee" thing is getting out of hand. And people are talking about integrating into one European army, one finance ministry and one foreign affairs ministry. But so far the people advocating for this are a progressive minority, and the majority of people in each member state is conservative about further integration. In order to justify further integration, a referendum would need to be held in each state so that people can vote on the matter, and so far every time there is such a vote, the answer is basically: "No, thanks, and leave us alone". Its been tried multiple times. Whereas in the US, the country is set up from the start as a federal state and not as a collective of federal states.
    1
  7. 1
  8. 1
  9. 1
  10. 1
  11. 1
  12. 1
  13. 1
  14. 1