Comments by "" (@umwha) on "The Wachowski Effect: Why Creative Talent Declines After Transition (Matrix u0026 Dragon Age Analysis)" video.

Why does transition ruin skills? 1. Hormonal derangement and poisononig (Biochemical) 2. Being a protected class ruins feedback mechanisms (Social) 3. Oppresion paradigm prevents the person from struggling with themselves anymore, rather they will interpret struggles as being the fault of the external world not giving them enough allowances or deference (Psychological) Further I assert that transition being associated with worse functional outcomes (not to mention general health) rather than improved functional outcomes, proves that transition does not unlock the 'true self' or improve the self.
194
40:05 Malcom charitably suggests that the reason trans identified males are sexually aggressive towards women is because 'they learned they had to be aggressive as males, and then once they transitioned they thought women who resist are transphobic'. I disagree with this explanation because it blames rape-culture and social programming - its a blank slate argument. It ignores the natural tendency to sexual aggression males have, even ones who identify as women. What we are really seeing is men who are already sexually aggressive feel that they now have licence now they are seen as 'women'. It also is a framework by which trans-identified males can blame women who reject them for being prejudiced and bigoted, which gives them a social and moral power of coersion against female resistance. Trans identification in heteosexual males is often about increasing your sexual access, removing rules imposed on your sexuality, and evading defense mechanisms of women. Read 'Pronouns are Rohypnol'
67
Malcolm, may I ask why do you choose to go along with trans vocabulary? Such capitulating to call them the Wachowski Sisters. Why do you use that vocab that affirms a concept which isn't true?
7
@ Yes! Because it stifles freedom of thought and critical thinking
6
9:20 - Taash's tone of voice here and big muscular appearance is how your average non-binary female bean beleies themselves to appear. When in reality they are just short, slightly dumpy women with short hair and piercings, but they think they look 'Butch'.
6
she
2
May I ask why Simone is taking estrogen?
1
@ that’s so sad I’m surprised starvation can have such long lasting effects.
1
@ Trans people SAY they feel amazing now yea. When people covert to any religion they claim to feel that their life was saved. Dosent mean it’s true. There are long term studies that show suicide rate dosent change after transition from Sweden.
1
@ when women take testosterone their womb slowly dies and begins to rot inside them, which will eventually kill you due to infection. Tell me again how that’s now poisoning?
1
@cypress2647 I also suggest you look into the effects that being on the pill has on women. Many report problems, 'I came off the pill and It was like I woke up' and issues of mental illness like depression are experienced by some women on the pill. The pill has estorgen and progestin, the same horomnes that trans identified males take.
1
'21:20: 'They now have a femnine brain' . No they don't. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8955456/ Look past the intentional biasing of the title. The study admits that Trans identified males still have brains that are closer to normal male brains by far, than actual female brains.
1
5:20 - The Mother is even tyring to state that their species has a term for 'people who don't match the gender given at birth' but Taash keel lashing out. Even the lines of the Mother, trying to sneak in this idea that this species had nonbinary gender identities, is still propaganda. I like the paper thin attempt to slightly change the phrasing of modern concepts to be a little bit more fantasy: 'given at birth' rather than 'assigned at birth'. UGH
1
Men cant become women. They attempted a sex change and failed.
1