Comments by "Byron" (@byron-ih2ge) on "The Destroyed 4th Century Buddhas of Afghanistan" video.

i still remember that day when taliban blew up these ancient buddhas , every indian who knew about this was shocked to hear this news. they were the last remenants of the indic civilization that once inhabited Afghanistan
21
@HolgerJakobs ya right but buddha was our homeboy so it hits a little differently
2
@elhamhemat572 no thats not true,the ivc had a settlements in afghanistan during its peak but it started in modernday eastern pakistan and western india .
1
@elhamhemat572 what a joke 😂 who is writing all this stuff , they should keep propaganda and history separate from each other , where should i even start first and foremost the people who inhabited the indus valley and were the forefathers or related to modern day dravidians (gene present in the people of south india ) . after the ghagra river(which was the main river of the ivc ) died out the indus valley civilization collapsed and the population dispersed itself everywhere . approximately after a time the aryans came in from the steppes . they intermixed with the local population of south asia ( majorly local tribals and some dravidians too)and had a relatively few intermixing near persia as it was sparsely inhabited .this diverged these aryans into two groups indo aryans and iranians .the indo iranian language when came in contact of local influences of india and persia split into vedic sanskrit and old persian . the proto indo iranian religion diverged into ancient iranian religion which was reformed and and ancient indo aryan religion ,this religion intermixed with local indian beliefs and the remains of what was left of the ivc to form the vedic religion and the vedas were written down near the indus river hence starting the beta version of the indian civilization. this vedic civilization finally mixed with south indians ( dravidians) to form the final form of the beginning of what we know as the Indian civilization today and the vedic religion mixed with the ancient dravidian religion to give us the final form of dharma .pakistan except parts of balochistan has always been indic in nature and even today majority of pakistan is indic in nature . afghanistan has always been a battle ground for the indian civilizationl the persian civilization and other civilizations , in preislamic afghanistan the east and northern parts were closer to india while the rest was closer to persia .after islam came in afghanistan and northwestern pakistan was completely persianised . also the invading turko mongols , persians , etc also mixed in nullyfing any major indian influence .the avestan language a language which was iranic in nature but was closer to sanskrit than old persian as it was always under the influence of the indian civilization is the forefather of the pashto language spoken in afghanistan today
1
@elhamhemat572 indian , persian , turko mongloids and dravidian. these are the four fundamental groups . u wanna believe it or not everyone is in that region is majorly a mix of these four groups. Pakistan is a synthetic country with nothing of its own created for political countries doesnt matter how much they try they remain majorly indic whereas afghanistan is a hybrid of various groups. And they can claim no single identity . they have everything in them . the traditions and culture of the indian civilization are prserved and continue in india the way they continued 4000 yrs ago . moreover people who lived near the indus and across indus were called by the persians as hindus so india isnt the reciever of the title of ancient indian civilization and indus civilization its that itself .
1
@elhamhemat572 the best example to describe all this would be a sapling . the sapling grew up into a huge, majestic and beautiful tree but some of its roots went bad due to some factors so These bad roots were cutoff but it wont affect the tree, the tree will keep its majesty with itself .now if those spoiled roots say hey we are the origination of this magestic tree so we deserve all of this it makes no sense except for themselves
1
@elhamhemat572 aryans were the Caucassian people who migrated from africa 😭, archaeology and history just died a brutal death
1
@elhamhemat572 aryans have nothing to do with the indus valley civilization , they werent the part of indus valley civilization nor did they destroy it
1
@elhamhemat572 buddhism originated in the indus valley r u high on something ?
1
@elhamhemat572 each of these ethnic groups have intermixed with each so seperating them makes no sense
1
@elhamhemat572 i know that but aryans were from steppe and had migrated out of africa thousands of yrs ago
1
@elhamhemat572 ok just tell me one thing even if we debate on this topic the origin doesn't really matter who is presently following the traditions of the Vedic civilization and the indus valley civilization ,where does the sanskrit language still survive its india and where is the ancient way of life in south asia still prominent in india , so the title naturally goes to indians ?end of the story
1
@elhamhemat572 the point of origination would have been a valid argument if there was any conflict but presently pakistanis and afghans have nothing much in commmon with their ancestors india is the sole heir hence india takes the claim moreover how did aryan dravidian all that even come up as a topic here . we are talking about buddhism here , buddhism is completely an indigenous religion of the indian civilization. Hinduism does have complexeties with its origin but there is no doubt about buddhism
1
@elhamhemat572 it makes no sense
1