General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Luredreier
NowThis Impact
comments
Comments by "Luredreier" (@Luredreier) on "Carrot vs. Stick: An Analogy for Criminal Legal Systems" video.
We don't really use sticks here in Norway. Neither for prisoners nor for children. Indeed you can lose custody if you slap the bum of a child or punish them. There's other techniques that's promoted by our government.
3
The stick never really help is our experience. Even if someone come out of a prison system and don't reoffend after a prison sentence using a stick they're still not the kind of people you want in your society. Only carrots does that. As for the idea that some can't be rehabilitated, of course not, if you give up on them... Yet we're still going to try with a mass murderer in my country that killed 78 people. If we succeed he will be released.
2
@pat77pat It might not be. But that doesn't mean that there shouldn't be. We do use rehabilitation for everyone in my country, and it works 80% of the time.
1
@pat77pat Also, you're aware that you're using the stick yourself right now with the way you're talking with him, right? Perhaps not the best look when arguing for the carrot...
1
@ademirsegura6307 "ADX"?
1
@ademirsegura6307 Okey thank you. But I'm still at a loss what you meant with the sentence there. Why did you bring up that prison in this thread?
1