Comments by "Leonid Shnaider" (@leon19736) on "" video.

@user-xd2ie5qz2z What is your experience and education in international law. In the Israel Army, on every battalion, there is a layer that specializes in international law. And every action goes via aproval of millitary lawyers that specialize in international law. I believe that those lawers have better knowledge and experience in international law than you
2
@maxpowerii7368 By British law, you can't call someone criminal before court convicted him in crimes. You using the word " criminal" shows your bias against Israel. What is your experience and background in the legal field to call someone criminal? Just because you have this opinion doesn't mean that this is true opinion and legally supported by laws
2
@maxpowerii7368 What is your legal education and experience in international law that you make such a bold claims? What is your proffesional knoledge of Israeli millitary lawers? Every action of Israeli in the war go in accordance with international law. Any other army in the world would kill many more civilians that Israel. Just look at the resent history of the wars. Russians in Mariupol , Rusisans and Syrians in Alepo and in Syria in General where 306 000 civilians were killed, Saudia in Yemen war where 400 000 were killed, Americans and British in battle of fallujah where one third of killed were civilians, bombing by America in Raqqa capital of ISIS where tens of thousands were killed, Russian war in Chechnia where 40 000 children were killed. Any Army in the world would kill many times more civilians than Israel in the war
2
@jonathanbailey1597 "not bias - looking at the unfolding genocide. You are really not living in the same world as the rest of us." You have no idea what is genocide is. You also luck legal education in international law to call some thing genocide. In order for genocide to take place it must be genocidal intent that is lucking in Gaza war. While fighting in Gaza Israel suppply food to Gaza . If Israel indeed wanted to commit genoci there majority of population og Gaza would be dead. Israel keep Palestinian cancer childeren in Israel and provides them with cancer treatment while fighting in Gaza. Before war in Gaza population og gaza doubled last 20 years. Imagine that in the mid of warld war 2 USA and Britain would supply German with food and give medical treatement to its civilians
2
On what law? Just because you wish to do so?
1
@tbitbi4427 It is truth. It is uncomfortable to hear the truth after being brainwashed. Russians hate to hear the truth on war after being brainwashed. You have been brainwashed. And think that what I wrote is a joke
1
@maxpowerii7368 Israel does what it has to do to defend itself from the terrorists that try to kill its citizens. Period. Any country in the world instead of Israel would kill many times more civilians than Israel . Just look at battle of fallujah where Brits and US killed locals and one third were civilians. Unlike Gaza vast majority of civilians in the city evacuated. Unlike Gaza. Or look at Mariupol where Russians killed 30 000 civilains.. Or look at Syria where Russia and Syrian regime killed 306 000 cibilians by UN and where chemical weapons were used. Or look at ISIS capital in Syria Raqqa where tens of thousands of civilians were killed by USA and UK bombing. Or Russian war in Chechnian where 40 000 children were killed. Any country in the world instead of Israel would end up with killing significant higher number of civilians. What is UN. Organisation that refused to condem massive rape on October 7th. Organisation that consists from totalitarian countries Like North Korea, Russia, Belorussia, Turkmenisat, Iran, Iraq, Afganistan, Saudia, Yemen, SOmalia, Syria, Lebanon, Sudan, Kazahstan, Myanmar (Burma), Venesuella, Cuba and many many more. Why Israel should care on what those countries think? Israel does what it has to do to defend itself from the terrorists that try to kill its citizens. Period.
1
@jonathanbailey1597 Do You mean person like Francesca Albanese who wrote the report that Israel conducting genocide. France , Germany , USA called her antisemitic and used extrimelly strong words against her. Her husband is in PLO organisation that called to destroy Israel anf throu Jews into medetiranian sea. And she is absolutly neitral and has no conflict of interests. She also jjustified 7th of October. UN is a big joke for Israel. how many times Israel was condemed for violation of human rights and how many Iran, Syria,China, Saudia, North Korea, Cuba , Venesuella, Russia. How many times Russia was condemed for its war in Ukraine and how many times Israel , despite being attacked first on 7th of October. Did any one condem Russia for killing 40 000 children in Chechnia? Did any one condem Syria and Russian for killing 306 000 civilians. UN gave this number, UN refused to condem for many months massive rape of Israeli woman that took place on 7th of October. Half of UN members refused to condem Russia for invading Ukraine. How Israel can take UN seriously after all facts i listed?
1
@jonathanbailey1597 I just can only reply that many EU countrues and USA after consulting with their layers claimed that there is no genocide in Gaza. There is a war in Gaza and civilians being killed in war. Israel killed 15 000 Hamas militants and when you fighting in a densly populated environment civilians being killed. If Arab countries like EU would give regugee to Palestinians like Eroupe did to Ukranians there would be many times less civilain casulaties. There is absolutly no way to fight in the city when civilians around you without casulaties. Any army in the world would also had simmilar casulaties. Very high chances that ICJ will deny genocide on Gaza despite the fact that Lebanon Judge is in the court - country that indiscriminatly firing missilies on Israeli cities. There are othe judges from totalitarian countries like China, Russia, Somalia and more I didn't see any intent to kill palestinians after watching many interviews with soldiers, officers, reserve soldiers, generals, minister of defence. In current moment of the war majority of Palestinians killed are militants. Which UN organs you mean? UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese who calimed that Israel commitining genicde? France, USA, Germany blamed her for being anti semitic, supporting 7th of October . She deny Israeli right to exist. She was harshly critised by all those 3 countries. She is absolutly neitral person who married to PLO memeber. Organisation that 30 years ago wanted to destroy Israel and put Israeli Jews into Medeteranian Sea. She is absolutly neitral person. And has no conflict of interests. And UN is well aware on how neitral she is and dosn't remove her prom her position
1
@jonathanbailey1597 My coments being removed by Youtube. I will write in short. I watched endless intervires of soldeirs, reserve soldiers, officres, generals, minister of defence, head of the army. Not in one single case i found genocidal intent in their inerviews. Western countries went to their lawers who specialazed in international law and found that there was no genocide in Gaza. Those countries communicated this fact openly on many ocations
1
@jonathanbailey1597 Those declarations were made immidiatly after 7th of October when people were highly emocianal after small Holochost took place. And after millions around the world glorified on the streets this small Holochost. Including on the streets of Western countries. Some of those qoutes were taken out of contest. As exemple word Amalec was used as proof to show that Israel intends to commit genocide. Nobody among Israelis percived when this word was used that Israel planning to commit "genoc". Also word human animals to Palestinians was used to Hamas. Not to all Palestinians. But in any way it is the army that decide how to fight in the war . Not politicions. Or comentators on TV. I didnt see any declarations of soldiers with intent. I did see however endless declaration of soldiers and officers when they try to save civilian lives. I didn't see any declarations on media last few months on the intent. And again Israeli army like any army don't fight based on declaration of media figures. Same like Russians . On Russian TV there was many declarations of "Genoc" on Uranian population by media figures and by ex president of Russia. It was 100 times worst than in Israel( I am Russian speaker and watch some Russian propoganda TV) Does it mean Russia commiting "Genoc" in Ukraine? They bring food and medicine to population of viliges they took over and destroyed. Id doesn't look like "Genoc"
1
Gazans can surrender, and the war (which they started) ends. This is not comparable to “genoci,” in which there is an unprovoked attack and no opportunity for surrender. @jonathanbailey1597
1
@jonathanbailey1597 Gazans can surrender, and the war (which they started) ends. This is not comparable to “genocide,” in which there is an unprovoked attack and no opportunity for surrender.
1
@jonathanbailey1597 My comments being removed again and again. Majority declaration of soldiers in their interviews are about how they try to save innocent civilian lives. Not on intentions of genocide. Same with officers and generals. They all talk on savings civilian lives. You can aleays pick few that contradict and say not nice things. But it will be called manipulation. To pick up some crazy guy and say that this is what vast majority of soldiers, generals, officers say
1