General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Byron
South China Morning Post
comments
Comments by "Byron" (@byron-ih2ge) on "Egypt unveils 3000-year-old Avenue of Sphinxes at Karnak Temple in Luxor" video.
@firojakhtar4419 no they should return to being Egyptians again and should abandon that fake arab identity that was imposed on them , thats what he meant..
17
Zack Erskine of course thats bound to happen berbers r native to that land unlike arabs , both egyptians and berbers were assimilated into being arabs
6
now revive the coptic language and make it your native tongue then u can indeed call yourselves egypptian instead of just having egyptian as your nationality!!
4
@firojakhtar4419 ahh yes, when u have no argument left so just make a vague comment😂. What r u even saying?
4
@كرديسوري-ج3غ cope
3
Zack Erskine lol hows that posible?? berbers or copts who originallly rsided in north africa werent even black lol, they look closer to indians..
2
@A17-r5w4k French is their lingua franca not native language dont be dumb , they have their own tribal languages.. No matter how much influence coptic has on that dialect, arabic is still arabic!! An absolute majority of it atleast.The parent of Egyptian arabic is quranic arabic not egyptian language pls remember that cause thats a fact which wont change Morever the official language of Egypt is modern standard arabic not even Egyptian arabic!!
2
@A17-r5w4k calling an Egyptian arab an arab is a sin wow , weird world we live in.. Ur seriously getting triggered for no reason..
2
@A17-r5w4k I am not jealous, why would i be jealous to see the real egyptian culture revive?? I am a big admirer of ancient egypt but its about accepting the truth keeping your blood and gentics aside nothing much survives of your ancestors.. And u would be classified in any ethno linguistic survey in this world as arab more accurately" assimilated arab" just like Lebanon or libya
2
@A17-r5w4k frnch is their lingua frnca , arabic is your native tongue understand the difference even in north africa especially in morocco more and more people r becoming native speakers of berber so that would make them berber now!! They r no more arab.. They now speak arabic as their lingua franca nothimg erong in that they would be still called berber But unfortunately unlike them coptic went extinct and untill u dont revive it ur an egyptian arab
2
@A17-r5w4k That dialect excuse is quite useless i must because its just a dialect the casual way , the formal dialect would always remain" modern standard arabic" even egypt's official language is not egyptian arabic but modern standard arabic man i am not imposing anything on you I am just telling you the truth as per technical definations " ur an arab as long as ur native language is arabic"thats a fact u like it or not ... if u wanna be called egyptian then speak coptic as your native tongue . for now you r just an a citizen of the " ARAB" republic of egypt" , an egptian by nationality and an egyptian arab by ethncity.
2
@r.p.5903 whats that
2
Zack Erskine yep exactly thanks for admitting history the way it is we dont need to add any prejudices to that
2
@كرديسوري-ج3غ i nvr commented on that topic dont make a fool of yourself
2
Zack Erskine ya ue right but i think its going a revival morocco has berber as a co fficial language now and berber identity is also rising up in the rest of north africa.. Now egyptian arabs too are slowly distancing themselves from there arab identity and going back their real egyptian identity..
2
@A17-r5w4k man labelled something else?? Your nation is literally called the " ARAB REPUBLIC OF EGYPT!!" Thats its official name!
1
@A17-r5w4k i dont say that!! Why don't u understand me pls understand the meaning of the word" assimilation"
1
@A17-r5w4k as i said dialects dont matters cause dialects r dialects there is known standardised arabic dialect!! There is only one standard arabic and thats modern standard arabic that is what is used for all formal purposes
1
@A17-r5w4k man even the flag of your country is 100 percent arab theme , ur evry inch an egyotian arab, an egyptian whose ancestors were assimilated by arabs ,now u wanna deny the truth then so be it
1
@A17-r5w4k pls read the word" assimilation" thats why ur assimilated arabs . Genetically turks arent even turks those guys were assimilated by conquering turkic people.. Just like u were assimilated by the arabs durimg their conquest
1
@samyebeid4534 ya they r hispanics . thats what evrybody calls them . They don't claim to be native mexicans..
1
@A17-r5w4k egyptian is today majorly a liturgical language for coptic Christians not anyone's native language thats a fact
1
@A17-r5w4k man a dialect is still a dialect , as long as ur a native speaker of arabic u will be called an arab not an egyptian and genetics dont matter, thats the reason why egyptians are called " assimilated arabs'
1
Zack Erskine are u from the region?
1
@A17-r5w4k man these egyptian revivalist mentality has kicked just about 2 decades ago before that for a 1000+ yrs u called urself arab!! The last egyptian died in 17th century
1