Comments by "Biały" (@Bialy_1) on "Ed Nash's Military Matters" channel.

@leary4 Just stop... you have zero understanding of this topic... Not to mention that low level approach was a bad idea even before proximity fuse development because ships were simply using main guns to just shot into water and planes were crashing into wall of water created by underwater explosions.
10
To land it you need some grass and grass is growing in all directions... with planes so slow if the wind was heavy then your landing speed in relation to the ground was just significantly slower and you could land on something much smaller...
8
@hydorah It got nothing to do with globalisation... USA started XX century as the biggest producer of good quality high tech products. Just like now everything is Made in China in old days most of the good quality hardware was produced in USA, now most of stuff is produced in China and quality of stuff "Made in USA" is often very poor.
5
@jacobmccandles1767 For me its clear he mispronounce it intentionally... And next time educate yourself about the topic before you start acting like a smart-ass (< That's how you spell it, typically...). There was nothing nice or polite in your misinformation quest.
4
Engine will be giving radar reflection... and night flying is only for experienced pilots not for poorly trained kamikaze.
3
@BigLisaFan "Probably not, but not every German was bad either, at least some tried to maintain a sense of decency in a time of great evil." Multiple cities with zero military presence in them were leveled to the ground in the very first day of the WW2, pease be so nice and tell us names of the German pilots that for example refused to drop boombs on Wieluń. Who exactly said "No there is a hospital with huge red cross on the roof i will not gonna drop bomb on that target"... „Hit the Poles so hard that they despair of their life; I have full sympathy with their condition, but if we want to survive, we can only exterminate them; the wolf, too, cannot help having been created by God as he is, but people shoot him for it if they can.“ — Otto von Bismarck And yea Otto is huge German hero to this very day and this quote is from his private letter to his sister...
3
@alijaffarov5069 "We are not Poland" You are right when Berlin was failing there was only Soviet and Polish flag flying over Berlin, so many historical illiterates here that taking all the tknowledge about WW2 from Hollywood movies... https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plik:Polish_flag_1945_Berlin.jpg btw. I wonder why there is no mention in all that movies about for example Polish soldiers kicking Afrika Korps out of that region of the world and how all soldiers of well know minority deserted when Polish army was in Palestine... Polish soldierds were fighting with Germans in Soviet Union, Africa, Italy, UK, France, Belgium and in the end in Germany. When Bismarck battleship sunk HMS Hood the first ship that found him and opened fire on him was Polish ORP Piorun, British headquaters were so scared that it will be Polish victory that they ordered ORP Piorun to go back to the port with excuse that they are low on fuel(as somehow British admirals were able to use 6th sense to detect amount of fuel in ship thousands km awey and also they were able to tell that all the shots from ORP Piorun missed the target, Polish sailors were reporting that they saw hits but again British 6th sense is superior to the eyewitness that was actualy there). Go and watch more Hollywood movies, for example "The intimidation game" a oscar wining movie about breaking Enigma code without three Polish mathematicians that actually did it in 1932(Henryk Zygalski, Jerzy Różycki and Marian Rejewski).
2
@JohnSmith-pl2bk That weapon range was only 150m... the engine power here is incomparably greater, and the fuel has much greater power... Mi-24 can stop from full speed to zero if he fires all of his 128 S-5 rocket 57mm tubes at once... and this is over 10 tons of mass doing over 200km/h... -> this pods are shaped into a cone to minimize aerodynamic drag...
2
"Read a book about a Luftwaffe pilot. His CO asked if he could shoot a man in a parachute and he said no. " LoL Luftwaffe pilots started this war with droping boombs on cities with no military targets...so stop reading idiotic German propaganda. You wana read about Luftwaffe pilots? Then read the conversations of German pilots POW when they were talking to other Germans unaware that the whole conversation is recorded. Allies got 100,000 of pages of this conversations and from them it is clear that yor story is strange, only posibility that it may be true is the fact that Germans started to act diffrently when they were aware that the war is lost and they gonna need to end up as an POW. Most of the German war crimes were in the central and East Europe and in 1945 you can read about all the worst criminals runing awey from the East front just to be POW of American or British soldiers... in hope that they will be as missguided as you. "Soldaten: On Fighting, Killing and Dying. The Secret World War II Transcripts of German POWs" written by German historian Sönke Neitzel and German psychologist Harald Welzer... they are trying to find excuses for German crimes and how how much fun Germans got when they were commiting them. Example from the book. The pilot(of ju 88 most likely) got 32 boombs and Polish city with street full of civilians, he is saying to other German how mad he is that he only droped few boombs before he was shot down because he wanted to kill hudereds of random Polish people that never did anything to him... Another example: Pilot of the stuka boomber in first week of the war droped by accident boomb not on Train station but on some civilian building, he was not happy the first day. As he said the second day when he did the same he did not care. Third day he started to have fun... https://youtu.be/Qvs7RnF73qs First weeks of the war and most of the crimes on this photo were made by your "honorable Luftwaffe pilots"...
2
@RedXlV Mi-24 can stop from full speed to zero if he fires all of his 128 S-5 rocket 57mm tubes at once... and this is over 10 tons of mass doing over 200km/h...
2
these two things cannot be compared...
1
@christopherneufelt8971 "USSR had also vast resources and serfs to feed the cannons" actualy Germany got plenty of resources from its ally the USSR, you know the country where Germany was training tank commanders(Panzerschule Kama - Kazan, Soviet Union), pilots -> Lipetsk fighter-pilot school and there was even a gas warfare facility, Gas-Testgelände Tomka. In 1939 and 1940 German war machine was fueled by Soviet oil, build out of Soviet metals and crews were trained in Soviet Union. Also in 1940 millions of slave workers were working for you and considering that Germany was so into looting all over the Europe that you managed to steal during that short period of time 1,5 million pieces of art i also wonder where did you managed to find all that time needed to commit all that real war crimes... The only good and reassuring thing here is that you guys managed to not learn anything from these two lost world wars and you are as usualy 100% sure that you did amazing job...🙃
1
@Thekilleroftanks "this wouldve been an absolute nightmare for any gunner to rearm." its kinda funny that you wrote this long comment on the basis o your complete ignorance as you managed to not notice that the engines are in wings so you have full access to the 20mm and can easly reload them or solve jamming issues... Not to mention that in your mind there were clearly at that time German planes that could take hundreds of 20mm projectiles and not sufer any critical damage... 🤣
1
@LuvBorderCollies Master O' None pointed very good question, you on the other hand are trying to change subject and claiming that pilots do not take responsibility for own actions... Germans during WW2 got plenty of anty air on the ground and big heavy boomber was an easy target. So boombers were most of the time not able to see what they are attacking because of the altitude. This whole story is completly different situation and the pilots got much more experience and tools to not do what they did.
1
"Those pilots should have been dealt with severely." heh in Germany? The country that judged that Heinz Reinefarth is inocent and even elected him into parliament? Guy was behind massacre of 200,000-250,000 civilians and did not have any trouble because of it. But lets "severely" punish some pilot that got order to open fire on military plane with military personel in it that was flying over controled by Soviet Air space and doing who knows what...
1
@User3417 The Hispano Aviación HA-1109 and HA-1112 are licence-built versions of the Messerschmitt Bf 109G-2 developed in Spain during and after World War II.
1
@phil3114 "You may want to reread the debate from the start" no need, that whole "debate" is full of false informations. "Dozens of Messerschmitt Bf 109 fighters, including the A, B, C, D, and E variants first saw active service in the Condor Legion against Soviet-supplied aircraft in mid 1937 as a testing ground for the new German fixed-wing fighter plane. The Bf 109 quickly replaced the Heinkel He 51 biplane fighter which suffered many losses during the first 12 months of the conflict. Of the Luftwaffe's Jagdgruppen, 136 Bf 109s were sent to Spain, and 47 of these, including Bf 109Bs, Ds and Es remained behind in service with the Spanish Air Force after the conclusion of the war in 1939" Gibraltar is too small for this whole story to be true, pilot would not be able to enter the plane before this type of planes would leave that tiny area of land and its air space...
1
If your enemmy is using cheap drone to aim his artilery on something expensive then the fact that u using some expensive system to shot it down is not as important anymore... but yes generaly there is lack of systems to shot down cheap drones. Polish company just started testing this https://youtu.be/bRWXxZ76cNg But the 2km effective range is very low and you need other systems for bigger drones.
1